Classic Diaries: Four reasons to anticipate postcapitalism
Author's note: this diary was published 25 September of last year -- still relevant today!
You know, postcapitalism -- the coming period of existence after the capitalist system has run its course, after Bernie Sanders' "political revolution" has outstripped Sanders' current promises, and brought us to a world in which we can actually do something about our situation without dragging around the profits system like a giant millstone?
Throughout history, people did things because "society" (which usually meant the elites or other gatekeepers) demanded it. Capitalism didn't change this pattern. The end of capitalism will be another chance, taken or not, to bring into being a society in which people do things for the actual reasons they needed to be done. So, with postcapitalism:
1) Medical law will be about health, not profit. Remember Martin Shkreli? The most alarming thing to consider about his guy is that he's just a symptom of patent law. Presumably medicines are created to save lives -- and after capitalism is finished, maybe they can do that.
On a larger scale, of course, the bias of medical law toward profit shows up as the ACA -- a bill which offers a few benefits to a few people, lowering the uninsured rate about 40% while at the same time insurance remains a gamble. The law was of course written to avoid the bad outcome predicted in John Geyman's 2009 book Do Not Resuscitate -- a book which predicted that the insurance gatekeepers industry was pricing health care out of affordability and that the whole system would at some point suffer a crash. The ACA was, of course, the Band-Aid which postponed that outcome.
Postcapitalist health care will, of course, be about healing, not about making money. Single-payer, as promised by candidate Sanders, will go a long way toward that end -- but even with single-payer (such as we can see with recent "reform" to Medicare) there will be profit-seeking vultures looking to carve money out of the system at the expense of the general health.
2) Food will be about feeding hungry people. Today, as Tony Weis points out in The Ecological Hoofprint, food is about growing a lot of grain so "farmers" can feed it to a lot of tortured animals who are crowded in tiny spaces and, eventually, slaughtered to produce food. Both society and nature foot the bill for this monstrosity, a fundamental part of a system which produces enough food to feed 12 billion people while nearly half the human race is either overfed or undernourished.
Oh, sure, there are still those things which we used to call farms -- but for the most part they're marginalized, being either subsistence plots in rural backwaters or boutique farms in hipster communities. Maybe after capitalism is finished we can all live on one, and (thanks to the evolving science of agroecology) live rather well.
3) We will actually be able to do something about climate change. In the promo for last year's landmark volume This Changes Everything, author Naomi Klein had something important to say about why the capitalist system gets in the way of efforts to "save the climate":
Elsewhere, Klein takes on Richard Branson for failing to live up to his promise to set aside $3bn to fight climate change. “So much hope was put in this parade of billionaires to try and reconcile capitalism with climate,” she says. “When Branson entered the climate game, he posited it specifically as an alternative to regulation. He said ‘the governments aren’t going to do this, we’re going to do this. Go to the UN climate summit in a couple of weeks and it’s all going to be the new green economy and the head of Bank of America sitting down with the president of Mexico – and we are all going to do it together.’” She remains irritated. “That is a dangerous idea at this stage of history. We now have two decades to measure that model. We are not talking about a theory here, we are talking about a track record. I think it’s fair to say: ‘OK, we tried it your way and we don’t have another decade to waste.”
So rich folks are going to pretend to save the climate as long as we let them, or as long as their concurrent efforts to sew up the world economy for big capitalists through "trade agreements" will let them. The track record is that they've accomplished next to nothing outside of their own megalomaniacal lust for profits.
What's needed is a global agreement to keep the grease in the ground while promoting solar and wind power for human need (as opposed to capitalist greed). The regime of value, dominated by interlocking directorates and the vast guarantees of value offered to oil companies for their reserves, will not let this happen. Bill McKibben:
If you told Exxon or Lukoil that, in order to avoid wrecking the climate, they couldn't pump out their reserves, the value of their companies would plummet. John Fullerton, a former managing director at JP Morgan who now runs the Capital Institute, calculates that at today's market value, those 2,795 gigatons of carbon emissions are worth about $27 trillion. Which is to say, if you paid attention to the scientists and kept 80 percent of it underground, you'd be writing off $20 trillion in assets.
