"White working class communities deserve to die"
It appears that Donald Trump has managed to do what no one else could do - make conservatives
hate working-class whites as much as liberals do.
Conservative writers who have scoffed at both Trump and his supporters include National Review's Kevin Williamson, who said in March that working class communities "deserve to die."
"Forget all your cheap theatrical Bruce Springsteen crap," he wrote. "Forget your sanctimony about struggling Rust Belt factory towns and your conspiracy theories about the wily Orientals stealing our jobs. ... The white American underclass is in thrall to a vicious, selfish culture whose main products are misery and used heroin needles. Donald Trump's speeches make them feel good. So does OxyContin."
The National Review even doubled-down on this.
Conservatives have always blamed the victims for their ills. It's what they do. But now they are blaming their entire base.
Call it death and The Donald: Analysis of primary election results so far shows that counties with high white mortality rates are also likely to vote Trump.
Stripped down to its essence, the G.O.P. elite view is that working-class America faces a crisis, not of opportunity, but of values. That is, for some mysterious reason many of our citizens have, as Mr. Ryan puts it, lost “their will and their incentive to make the most of their lives.” And this crisis of values, they suggest, has been aided and abetted by social programs that make life too easy on slackers.
The problems with this diagnosis should be obvious. Tens of millions of people don’t suffer a collapse in values for no reason. Remember, several decades ago the sociologist William Julius Wilson argued that the social ills of America’s black community didn’t come out of thin air, but were the result of disappearing economic opportunity. If he was right, you would have expected declining opportunity to have the same effect on whites, and sure enough, that’s exactly what we’re seeing.
Which should be a self-evident observation. Hell, it's even a foundational belief of capitalism - that millions of people can't be wrong.
But the Republican elite can’t handle the truth. It’s too committed to an Ayn Rand story line about heroic job creators versus moochers to admit either that trickle-down economics can fail to deliver good jobs, or that sometimes government aid is a crucial lifeline. So it ends up lashing out at its own voters when they refuse to buy into that story line.
Of course the Democrats are no better, just different.
As Thomas Frank explained in Listen, Liberal, Democrats are also a party of the elites, the top 10% professionals.
The white working class is being destroyed before our eyes, but economic issues aren't even on the Democrats agenda unless they can be spun as minority issues, not class issues.
Consider this amazing statement by Hillary.
“If we broke up the big banks tomorrow—and I will if they deserve it, if they pose a systemic risk, I will—would that end racism?”
“No!” the audience yelled back.
Clinton continued to list scenarios, asking: “Would that end sexism? Would that end discrimination against the LGBT community? Would that make people feel more welcoming to immigrants overnight?”
Where does one begin with this?
Forget for a moment that Hillary has no concrete plan for ending discrimination, and think about how this would sound to someone just struggling to make ends meet.
Pure economic concerns and class concerns don't even factor into this equation.
Obviously, no one ever promised a piece of legislation would “end” hate and injustice. Anyone even notionally sincere about battling the prejudices and cognitive dissonances that oligarchs and overlords have forever promulgated to divide and conquer humanity understands that “racism” and “sexism” are not forces you can arrest with a pen.
Democrats rarely even think in terms of 'solidarity' anymore. 'Opportunity' in a 'meritocracy' is now the mainstream philosophy of the Democrats.
And everyone knows that if you fail in a meritocracy then you have no one to blame but yourself. Which sounds just like Republican elitism.
Comments
And this is why I am leaving the Democratic Party.
For 35 years, the Democratic Party has demanded that I put my economic aspirations aside to help the less fortunate - and I have, willingly. Now I am falling into that category and they have nothing.
I meant to say that stupid people are generally Conservative. I believe that is so obviously and universally admitted a principle that I hardly think any gentleman will deny it."
John Stuart Mill (1806 - 1873)
I left this in Armando's diary.
It does connect to the point of what you wrote. White people playing PoC, women and gays to oppress poor white people cause they got theirs. This election is a joke only I'm not laughing.
"Religion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich."--Napoleon
JFC
Yeah, I'm not identifying as a democrat these days either. I'm done with being sold out and thrown under the bus by the democrats. Years ago when I started my FB account I put 'anti-stupid' for political beliefs. I haven't changed it.
This shit is bananas.
Some years back after Occupy introduced the term the 1%
I used to comment that the Republicans serve the 1% but the Dems' tent is 10x!! the size of the R's.
The comment ususally went over the heads of the people to whom I was trying to make the point about the Dems screwing Working People.
Compensated Spokes Model for Big Poor.
don't look at the Hillary behind the curtain
Keep looking at the window dressing! Don't pay any attention to that real Hillary behind the curtain!
"US govt/military = bad. Russian govt/military = bad. Any politician wanting power = bad. Anyone wielding power = bad." --Shahryar
"All power corrupts absolutely!" -- thanatokephaloides
Hasn't it always been this way?
Rivethead by Ben Hamper kinda made that point pretty forcefully 25 years ago.
Small pie yields discrimination
Ending income inequality will not end discrimination but no single thing, except for time, can accomplish that; however when the people are not blinded by the fear of being or ending up on the short end of our economy they are more likely to treat each other as fellows rather than foes.
Many of the 1% attained that status by manipulating our system to their benefit. The only way they can maintain that ill-gotten advantage is to keep the people divided or distracted or both. Pitting groups (races, religions, ages, etc.) against each other accomplishes both: some become trapped in hatred and others have to use their scarce time and resources to counter the hate leaving less available to fix the underlying system. Once we find the true source of our discontent putting an end to the hate-based problems will become considerably easier.
Class consciousness taboo
The convergence of middle aged white suicide, Trump, opiates and rage is the outcome of boomer whites (and I'm one, but atypical for reasons of no interest to anyone else) being unable to countenance an honest discussion of class, privilege (and its unspoken expectations), inequality, and alienation. There is a great discussion of this going on over at a weird blog called thearchdruidreport.com that I recommend highly.
I was talking to a very "liberal" white lady artist who was going on with some fairly racist garbage (which she denied was racist because her niece is married to a "perfectly lovely" Mexican man) about securing the borders because the folks coming from south of here lack, well, you know, "creativity", wouldn't survive without us "capable" folks propping them up, and argle bargle like that. I think I permanently trashed that friendship when I pointed out to her that if all the infrastructure propping up her and her brilliant and gifted friends collapsed, they would be hard put to survive at all. She seemed shocked - I think she fancies Ayn Rand's little choo choo train would pick up her the the hubby and kids and whisk them off to Teluride in time for the girls' dance lessons. Did she think she was going to be more resourceful than the people who pick and process our food, care for the elderly and disabled, clean and build damn near everything and do anything else that people who consider themselves the cultural elite assume that "less creative" folks must do because they can't do anything "worthwhile"?
Haven't been to ArchDruidReport in a while.
Wow. They really do have a fascinating
discussion going on over there.
Thanks for bringing it to our attention.
Only connect. - E.M. Forster