View from a Fannish Perspective (and Hello over here!)

I posted this at TOP a couple weeks ago, my first and last diary. If I'm gonna post at a progressive blog, I'm going to post at a progressive blog.

~~~

Fandom's been a big part of my life for more than twenty years. It's a very interactive community, very grassroots. I've participated in many forms, conventions, meta discussions, and yes, even fanfiction (reading AND writing and no, I'm not going to give you my penname). I've followed a number of fandoms, including Lord of the Rings, NCIS, Criminal Minds, and Avengers, among others.

As far as political fandom goes (and yes, there is such a thing) I followed Obama's campaign mostly after the fact; I tend to be a late follower in anything - I was late to tumblr, I still have a Livejournal (that I very rarely update), and I still haven't ported all of my fanfiction to AO3. I only read Twitter when specific posts show up on BNR or someone else's tumblr or someone on Pidgin links me directly.

My 'participation' consisted of voting and spending long afternoons watching various rally and campaign speeches in the summer of '08.

Bernie's campaign is different.

Before his campaign even got started, I was chatting up a local organizer about volunteering. He set up the a local livestream meeting in July at the local coffee house; the fact that I was there (with my laptop!) saved it when it discovered that the equipment on hand wasn't capable of connecting to the tv. Most of the 100+ people packed into the room stayed late to watch Bernie speak, since we only managed to get it up and running when the organizational part started.

Politics may be 'taboo' but I find that annoying. I talk to everyone about Bernie - and I ride public transportation, so I almost always have someone new to talk to. Of the TWO HRC supporters I've run into in the last eight months or so, one of them has switched to supporting Bernie after looking him up at my suggestion. The other I have not seen since asking him to look Bernie up, but the only reason he could give for supporting HRC was because "It's about time we had a woman in the White House."

I made my first donation (ever!) to a political campaign, even though I can't afford much.

I attended his rally here in town back in November and stood in line over three hours for the privilege to do so. (The people I met there were awesome!)

Yes, I own, have read, and have out on loan Bernie's updated Outsider in the White House (with a waiting list on the want-to-borrow part). I don't know when (or if) I will get it back.

THAT SAID.

There are three four things I really want to point out.

First, one of the things that really gets me to connect with a fandom (show, movie, book (series)) is the exploration of not just power, but people assuming power less than enthusiastically. People who assume power because the current leadership fails to function, for whatever reason, be it corruption (because power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely; therefore it stands to reason that the best person to give it to is someone who didn't want it in the first place) or incompetence, or lack, etc.

Bernie's earned his retirement. He's worked his entire career for the betterment of other people and society as a whole, and deserves to spend the rest of his life (may it be long, hale and hearty!) with his family, with Jane by his side and spoiling his grandkids. But his job's not done - it won't be done in his lifetime, and it likely won't be done in mine. He sees that, probably better than I do, and is willing to give up what his ad American Horizon offers - time to spend with the grandkids - to try and make sure the rest of us have a shot at the chance to do so.

Moreso, I get the distinct impression that he's not in this race necessarily because he wants to be, but because he sees a need for someone like him - someone who can and more importantly will stand up for the people who elected him to his various offices, lead by example and inspiration, and reach for what's beyond his grasp, always - and no one else fit the bill. I can see him willing and able to pass that torch to someone else.

Point the second.

One of my biggest fandoms is Marvel Cinematic Universe, particularly Avengers (and its individual members' movies). In Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Captain America was accused of treason and the general public finds it impossible to believe. This patent disbelief - the strength of Captain America's reputation - plays a major role in the end of the movie, and spurs others to act on his behalf and their own.

Bernie wasn't a hero of WWII, and he didn't spend almost 70 years on ice, a period of time in which Captain America's legend and persona took on mythic proportions. But what he does have is decades of public service and a set of consistent guiding principles, all connected by a thread of fairness and justice. We've seen it play out again and again against attacks from many directions. Nothing sticks. (Not even socialism.)

So if you ask if I'm comparing Bernie Sanders to Captain America? I don't think Bernie likes bullies any more than Steve Rogers did, so I guess you could say...

I really want to see a manip of Bernie wearing a Captain America uniform.

Point the third.

As much as I loved, and still love, The West Wing, before there was The West Wing there was a movie called The American President.

People (some of them probably Bernie himself and/or surrogates) have, in some fashion, made the point that democratic socialism is an unavoidable part of our society at large (and while they may be talking about Social Security and Medicare, I'm talking, more basically speaking, about ROADS.).

The climax of The American President is a speech given by President Andrew Shepard, a speech I at one time could recite from memory (yes, I watched it that many times). While the topic was different, I very very much liked the approach he took in addressing one of the attacks by his political opponent, Senator Bob Rumson.

The attack was about Shepard's being a member of the ACLU, and the pertinent part of the speech is bolded in the transcription below the video:

For the last couple of months, Senator Rumson has suggested that being president of this country was, to a certain extent, about character. And although I've not been willing to engage in his attacks on me I've been here three years and three days, and I can tell you without hesitation being president of this country is entirely about character.

For the record, yes, I am a card carrying member of the ACLU. But the more important question is, why aren't you, Bob? * Now this is an organization whose sole purpose is to defend the Bill of Rights. So it naturally begs the question, why would a senator, his party's most powerful spokesman and a candidate for president choose to reject upholding the Constitution?

* bold and italics emphasis mine

I would dearly, dearly love to see Bernie take the "But you're a socialist!" question/accusation and turn it around like that. I'm no kind of speech writer, but I can imagine him cutting that argument off at the knees in a way that simply pointing it out hasn't (thus far).

Democratic socialism isn't just for the little guy. We've heard that - the point's been made over and over again that we have socialism for corporations and elite, and rugged individualism for everyone else. But the truth is that democratic socialism lifts everyone, poor and wealthy alike. More importantly, this country cannot function without the democratic social systems that are currently in place (roads, sewage treatment, etc.) despite the oligarchy's attempts to destroy them.

The fourth point I want to make has to do with one scene in the America ad.

I love this ad so much, like many many others. I've watched over and over again, and cried, and gushed to friends, and sat them down and made them watch. I've watched every clip about it I can find and read every blog and article I came across about it, and nobody's pointed out the little bit that struck me the most.

Here's the ad; if you need to, go ahead and watch (another) few times. Please pause it at 0:10 when it lets you go.

It's a man and a woman in a coffee shop, talking and working on their laptops. No big deal, right?

The people in the shop aren't the point. At least, it's not the point I see in this particular scene. In my view, the point of this clip is the poster on the wall between and behind them, with the photograph of the hands on the keyboard.

If there is one person alive who fits that headline more than Bernie does, I don't know who it is.

The fate of a good man.

Bernie Sanders is, IMHO, a truly good, compassionate, honest and profoundly unselfish man. Just an ordinary man, trying to do extraordinary things.

An ordinary man I would be proud to call my president.