An economy based on need, rather than greed, doesn't worry about sick jokes like "$20 trillion in assets." It's time, as Kim Stanley Robinson pointed out, to end the multigenerational Ponzi scheme.
4) Education would no longer be about making money. The secret is out about this one: nobody really goes to college anymore to know anything -- what's important is getting a credential so you can get a higher-paying job. David F. Labaree has made a career out of discussing this: so, for instance, you can read "How To Succeed In School Without Really Learning," about the history of the memorize, regurgitate, and forget routine, and you can also read "Someone Has To Fail," about how education in America has been the consequence of the public demand for credentials.
What has happened on a larger scale, of course, is that we live in a society in which nobody really cares to know anything unless it makes them some money. The social consequences of such a reality are of course, a politically-disengaged and socially-alienated world. The economics of such a society are rather simple -- there are only so many good jobs, yet the colleges can generate endless numbers of credentials. The market value of each credential, then, is bound to decline, while at the same time aggregate national student loan debt now exceeds $1.2 trillion. College by such a standard has become pointless. Attend, or don't attend; you won't learn anything meaningful either way.
Ending capitalism will allow school to, once again, be primarily about knowledge rather than knowledge being something in the mix of school priorities. This is important because in the search for ways to "save the climate" (Naomi Klein's term), to change the food system, and to heal the sick, we'll need all the knowledge we can get.
As we can see with Bernie Sanders' Presidential campaign, a "political revolution" must start with:
re-establishing the principle that the working class should get something from government outside of the police state, the military, the "free market," and the value of money.
Must we see the video again? Okay.
We can't stop, then, at some little hedge or two against the power of money. We need a society in which the power of money isn't bringing everything to ruin -- a postcapitalist society. Feeling the Bern, then, is a good start.
Comments
Great read Cassiodorus
I guess there will be an existence after the parasite destroys it's host --I like your positive outlook for when that eventually happens.
There is nothing which I dread so much as a division of the republic into two great parties.. This...is to be dreaded as the greatest political evil under our Constitution.--John Adams
Here's an analogous way of explaining it:
“When there's no fight over programme, the election becomes a casting exercise. Trump's win is the unstoppable consequence of this situation.” - Jean-Luc Melanchon
and this
Remember the good old days when you asked a child what they wanted to be and they chose something they wanted to do, not what would enrich them the most. Farmer, fireman, truck driver--all answers from little children who aren't yet polluted by greed.
There is nothing which I dread so much as a division of the republic into two great parties.. This...is to be dreaded as the greatest political evil under our Constitution.--John Adams
Limitless options
My little one's two most recent career goals are garbage man and artist. I suggested to him that the day job/night job scenario might allow both. He was pleased.
God I love this comment.
There is nothing which I dread so much as a division of the republic into two great parties.. This...is to be dreaded as the greatest political evil under our Constitution.--John Adams
I honestly look forward to more expensive but better tasting
meat.
For anybody who's never had Kosher meat, it DOES taste better. Add in the fact that people don't NEED to eat meat every meal...
I'm actually looking forward to changing my habits a bit. Different isn't always bad.
I do not pretend I know what I do not know.
I can offer suggestions for alternate protein sources
I've been a vegetarian for many years... after my 2nd child was born. (I craved red meat when I was pregnant, tbh). Anyhow, it's not hard.
Don't believe everything you think.
I'm also a vegetarian
though others don't have to be -- & in that regard I would urge everyone to look at Tony Weis's book The Ecological Hoofprint...
“When there's no fight over programme, the election becomes a casting exercise. Trump's win is the unstoppable consequence of this situation.” - Jean-Luc Melanchon
beans beans the magical fruit!
the more you eat the more you toot!
