India's War on Cash destroys economy, lives

Prime Minister Narendra Modi probably thought he was pretty smart when he recently banned the country’s large currency bills, 500- and 1,000-rupee notes, 86% of cash in the market, in the name of fighting corruption. Instead India's economy was plunged into chaos.

But it has stunned hundreds of millions of poor and working-class Indians who live an almost entirely cash-based existence, paying in bills for everything from rent to groceries to cellphone credit.
The plan was shrouded in such secrecy that even India’s financial institutions were ill prepared, creating long, sometimes unruly lines outside banks, ATMs and chronically understaffed post offices that are authorized to exchange the now-worthless notes and dispense new ones.
Credit and debit cards are unaffected, but only half of Indians have bank accounts. Even for those fortunate enough to find some cash — the government has set a temporary $66 daily limit for withdrawals — a newly released 2,000-rupee banknote is in effect useless for daily purchases because most merchants can’t make change.
Adding to the headaches is that the 2,000-rupee note and a new, revamped 500-rupee note are of a different size, meaning it could take weeks to reconfigure the country’s 200,000-plus cash machines to dispense them.

Actually it'll probably take four months to reconfigure the ATM machine.

Few villagers have access to an ATM. Most have to trek to a bank branch to change their cash, which means losing out on crucial days of labor. Many Indians, particularly women, still don’t have an active bank account. Finance Minister Arun Jaitley wondered aloud how many poor people would even have 1,000-rupee notes -- probably a rhetorical question, but surely it shouldn’t have been. Someone should've sought the answer before shutting down India’s financial system.

But that's only scratching the surface.

Blue-collar workers are not showing up for jobs, unable to scrounge up money for bus fare or fuel to power their motorbikes. Mumbai’s cash-based taxis and rickshaws have also struggled as middle-class customers opt for card-based services such as Uber.
Even filling up the tank has become a chore as gas stations, which have been authorized to accept the old bills for a limited time, refuse to make change, said Lallan Jaiswal, a cabby sitting idle by the roadside, his khaki uniform slung over the driver’s seat.
“They fill up the tank only if we buy gas worth 500 or 1,000 rupees,” Jaiswal said — the equivalent of a day’s worth of fares.

India's economy just got hit with a neutron bomb. The buildings are still standing but people are dying.

Nearly three dozen people have died in the aftermath of India’s bold, surprising move to demonetize its Rs 500 ($7.5) and Rs 1,000 ($15) currency bills overnight last week.

Some of these people have reportedly died standing in the long snaking queues, while many others died because hospitals, pharmacy shops, and ambulances refused to offer services in exchange of old notes. 

A child reportedly died at a hospital owned by union culture and tourism minister Mahesh Sharma, after the staff refused to accept old notes for treatment. 

An infant died in Odisha after an autorickshaw driver refused to take the family to a hospital. The family didn't have smaller denomination notes with them for the fare. A sick newborn was refused treatment in Mumbai after the parents couldn’t provide money in new currency bills. The infant died.

Some people are losing hope. A 50-year-old mother of two committed suicide in Gujarat after grocery stores refused to accept old currency notes. In another similar incident, a 55-year-old woman in Telangana committed suicide after learning that Rs 5.4 million ($79.500) in cash she had saved over the years was useless overnight.

All this in just one week. ONE WEEK.
What will India look like two months from now? Conditions will get worse before they get better.
Even worse, it's unlikely that corruption will be affected by banning cash.

Even in the best case scenario -- that a significant proportion of the outstanding currency is destroyed -- there’s no reason to suppose it was all black money and not the savings of regular citizens scared of harassment by tax authorities. Modi has dropped dark hints that this is just the beginning, raising fears that business should now worry about of constant tax raids and the reopening of decades-old cases. In fact, that dark new age may already be here.

Even setting aside the painful adjustment, the long-term effects of this monetary shock on India’s informal economy could well be severe; a large proportion of marginal firms may not survive the loss of a fortnight of income. The informal financial sector -- unregistered moneylenders who provide loans to businesses worth 40 percent of total bank lending -- will be decimated.

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

They had to have foreseen the problems this would create. I wonder who's really benefiting from this...?

up
0 users have voted.
divineorder's picture

up
0 users have voted.

A truth of the nuclear age/climate change: we can no longer have endless war and survive on this planet. Oh sh*t.

divineorder's picture

researching the consequences....

up
0 users have voted.

A truth of the nuclear age/climate change: we can no longer have endless war and survive on this planet. Oh sh*t.

tapu dali's picture

be damned.

up
0 users have voted.

There are known knowns; there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns – the ones we don't know we don't know.

up
0 users have voted.

Orwell: Where's the omelette?

divineorder's picture

http://www.ndtv.com/india-news/anand-sharma-begins-debate-on-notes-ban-a...

The Congress leader accused the government of bringing in "financial anarchy" with the sudden ban on Rs. 500 and Rs. 1,000 notes last week, which has left millions queuing up at banks and ATMs for cash.