~~~

Disclaimer: First diary; lurked for years, never had anything to say before now. Please be gentle. All words belong to me.

***

Note: The disclaimer at the end was half joke, what with the creation of AO3 making such things sort of a moot point, but I left it in because I'm thorough that way.

Other note: Yes, I did have not one but TWO moments of extreme deja vu over at TOP with two different diaries concerning points two and three. But I know next to nothing about Marvel comics-verse, and my focus on the speech was different, so. There you go.

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

Lookout's picture

Bernie is a better man than me (cause I'm hoping for an indictment). He could help our country reach toward its potential. We are moving forward, and I keep hope in my heart.

You'll like it here.

up
0 users have voted.

“Until justice rolls down like water and righteousness like a mighty stream.”

Not me, us.

Bernie is definitely a better person than I am - I have a few guesses as to the consequences of various possible outcomes of November's election.

And I already love it here - the blue especially. There have been studies showing that warm colors - like orange - actually predispose people to violence. And there are some (like me) who actually find yellow in particular, but also some shades of orange painful to look at. The blue is a very very welcome change.

Aside from other things.

up
0 users have voted.

Love of power is a puppet string. - Makana, Fire is Ours

Nice diary. Yes, Bernie is the last honest man in politics. I can only imagine how tired he must be. But he battles on for our democracy.

up
0 users have voted.

TOP - That Other Place. DailyWassermanSchultz.

I never thought I could cry listening to a politician, and I didn't, not even listening to Obama back in the Hope and Change campaign. But Bernie is no politician - he's a true statesman, and a public servant, and I can't seem to turn off the waterworks listening to him speak.