Legume + grain = a more absorbpable protein than a steak!
Don't eat too much dairy though.
Some cuisines are naturally veg/vegan like south indian.
Enjoy all the fruits of Gaia!
Eat stinging nettles too!
They're everywhere this time of year and they've got lots of essential calcium, potassium, iron, vitamins A and B6...
“When there's no fight over programme, the election becomes a casting exercise. Trump's win is the unstoppable consequence of this situation.” - Jean-Luc Melanchon
I don't think I could ever be a full vegetarian...
I like my salami and pepperoni too much.
However, I freely admit that it wouldn't kill me to eat more vegetables than I do.
I do not pretend I know what I do not know.
The hardest thing will be to
convince people that they just may have to sacrifice somethings that they now take for granted...or will have to pay more for it.
For instance, the best way to "keep the grease in the ground" is to STOP USING IT.
Please help the Resilience Resource Library grow by adding your links.
First Nations News
As I'm arguing in a forthcoming paper --
Our aggregate diet for energy will be vastly reduced once we switch over to a union of free producers. Think of all of the energy consumed merely to prop up the society of money -- energy consumed getting goods to markets where people have money (rather than using them where people need the goods). Think of all of the professions which don't produce anything but which continue to use up the world's energy upon tasks of extracting money.
It's not as if the privileged folks of the world really need to consume 93 million barrels of oil every day -- what they need, of course, is to make a buck, so the barrels are consumed.
“When there's no fight over programme, the election becomes a casting exercise. Trump's win is the unstoppable consequence of this situation.” - Jean-Luc Melanchon
I have said this many times but it bears
repeating ... the ideology of money -- not just capitalism, but money itself -- is the cruellest belief system ever visited upon humanity.
We are enslaved by it and it's not even REAL!
Why do we do it?
Like the elephant bound by a string because that elephant believes the string is a chain ... we are chained by our own belief systems, including the one in which we MUST have MONEY to EXIST.
It's ridiculous. But I can't opt out by myself.
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Post capitalism
Pfizer is leaving the USA to avoid paying $35Billion it owes in taxes. The company will be headquartered in Ireland where the corporate income tax rate is less.
Pfizer charges 12 times, on average, for its medicines in the USA as it does in Ireland.
Since the only imperative of monopoly capital is to grow and profit, there will come a time when it reaches its limits. I think it has now reached its limit. There is worldwide overcapacity and the financialization of capital is a symptom of a stagnating system. Global capital would fail if it weren't backed by the US military and NATO which paves the way to the exploitation of the global south. Capitalism treats nature, the biosphere, as a free dumping ground for its enormous waste products and a free source of raw materials. With climate change, the system has put itself into a setting where it will kill off a living planet in order to meet its growth at-all-costs imperative.
Humanity must move to a system of sustainability that nurtures the planet instead of destroying it. There are models to follow that have proved to be long term successes. We must end the greedheads' rule where "if you're not cheating, you're not trying hard enough" is the slogan.
"The justness of individual land right is not justifiable to those to whom the land by right of first claim collectively belonged"
Where are we going AND how do we get there?
Excellent essay. I like how you melded the political revolution, of which the Sanders campaign is a step, with a vision of four key features of a post-capitalist society. Great work.
The forces of divide and rule are aligned against Sanders, and the struggle against those forces is epic. Clinton is part of the divide-and-rule system. The U.S. unofficial two-party oligarch-controlled lesser-of-two evils electoral system is a major tool of divide and rule. I reluctantly believe that a takeover of the Democratic Party is the best approach.
The Democrats could just as well descend --
back into the "lesser of two evils" trip they've been on for the past forty years. Then they take over you. Kerry for President! Give more war a chance! You do realize that the historical record does not support the "take over the Democratic Party" strategy, right?
I really don't see why the Bernie people couldn't just be a party in their own right.
