Right Wing Caricatures vs. Reality Regarding the Perception of the Left-Wing

I'd like to start this post off by stating this: There is no effective left wing in the United States. Anything even resembling the left has been beaten to death time and time again throughout American history. The closest thing we had to a left wing government was from the mid 1930s to the 1960s and even then, back room deals were made to make sure that any left wing policy was as ineffective as possible.

These days, what passes for 'left wing' in the US doesn't even pretend to care about our issues anymore. Lip service is paid to issues like wage suppression, the continuing organized theft by the capital class in the guise of economic policy, womens' issues, LGBTQ rights, environmental degradation, single payer and so on. Of course, once elected, this same so-called left wing throws everything out the window with token resistance and cries of Republican Obstructionism. Oh, and don't forget the whole gradualism schtick, or as I like to call it 'You wait your fuckin' turn, peasants!'

We saw this happen time and time again. We were told 'it isn't that simple', 'it takes time', blah blah blah. Yet, these same empty suits were more than happy to get their hands on those corporate bribes and pass laws that go against everything they claim to stand for.

But none of this has stopped the reactionaries of the internet now known as the Alt Right from bitching about 'the left' anyway. In almost any news, political or general issue discussion video, comments like these are found throughout: "Stop white knighting for feminists!!!" "You're a libtard cuck!!" "The West is fucked because Muslims and the leftists sucking dick for them!!" "PC Dictatorship"....actually, the whole PC Dictatorship thing is in response to the fact that you don't see characters calling each other 'faggot' anymore on TV or people from disenfranchised groups gaining access to things they take for granted, but I digress. Oh, and don't forget the whole SJW bit either. Plenty of reactionaries still throw that one around for the sake of shutting down discussion.

That brings me to the caricature that these same folks often hold up as an effigy for 'the left'. The effigy was solidified when Hillary Clinton's campaign played the Injustice Collector card throughout the entire Democratic Primary. Nothing was off limits. If you didn't support Hillary, you were racist, sexist, a right-winger, anti-gay, tone deaf and any repudiation of Hillary's blatant faux-progressive populism was seen as a right-wing talking point.

Of course, if the right-wing reactionaries and the injustice collectors bothered to look even slightly past their own noses for a little bit, they'd realize that the left has had virtually no power in the States, and that any attempt to take any power at all is always met with brute force from both corporate and government goons. They'd also see that while groups such as feminists and Muslims (among many others the right-wing reactionaries shit on for sport) have their troublemakers, they aren't the folk demons that too many perceive them to be.

So what the hell do we do to take power away from the effigy? There are no easy answers here, but shutting the hell up and going away just to make a few people more comfortable isn't an option. That's what got us here to begin with.

See ya around,

Aspie

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

lotlizard's picture

Conne Island is a music venue, cultural center, and meeting place for the radical left in Leipzig.

Conne Island entry on Lonely Planet (travel guide site)

Run by a collective, this cult location has defined Leipzig nightlife for ages with concerts and club nights that feed the gamut of musical appetites — punk to indie, techno to hip-hop. It’s in the punkish-anarchist enclave of Connewitz.

At the height of the “refugees welcome” campaign in September 2015, Conne Island decided to offer cut-rate admission to refugees for only 50 euro cents (a normal patron might pay 10 euro). Many young male refugees took them up on the offer, and “reality ensued.”

https://www.residentadvisor.net/news.aspx?id=36828

The original Tageszeitung article referenced is here (text in German):
https://www.taz.de/Fluechtlinge-im-Conne-Island/%215344474/

There was an increase in theft, rules were going unenforced, and, worst of all, sexual abuse by migrants was going unreported or unpunished because people didn’t want to appear racist and, being part of the Left scene, didn’t want to give populists on the Right additional fodder for anti-migrant agitation.

Good intentions will backfire from time to time, it’s naïve to think they won’t. The loss for the Left and win for the Right here was, people on the Left’s unwillingness or inability to talk honestly and openly about migrant misconduct. The Conne Island plenum’s public statement calling for a new community discussion is an attempt to correct that.

up
0 users have voted.
Thaumlord-Exelbirth's picture

And they support twisted ideals of what are attributed to liberals. Like re-segregation. Don't know what else you would call "safe zones, schools, and areas exclusively for black americans." Then there's the whole extreme censorship thing, where anything at all that could be perceived as offensive in any way possible must be banned and censored, including things that are very mild, like "wimp," or "coward." No, I'm not making that up. There are people who actually want those words banned from all media.

It is worth noting that there are also right wing SJWs, who want to do things like ban any and all criticisms of the US, or of christianity.

up
0 users have voted.
The Aspie Corner's picture

Because if they actually cared about social justice they wouldn't be focused on the issues you lay out. Injustice Collector is a better term anyway.

up
0 users have voted.

Modern education is little more than toeing the line for the capitalist pigs.

Guerrilla Liberalism won't liberate the US or the world from the iron fist of capital.

