Shakespeare on transgender

 photo DTempest-2609_fs_zpswxsor17u.jpgUniversity of British Columbia professor of English Literature Mary Ann Saunders is presenting at a conference which begins on Thursday. The conference is called 2016/Moving Trans History Forward: Building Communities -- Sharing Conections and it is being held at the University of Victoria. Keynote speakers are Jamison Green of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health and SiriusXM founder Martine Rothblatt.

Professor Saunders' paper is The (Transgender) Tempest: Shakespeare as Trans Archive. She will be speaking, of course, about the character Ariel, the spirit who is the sorcerer Prospero's indentured servant.

On three occasions during the play, Prospero orders Ariel to take on female form.

Saunders based one of her English literature courses around this character after reading a paper that focused on the 2010 film version of Ariel, in which the male character has breasts when taking on female form, but a masculine face.

Saunders said she said she was "irritated" when the article she read described the character in the film as an example of "body horror."

These are her [author of the article] words: is grotesque, is monstrous, and she refers to these embodiments as impossible.

When I read that I was thinking well, okay, but this body looks an awful lot like my body.

And, it looks an awful lot like the bodies of a lot of trans women I know. And our bodies are not horrifying, they are not grotesque, and they're certainly not impossible. Otherwise I would not be here.

--Saunders

From there, Saunders realized there were a number of interesting parallels between Ariel and the lives of trans women.

Case in point: When Prospero makes Ariel take on the form of a sea nymph to lure a prince, it "draws on kind of a cultural stereotype … which is that we take on a false female form in order to seduce or lure unsuspecting men into relationships that they would not otherwise want to be in or chose."

Saunders, who is emphatic that she doesn't believe this stereotype, recalls watching the movie scene in which Ariel watches the prince with Prospera's daughter.

At that moment I see playing out a feeling I know a lot of trans women experience, which is this feeling that the people who we want to love us, the people who we want to be in relationship with us, are not going to be.

They're always going to choose the person who isn't trans over us.

--Saunders

Saunders says she knows this is not a universal condition, but she says it speaks to a common trans anxiety.

There's this place of identification there, which I find really beautiful, and also really bittersweet.

--Saunders

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

TheOtherMaven's picture

In Shakespeare's own time the character was of course interpreted by one of the boy-players (no women were allowed on the Elizabethan-Jacobean stage). But as soon as the Restoration imported the French idea of actresses, Ariel was practically always played by a woman.

Starting circa 1930, it's been an anything-goes part.

up
0 users have voted.

There is no justice. There can be no peace.

See below. Smile

up
0 users have voted.

...women were not allowed on the stage, so female characters were performed by young boys. Thus it is no surprise that stage directions always refer to Ariel with male pronouns. It is also the case that on the few occasions that Ariel refers to hirself with pronouns, s/he uses male pronouns.

up
0 users have voted.
darkmatter's picture

Very interesting paper. It is interesting, isn't it, how throughout the play Ariel is used--commanded, even--by Prospero to bring about the successful union of the next-generation couple, Ferdinand and Miranda. But all along, Ariel reminds Prospero of his promise to grant Ariel freedom. Ariel, and the gendered ambiguity he embodies, is "released" at the same moment the the heterosexual couple is established and political order is restored. Teasing out the meaning of Ariel's "freedom" in the context of the play would therefore be important to do. Anyway, thanks for sharing!

up
0 users have voted.
detroitmechworks's picture

I much prefer the comedies "As You Like It" and "Twelfth Night".

I admit that I do enjoy the breeches plays quite a bit, and it is very delightful when an actress gets to play with gender as much as they are allowed to in those two pieces. (Full Disclosure: My Son's Name is Oberon, and I wanted to name my Daughter Rosalind, but was overriden by my ex-wife who preferred the name of one of my original characters, Raeka)

Not trying to denigrate the very real struggles because the plays deal with gender humorously. Rather I'm always happy to see when a piece can handle the subject maturely, and yet still show great insight. (Which I feel Shakespeare DOES, in the hands of a director who gets it.)

up
0 users have voted.

I do not pretend I know what I do not know.