“When there's no fight over programme, the election becomes a casting exercise. Trump's win is the unstoppable consequence of this situation.” - Jean-Luc Melanchon
I'm on the fence.
I'm fairly well aware of the history of the parties, including third parties. Maybe you're right.
Since there's no standard for political success --
everyone just trades ideas.
“When there's no fight over programme, the election becomes a casting exercise. Trump's win is the unstoppable consequence of this situation.” - Jean-Luc Melanchon
Let the party go ....
it's time for fresh ideas and a new system! At the very least, a strong third party, which is what the Bernie movement basically is.
Who the hell wants to be a Democrat anyway? And be associated with that corruption? I know I sure as hell don't.
Let the Clinton's take it down and they and their supporters can rot within the corrupt party system, who cares?
The oligarchy is going down one way or another, and the best way for all concerned is by way of a political revolution.
WHO NEEDS DEMOCRATS?
I'm for unemotional analysis on this.
There's a reason Corbyn stayed with Labour. Which is not to say it's not complicated and messy: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/mar/21/with-the-tory-party...
And as I implied above, third parties in the U.S. have it much tougher. But I'm not fixed in my opinion and think the discussion must go forward.
Stuff and Shelf-Space
Balance that and you solve a lot of problems.
1. Stuff - Most of us have too much stuff. At least in the west.
2. Shelf-Space - How do you replace stuff? Use other 'real' stuff, or new or old virtual 'stuff.' (Note the pairs of ' ' - they are used on purpose.)
3. Free - 'Free' has a cost. How to value that.
I've been focusing on those in Midnight Mulling, so stay up late and join. Discuss postcapitalism while you are there.
4. Not much talk about leisure yet. But all the things mentioned up-thread aim at massive leisure - or its opposite.
best, john
Strange that a harp of thousand strings should keep in tune so long
Everyone has the same amount of stuff --
It's "value" (using the definition to be found in Marx) that the privileged people hoard. "Negative value," as Jason W. Moore defined it, is foisted off on the poor.
“When there's no fight over programme, the election becomes a casting exercise. Trump's win is the unstoppable consequence of this situation.” - Jean-Luc Melanchon
How about if Progressives
were to join forces with all of the smaller, less viable parties?
Please help the Resilience Resource Library grow by adding your links.
First Nations News
post capitalism or death
is inevitable; however, how we imagine post capitalism is probably very different. I think we need many different experiments with alternative currencies and a cultural understanding about owning the resources of the earth in common.
May the dolphins, whales and furry things inherit the world. Humans, unless we do an about face, have just about proven we don't deserve this beautiful planet.
Post Capitalism
I think that if we survive as a species the ultimate economic/political system will not be Capitalism. Capital, by its nature, is a social resource. No one can accumulate it with just their hard work. It's purpose is social, to invest in the future for all of the people. The fact that it is controlled by a few individuals is both wrong from the social justice standpoint, but also far from optimum. The claim that only individuals can make good decisions about how to use capital is to completely dismiss human intelligence and replace it with human greed.
The problem up to now is that running a large society is complex. Any systems to replace Capitalism have been too simplistic, e.g. Marxism. Capitalism claims that you can replace analysis and design with a number of greedy actors. When we do figure out how to replace it with a system that actually is both fair and optimum we will look at Capitalism with complete astonishment, that we ever considered it as a reasonable solution.
Capitalism has always been the rule of the people by the oligarchs. You only have two choices, eliminate them or restrict their power.
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Whenever I hear of something good not being done
Because it "costs too much" I become furious. That is not a reason, it's an excuse. Money is not real, people are.
Enjoy every sandwich. (ripwz)
Excellent diary! Thanks for reposting it.
www.RayPensador.com
When you boil it all down, the number one step you can take to get out from under the fascist boot of the oligarchy is to stop subjecting yourself to the the U.S. corporate news media. It is a powerful psyops weapon.