Simone Zimmerman talks about activism and the effort to remove her from Bernie's campaign.
For five days in April, Simone Zimmerman was the most controversial figure in Jewish politics.
The 25-year-old activist served very briefly as Bernie Sanders’ Jewish outreach coordinator, before being fired after an old Facebook post in which she used profanity against Israeli prime minister Netanyahu surfaced — and quickly ended her political stint.
Earlier this week, Simone was interviewed by Isaac Luria and the interview is up on +972mag. I recommend a read if you’re interested in the subject:
“Bringing a nuanced sign to a pro-Israeli rally is not enough anymore,” she explains. “There is a crisis on our hands. The occupation is hitting its 50-year anniversary. We care about this community too much to not demand that it be on the right side of history. Even if it makes people a little bit uncomfortable. Disrupting business as usual is actually essential to making change.”
she talks about the year-old facebook post that became a lightning rod leading to her suspension, saying she edited it a few hours after posting it to take out some of the profanity:
Then the Facebook post was leaked on a right-wing news site. The screen shot said “posted 10 hours ago” and was an old profile picture of mine, which means that somebody took a screenshot of my Facebook post when I initially wrote it and had been saving it.
I assume it’s probably someone I went to college with. When I was at Berkeley, there was a group of more right-wing pro-Israel students who sort of told us they were keeping files on us. So it’s not a total surprise. It wasn’t inconceivable to me that somebody I know could have been holding on to that to use against me one day. The headline became, Sanders Staffer Says Fuck You, Netanyahu On Her Facebook Page.
At the time, she was the subject of blistering attacks, including one in the Jerusalem Post by a fellow UC Berkeley grad who claims to have figured out how a “Pro-Israel enthusiast turned anti-Israel radical”:
At Berkeley, Zimmerman frequented Hillel, which presents itself as “home away from home.” There, she encountered Kesher Enoshi, a Hillel group presenting programs demonizing Israel and the IDF. Kesher Enoshi had been collaborating with Students for Justice in Palestine, a leading BDS campus group – on the Anti-Defamation League’s top 10 list of anti-Israel groups in America. The Hillel director, Rabbi Naftalin-Kelman, supported and promoted Kesher Enoshi. [...]
Many students from pro-Israel homes, even those with Israeli parents, were coopted and alienated from Israel at Hillel. Many, like Eyal Mazor, became BDS leaders. After graduating, Mazor joined two BDS groups: Code Pink, which disrupted Netanyahu’s speech to Congress, and Jewish Voice for Peace, with Mazor as a key organizer, which disrupted Netanyahu’s speech before the General Assembly of Jewish Federations in New Orleans. [...]
Simone Zimmerman and many other students have been brainwashed and coopted.
At the same time, she was defended in strong terms by many including Dove Kent:
The vicious offensive against Zimmerman by the Jewish Right combined with the lack of support from the Jewish mainstream – leading to her suspension from her job on Thursday – is not isolated, new, or even surprising. Jews, Palestinians, and others who speak out against the Israeli occupation and for the humanity of Palestinians have reported being fired, intimidated, monitored, threatened, censored and attacked for many years.
and Jacob Myerson who wrote in Jacobin:
If not Bernie Sanders and Simone Zimmerman, who will represent the Jews who regard Netanyahu as an asshole?
New York magazine described the events leading up to Simone’s suspension:
On Wednesday, the Washington Free Beacon, a conservative outlet, dug up a Facebook post of Zimmerman’s from last March in which she wrote: “Bibi Netanyahu is an arrogant, deceptive, cynical, manipulative asshole … Fuck you, Bibi, for daring to insist that you legitimately represent even a fraction of Jews in this world.”
Ronald Lauder, the president of the World Jewish Congress, called on the campaign to fire her on Thursday morning, according to the Times. Zimmerman has not been fired, but Sanders spokesperson Michael Briggs told the Times that she had been suspended while the campaign investigates the matter.
The JTA also did a comprehensive, widely distributed, if slightly critical round-up of her experience. And here’s the NY Times on her suspension:
But the suspension was also an important moment in the small but deeply felt universe of Democratic Jewish politics, which has been torn apart on generational and ideological lines over the acceptable level of criticism of Israel’s right-wing government.
With Ms. Zimmerman’s history of opposition to Israeli policies in the West Bank and Gaza, her hiring drew concerted and ultimately overwhelming pressure from American Jewish leaders. Her suspension showed that when it came to the high stakes and intense scrutiny of presidential politics, the establishment’s view of Ms. Zimmerman and her brethren as dangerous radicals still held sway even with Mr. Sanders, a candidate promising a revolution. [...]