Thaumlord-Exelbirth's picture

A warrior (or soldier) doesn't consider the consequences of what they do. They just have a goal, and fight toward that goal.

Besides, the name is stuck. Trying to change it now would be like trying to change the meaning of "nazi."

up
0 users have voted.
Lily O Lady's picture

by those on the left. We're it not for the fear of communism, I think we would not have had the New Deal.

I put the rise in inequality to the fall of Soviet communism, although TPTB seem quite content with Chinese communism, if it really is communism rather than the totalitarianism that both our major parties seem to favor.

Neoliberals are mainly committed to social issues so that they can, at times, paint themselves into a corner, as lotlizard has said happened in Germany. Ultimately this really hurts the true liberals/progressives/leftists while the neoliberals skate ever rightward out of harm's way.

up
0 users have voted.

"The object of persecution is persecution. The object of torture is torture. The object of power is power. Now do you begin to understand me?" ~Orwell, "1984"

The so-called "left" gets bashed mostly over culture war stuff, identity politics etc. Yet our priorities are economic. The biggest issue is wealth inequality and how it affects politics. Why did the Obama administration and a Dem-controlled Congress extend the Bush tax cuts for the rich, when they easily could have done nothing and let them expire? Why is Obama the first president since FDR who didn't obtain an increase in the federal minimum wage? Why did Obama convene the Catfood Commission to promote more tax cuts for the rich and benefit cuts for everyone else? The culture war is a distraction.

up
0 users have voted.

"We've done the impossible, and that makes us mighty."

for progress, accused the environmental movement as being "too white." Green Peace, The Sierra Club, and others have never been discriminatory and while it's true the majority of the members of The Sierra Club, to pick one, have been mostly Euro-American the organization has always been welcoming to all who share the goal of a sustainable environment.

It reminds me of the complaint against Senator Sanders that he was from Vermont, an overwhelmingly Euro-American state, so he couldn't know how to represent African Americans. (How's that Obama working out for African Americans?!)

The culture war, as was pointed out very well here yesterday by a poster, serves to divide wage earners when solidarity is what is needed. The 1% has the money; we have the people but have to overcome the distractions Big Money puts in the way of achieving an international worker movement.

up
0 users have voted.

"The justness of individual land right is not justifiable to those to whom the land by right of first claim collectively belonged"

There isn't much we need to do. The PTB will foolishly expend what value remains in this nation, and it will collapse from within.

Take the economy (please!). The war against the worker has again heated up. Layoffs are increasing, and the Fed threatens to raise interest rates. The Fed signal ALWAYS means more layoffs and reduced income for the working class generally. As we still have yet to fully recover from the 2008 crash, there isn't as much room to fall this time. It will hurt worse than the last one.

Take global issues. War remains likely with both China and Russia. There is no reason to think that it wouldn't go nuclear fast. But even if somehow that doesn't happen, it will be very bloody, more like the Pacific War than like Afghanistan.

Now throw in climate change. The deniers are having a hard time coming up with excuses as to why the scientists are wrong. they aren't getting the same play in the major media they once enjoyed as a result. But with the deniers quieted, there remains no meaningful effort to do anything about it. With much of the US farmland expected to be in deep drought for many years, food riots will become more likely, and the draconian laws pushed through the Congress beginning with Reagan and continuing with Obama will be invoked.

Power can only be maintained by the few as long as the majority acquiesces to their rule. Hungry people have nothing to lose against such forces. It will be seen as being better to die quickly than to endure a long starvation, and to take one of the oppressive bastards with you when you go.

up
0 users have voted.

Vowing To Oppose Everything Trump Attempts.

Bisbonian's picture

they're small.

up
0 users have voted.

"I’m a human being, first and foremost, and as such I’m for whoever and whatever benefits humanity as a whole.” —Malcolm X

Vote all you want. The secret government won’t change.
The people we elect aren’t the ones calling the shots, says Tufts University’s Michael Glennon
[link]

IDEAS: This isn’t how we’re taught to think of the American political system.

GLENNON: I think the American people are deluded, as Bagehot explained about the British population, that the institutions that provide the public face actually set American national security policy. They believe that when they vote for a president or member of Congress or succeed in bringing a case before the courts, that policy is going to change. Now, there are many counter-examples in which these branches do affect policy, as Bagehot predicted there would be. But the larger picture is still true—policy by and large in the national security realm is made by the concealed institutions.

IDEAS: Do we have any hope of fixing the problem?

GLENNON: The ultimate problem is the pervasive political ignorance on the part of the American people. And indifference to the threat that is emerging from these concealed institutions. That is where the energy for reform has to come from: the American people. Not from government. Government is very much the problem here. The people have to take the bull by the horns. And that’s a very difficult thing to do, because the ignorance is in many ways rational. There is very little profit to be had in learning about, and being active about, problems that you can’t affect, policies that you can’t change.

up
0 users have voted.

"Religion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich."--Napoleon