"I condemn the prime minister. He should apologise for saying that the poor people standing in queues for five-six days are scamsters," Mr Sharma said.

The opposition has planned a united offensive against the government's sudden move to pull out the two biggest currency notes from circulation. In a late night announcement last Tuesday, PM Modi said this was necessary to bring black or untaxed money into the economic mainstream.

"You have created an environment where you cannot ask questions. If you ask questions then questions are raised on your patriotism," Mr Sharma said.

He also charged that the move was leaked to select persons.

"You said there has to be secrecy, or else, criminals and terrorists would come to know. You did not keep it secret," he thundered. "You leaked it selectively. BJP units deposited crores into banks before the ban," alleged the former minister.

Sound familiar?

up
0 users have voted.

A truth of the nuclear age/climate change: we can no longer have endless war and survive on this planet. Oh sh*t.

Comes under the heading of "you can't make this stuff up" followed by, "FOLLOW THE MONEY" - wonder what country the Prime Minister sent his share to for safe keeping.

up
0 users have voted.
Bollox Ref's picture

from the Subcontinent posting on Dead State will make it through okay.

up
0 users have voted.

Gëzuar!!
from a reasonably stable genius.

I'll bet that the cash and carry approach to medical care has the GOPers salivating; they've found their dream replacement for Obamacare: cash up front or die quickly---the plan that Alan Grayson exposed on the floor of the house not to long ago. It's a shame that the Dem machine shafted him this year but he wasn't the only one and this year want the first time for such behavior either.

up
0 users have voted.
Song of the lark's picture

Its an increditably repressive impulse. From Caseyresearch
"Governments want to herd everyone into the digital financial system…

As we mentioned earlier, holding paper cash lets you “opt out” of the financial system. Holding and using paper cash makes it much harder for governments to track, monitor, and control you. Holding paper cash also thwarts the government’s ability to take money directly from your bank account via “negative interest rates.”

This is exactly why the government hates paper cash. By banning cash, the government is closing the escape hatch. It’s penning us in like sheep for a shearing. If all your money is in a digital bank account, you’re helpless. The government can confiscate your cash via negative interest rates, and there’s nothing you can do about it."

It's a real movement by financial elites to control a wide variety of uses of cash money.
Try going in your bank and withdrawing a large sum say 10,000 dollars from you bank account in cash. You will likely run in several problems and be subjected to questions.
The other day my son was in Central America and asked me to deposit 1500 dollars into his account to pay for some comic art for a new comic he's working on. Chase bank one of the largest banks in the country would not let me deposit it into his account in cash. US currency completely worthless. I had to do it by check.
No doubt many of you can find similar anecdotal information, of limits at ATMs , etc.
Only 5 % of US. Currency is cash , the rest is digital.
Last year the 500 euro note was taken out of circulation.
This year India
Next year Larry Summers is recommending elimination of the 100 dollar bill. This is not going to end well.

up
0 users have voted.
SmartAleq's picture

Inadvertently. For the past couple years I've been self employed and the majority of my income is in cash. Banks lose their shit when you bring cash to deposit and I'm pretty sure they are already filling out the suspicious activity reports as I'm walking out the door. Thank goodness for credit union network ATMs that accept bills because otherwise I'd have a real bitch of a time paying my bills. I can only imagine how much fun it must be for people who are not only in cash based business but who are also unbanked--as many are who have less than stellar credit. I recently had some spray insulation installed under my house and paid the guys in cash and they were banjaxed--had to call in to the office to make sure it was okay and I wrote up a receipt on their work order for them to sign in case they wandered off to the casino or something.

Every so often they yap about banning cash but it's almost impossible--for instance, with so many states legalizing cannabis but the banks refusing to let the businesses use proper banking (because of federal laws and FDIC cannabis based businesses are blocked from the banking system and are forced to handle massive amounts of cash, which makes them huge targets) is causing a whole raft of problems that apparently nobody ever thought of.

Me, I've decided that keeping the bulk of my money liquid is a pretty good idea because fuck the government and their snooping and following us around. Cash can be hazardous but it sure does make you invisible--unless you have to deal with a bank.

up
0 users have voted.

"Nothing's wrong, son, look at the news!" -- Firesign Theater

link

About half of an estimated 9.3 million trucks under the All India Motor Transport Congress were off the road eight days after the announcement as drivers abandoned vehicles mid-way into their trips after running out of cash, according to Naveen Gupta, secretary general of the group. India’s roads carry about 65 percent of the country’s freight. Drivers don’t have enough money for food, truck maintenance and to make payments at border check posts. “It will take a few more days for the situation to normalize,” Gupta said in an e-mailed statement.
up
0 users have voted.
Ken in MN's picture

So, kids, there is you clue as to what to invest in for the future: Cigarettes and liquor, for the coming prison economy...

up
0 users have voted.

I want my two dollars!