He is the first person I've ever been able to vote for.

up
0 users have voted.

Love of power is a puppet string. - Makana, Fire is Ours

Embedding of the playlist is disabled, so you'll have to go off-world for it:

https://youtu.be/EzlGKEC1MyQ?list=PL48F1E62AB313FA4C

up
0 users have voted.

The earth is a multibillion-year-old sphere.
The Nazis killed millions of Jews.
On 9/11/01 a Boeing 757 (AA77) flew into the Pentagon.
AGCC is happening.
If you cannot accept these facts, I cannot fake an interest in any of your opinions.

jiordan's picture

Wonderful to have you and your writing here. Its a fantastic essay and I whole-heartedly agree with your points. Sometimes watching Sanders in interviews he just seems resigned to needing to do this. I have never once gotten the impression he's interested in the power of the position at all--which may be one of the reasons I find him fascinating.

Thanks for sharing your work--I look forward to reading more.

up
0 users have voted.

Sorry it took so long to get back to you!

Yeah, I totally agree, I see him and I can just hear him in my head going "We are the richest country on the planet and we really have to do this? I really have to do this?" all the time.

Thanks! Working on transcribing the TYT interview atm!

up
0 users have voted.

Love of power is a puppet string. - Makana, Fire is Ours

it's a wry bread.

up
0 users have voted.

The earth is a multibillion-year-old sphere.
The Nazis killed millions of Jews.
On 9/11/01 a Boeing 757 (AA77) flew into the Pentagon.
AGCC is happening.
If you cannot accept these facts, I cannot fake an interest in any of your opinions.

Phoebe Loosinhouse's picture

I loved the very personal viewpoint and your including some of the media that helped to shape it. I also liked your take on a subtle nuance in the America ad that I bet many (including myself) missed.

Your essay made me think of something that my husband and I talk about quite a bit - I'm referring to the Captain America part. We notice the lack of heroes in most of our TV and films - it's the age of the anti-hero all the time. There is a lot of entertainment where there isn't one single person in it who is sympathetic for being simply a nice/good person. It's unsettling, because you don't know whose side you're on, if any, or if there is anything in the show that you're rooting for. The underlying premise is that life sucks, everyone is corrupt, and the sooner you wise up to that fact the unhappier you will be, but at least you'll be a realist. It's a very cynical worldview and it works to crush any idealistic or optimistic bud that may be existent in one's outlook.

When I was younger, there were a lot of shows and cartoons that inculcated within us that there was a moral compass in the world and that justice was a necessary component to any society. It was often presented in a patriarchal fashion, the father coming home, sitting down with his pipe and solving all the moral dilemmas the family had run into that day - "Lying is always wrong, Billy," "You can't let the other girl take the blame for something you did, Susie", "Jesus, Martha, how many Manhattans have you had already?" (just kidding). But anyway, the media had a large part in raising us, and the sanctimony and piousness and sappiness of a lot of the stuff we watched probably had a net positive in socializing us. Don't laugh, but believing that there was such a thing as "truth, justice and the American way" inspired a lot of little do-gooders who became adult do-gooders. I am really sorry to see that our current day is overwhelmed by cynicism, because that feeling that every good outcome is impractical and unrealistic forces the masses into believing that the only thing that works is "pragmatism" doled out in incremental doses.

up
0 users have voted.

" “Human kindness has never weakened the stamina or softened the fiber of a free people. A nation does not have to be cruel to be tough.” FDR "

What really gets me is that, of all the articles and interviews and people I've personally talked to about that one shot in the ad, I'm the only one who points it out. Everyone just looks at me strangely and goes "Huh, you're right. I never would have noticed that." Windmills in the beginning? Yes. Same sex couple? Yes. 'Background' headline? Uh. No.

But then, I'm in fandom, so seeing stuff like that is sort of second nature now?

You're right! I grew up on Thundercats and GIJoe, both of which (actually, a lot of other shows, too) had underlying social themes to them that you don't see today. And a lot of the "you don't see today" is because, by and large, cartoons have become little more than 20-minute commercials for tie-in toys.

I wish I had more and better words with which to reply; your comments are awesome, and you might think about doing a blog post based on them.

up
0 users have voted.

Love of power is a puppet string. - Makana, Fire is Ours