Germany and Russia must coordinate on Israel/Iran crisis

Brilliant article by Daniel Lazare at Consortium News. The few parts I have not included are also worth reading.

Trump’s Iran Debacle: What Will Germany and Russia Do?
May 11, 2018

It falls to Germany to save the Iran nuclear deal and try to prevent a devastating new Middle East War, argues Daniel Lazare.

By Daniel Lazare Special to Consortium News

In the wake of Donald Trump’s thoroughly unsurprising decision to scuttle the Iran nuclear accord, two countries that may be most in the hot seat are Germany and Russia. The big question now is whether their mutual discomfort leads them to find common cause.

Angela Merkel’s plight is especially painful. Not only are Germany’s extensive business links with Iran at risk thanks to Trump’s decision to re-apply sanctions, but the German chancellor’s political fortunes have taken a beating thanks to years of American incompetence in the Middle East.

In Libya, then-Secretary of State Hillary Clinton devoted two weeks during the 2011 Arab Spring to persuading Qatar to join the anti-Gaddafi coalition, only to stand by and watch as the oil-rich emirate seized the opportunity to distribute some $400 million to murderous Salafist rebels spreading anarchy from one end of the country to the other. The result was a failed state that soon turned into a jumping-off point for hundreds of thousands of desperate refugees making their way to Germany and other parts of the European Union.

Remarkably, Clinton did the same thing a few months later in Syria by teaming up with Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and other Arab gulf states to fund what would soon become a full-scale Islamist invasion. The upshot: more murder and mayhem, more refugees, and more terrorism when ISIS – funded by the Saudis and Qataris according to no less an authority than Clinton herself – decided to extend its jihad to Paris, Brussels, Nice, Manchester, Barcelona, and Berlin starting in November 2015. As if that weren’t enough, Washington irritated its German partners by opposing the Nord Stream II natural gas pipeline, a Russo-German project headed by ex-Chancellor Gerhard Schröder, and then, under Trump, by pulling out of the Paris climate accords last June…

… But Germany is not the only one feeling the pain – Russia is too. It is allied with Iran in support of Syria’s embattled president Bashar al-Assad, yet has somehow managed to maintain good relations with Israel. This is why Putin invited Benjamin Netanyahu to be his personal guest at this week’s May 9 Victory Day celebrations in Moscow where the Israeli prime minister joined Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic in laying a wreath on the Soviet Tomb of the Unknown Soldier. When Putin paid tribute to the Soviet troops “who saved Europe and the world from slavery, from the horrors of the Holocaust,” by defeating Nazi Germany (quote begins at 2:00), there was no doubt as to whom he was addressing.

But the celebration also featured a traditional Red Square military parade featuring not only unmanned robo-tanks and Sukhoi Su-57 stealth fighters, but mobile batteries of anti-aircraft missiles. Less than twelve hours later, Netanyahu showed his thanks by destroying at least five Russian-made anti-aircraft batteries as part of the assault on Syria. According to the Israeli military, Israel notified Russia of the impending attack via “deconfliction” procedures in place since September 2015 – which means that Russia more or less assented to the destruction of its own defense systems.

It’s Up to Germany

This can’t go on, especially with Israel intervening ever more heavily on the side of pro-Al Qaeda rebels whom Russia, Iran, and Syria are trying to repel. The more the battle intensifies, the more impossible Putin’s position will become…

… It would be a dangerous leap into the unknown on the part of a country that couldn’t be more risk averse. But Germany may have no choice. Trump is nuts, American power is receding more rapidly than anyone would have thought possible two or three years ago, while western liberalism is crumbling as well. Hardliners are in control in Washington where Republicans and Democrats compete to see who can be more obsequious to Israel and more hostile to all things Russian. The same goes for Tel Aviv and Tehran where, thanks to Trump, the hardliners are equally in the saddle.

If there are two countries that know what can happen when the crazies are in control, it’s Russia and Germany. But now that history has placed them in the same boat as it approaches the cataracts, Putin, for one, is rowing madly. Will Merkel lend a hand with the oars?

12 users have voted.


mimi's picture

for President Trump. It's not often that a German Chancellor speaks that clear of a language. So, it was all over the evening news here.
Merkel rips Trump for leaving Iran deal: Move 'undermines trust in the international order'

German Chancellor Angela Merkel is criticizing President Trump’s decision to pull the U.S. out of the Iran nuclear deal, saying it “undermines trust in the international order.”

Merkel made the comment while addressing an audience at a Catholic conference in Muenster, according to Tass.

“I believe it is wrong to unilaterally tear up the agreement, which was agreed on and which was unanimously approved by the U.N. Security Council," Merkel said.

On Thursday, Merkel said Europe can no longer count on the U.S. to protect it.
“It is no longer such that the United States simply protects us, but Europe must take its destiny in its own hands. That's the task of the future," she said.

The way she sounded in German was very clear. Nothing weaseling about it. With Putin she will have a Kaffeeklatsch and some Sachertorte and vodka afterwards. That will do it. Wink
It's so serious an issue I can only make some banal joke about it. I hope you understand...

I somehow stumbled over the wording in this paragraph:

Germany has real clout with regard to the Jewish state. (me: really, I think not) It is Israel’s biggest trading partner in Europe and, after the US, its second largest trading partner overall.(me: There are other things the are more influential in the German-Israel relations, and that's our past history with each other) It is an important cultural and scientific partner, while Berlin, in one of history’s more delectable ironies, is now home to one of Israel’s largest expatriate communities, some 15,000 Jews and Arabs who find life in the German capital freer and more vibrant than back home and, as a consequence, have peppered it with Hebrew-language kindergartens, a Hebrew library, a Hebrew literary magazine, a Hanukkah market, and Iranian-Israeli techno parties.

It's not an irony, imho, it's the passing of time and the second generation after wwwII taking on the rudder, and they are a little less traumatized than the elder generations, and can enjoy "The Berliner Luft". Says an old Berlin girl...

bygone times and bygone songs... sounds very German, doesn't it?

I hear my mother whistling to that melody. Heh, Berlin had always been a "special place" in my family's heart and mind. All my parent and grandparents were Berliners and made it through wwwI and wwII. Nevertheless even today sometimes the "Berliner Luft" (Berlin Air) can blow away our always present suffocating, depressing, stinking past.

And Merkel ain't that comfortable dancing on the eggshells. So, I think, she won't.

5 users have voted.


for this reassuring response! I hope so very much that common sense begins to assert itself. A country that exports war and suffering cannot be a leader. It can only be what President Eisenhower called our military industrial complex, the Merchants of Death.

3 users have voted.