“This is the American Jewish community eating its own,” said Peter Beinart, a mentor to Ms. Zimmerman and a leading voice in liberal Zionism. “Simone is the best of the best. Most of the other kids have given up on the community. She cares deeply and wants to make it live up to its own stated ideals.
Comments
Another hypocrisy
It's not quite like that only black people can call each other "niggers". The situation with Jewish extremism in defending anything done by the state of Israel is by labeling even Orthodox Jews who are pro-peace as anti-semitic. This is political correctness becoming willful blindness. There are valid points to a two-state solution. Attempts to discuss this point are often (perhaps even the majority of the time) greeted with outrage cloaked by the term anti-semitism. Is eye-for-an-eye still the justification of oppression of Palestine. What is the moral principle validating such oppression. Blacks were legally oppressed for 4 centuries. They now vote, pay taxes, get to elective office. Does a disagreement with a Black citizen make one a racist? Not if such a disagreement is respectful AND rational. I do not find the continuing oppression of Palestine by the state of Israel to be either respectful nor rational. In c99 we are free to express ourselves by saying what we believe about issues and without name-calling. Although I may disagree with Ms. Zimmerman's choice of language on her FB page, I do not disagree with her sentiments.
A similar analogy
could possibly be made to Clinton supporters accusing any critics of Hillary on any subject matter as being sexist.
Love is my religion.
Everybody seems to want the messenger dead.
I think a two-state solution is good for I/P, and I would heartily support one for the US. When you have such a divide in beliefs and what people want, giving them the opportunity to go their own ways is a reasonable solution. Heck, I'd even be glad to give Texas back to Mexico.
What is going on in I/P is a crime. I look at pictures of the bombed-out ME, and it leaves no wonder as to why there are so many refugees. There is no acceptable reason for what the US and Israel are doing to that region.
"Religion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich."--Napoleon
Don't Mess with Texas
I really hate it when people say they would toss everyone in a whole state out of their perfect utopia. It's one of the few, albeit disgusting, acceptable forms of bigotry.
That said, this Texan still sports a Bernie bumper sticker, and my son thinks it's what caused someone to make a false complaint to TxDOT against me.
It seems the anti littering program "Don't Mess with Texas" has a hotline you can call and report people who litter from their vehicles. The Hillbot (doubt it was a Trumper) lied and said litter flew out of my truck bed.
Couldn't have happened because I never, ever toss trash in my truck bed. I remember the crying Native American public service announcement from my childhood. It made its point with me. And, I back into my spot at work, so no one walks behind my vehicle. Plus, based on the time they claimed it flew out, I would have been 15-20 miles from work.
Didn't happen. Either I pissed someone off with my driving, or a Hillbot did it. I'm going with Hillbot, because I can't remember the last time I've been honked at or flipped off.
This Berner lives in Texas and there are lots of us here worthy of staying Americans. Hate our voting machines and crooked Republicans and Democrats, but don't hate us, please.
same ol' same ol'
if you don't support hrc, you're not a good dem; if you don't support Israeli policies, you're not a good Jew; if you don't support the war, you're not a good American... I thought her choice of language was appropriate to the subject.
Nice round up of the info.
What are your thoughts about her, Subir?
"We'll know our disinformation program is complete when everything the American public believes is false." ---- William Casey, CIA Director, 1981
I rarely use that kind of language in public
Buut that isn't a judgement. I understand why people are driven to curse at politicians. I think she's an activist, and I think that would have made it very difficult for her to effectively do outreach to the broader Jewish community hat holds a range of views on Israel. I don't like the concerted campaign to get her fired. That happens way too often to critics of Israel.
@subirgrewal
Why did you post this
if you didn't disagree with your premise, just didn't like her delivery? Cursing in public offends you? Well, fuck that.
Was there any other reason to post this other than to make Bernie look bad?
Any? At all? And or those who voted for him?
Do you realize most of the people on this site are likely to vote for Stein? Bernie is old news.
Or is he? You have a better tap into the line than I do.
Stop it. Don't do this.
Fight for Hillary up front and write why. Do it daily. But you need to stop this circumvention stuff.
Head on, subir.
Come on.
Head to head. Hand to hand.
"We'll know our disinformation program is complete when everything the American public believes is false." ---- William Casey, CIA Director, 1981
There's a problem with cussin' out Bibi?
I mean, the guy is a genuine asshole, and a cold, calculating one at that.
Yes, but in polite company we only call people assholes
through internal DNC emails.
To say it where the plebs can hear?
How gauche....
"I used to vote Republican & Democrat, I also used to shit my pants. Eventually I got smart enough to stop doing both things." -Me