The NFL Has Managed To Diminish My Favorite Pastime

(Three years ago on the eve of the Super Bowl I published this at TOP. Thought I'd re-publish here today, in light of how the cross-section of fascism includes the massive pro sports industry residing squarely at the heart of corporatism and militarism. NFL coaches Rex Ryan and Bill Belichick are on record having publicly "endorsed" Trump, and the Fraternal Order of Police swung their weight behind him too. If you've ever been to a stadium for a game you can viscerally feel the political persuasion of the overwhelmingly young/middle-aged white, male working/middle class fan.

To that point, quick story: In 2004 I looked on the Jets schedule and to my utter amazement and shock saw that they would be playing their most reviled rivals the Miami Dolphins on Monday Night Football, the very night before the election. Shock because I knew the high profile event would compel me to face the fact that the opportunity was too great not to make a political statement. So I bought an American flag at the Army Navy store and spray-painted on it "Give Me Kerry or Give Me Death" (how naive I was then makes me cringe now) and went the stadium with a friend who is a great guitarist but also likes to box and lift weights, assured by him that no one would touch me.

Well, you know the score. The frothing vitriol was intense. Walking the parking lot in the early evening instead of the late morning of a Sunday game, which is always a cauldron of intensity under normal conditions, was ratcheted up several levels due to all existent factors. I began to think I might be pummeled beyond recognition. In the stands during the game was fraught with thick tension and animosity, a couple of times we stood we the flag hoping catch the attention of the MNF camera crew. I'm sure they noticed such an act, but didn't have the balls to air such a display of dissent, which was what I was willing to sacrifice for, hoping to sow some doubt about Bush among the millions of RW fans watching at home. Fuck 'em, I thought, they need to see dissent, and especially from one of their own, since football is very tribal. Nothing happened. But I was the object of scorn from every direction.

Richard Wolf made the observation this past Friday on his weekly radio show "Economic Update" that the NFL redistributes its profits so that every team has an even chance at making the Super Bowl. No matter which teams generate the most profit in ticket sales and merchandise, etc.

Well, wouldn't you know it. Who knew that the sport given to the most Right Wing and fascist tendencies would adopt fierce Socialist policy for the sustainment and betterment of its beloved, manly game? The NFL runs a socialist system.

Remember this as you watch (if you do) the game today: The NFL uses a socialist model of re-distribution of its profits. I may or may not be watching. Probably won't. given that the Patriots were caught cheating against my team and then again in a recent Super Bowl deflating the football for advantage.)

Football has been my favorite sport for many years. Some of my fondest memories are of going with my Dad as an 8 year old to high school football games he officiated on weekends; and for close to a 20 year stretch I hardly missed a home game at the Stadium to see the Jets. I played a little in high school and caught two touchdown passes on the day my JV high school team won its first game in three years for our small Catholic school - it was a thrill I still think about over 30 years later. There are few things to me that are as graceful as an airborne receiver making a diving catch with his body extended in a way the defies reality, or the fluidity of a running back running making tiger-like moves with agility, sheer power and stamina. I will even stop on the side of a road to watch a high school or amateur game.

However, I find the game as it is presented today by the NFL holds less and less favor to me. Not so much because of the game itself, though my enjoyment has been greatly impacted by the revelations of the Frontilne report “League of Denial,” but because it has been overshadowed by its caretakers’ decisions to militarize and corporatize almost every aspect of its presentation. The corporatization of football as a commodity to sell advertising is at the heart of the NFL today, it’s the engine room of a capitalistic society that demands profit over people every time. All manner of commercial ads, from beer to cars to fast food to banks, bombard the viewer throughout.I have come to loath consumerism, and it is impossible to separate it from the game.

Far more dangerous than the corporatization is the collusion with the military to neatly weave this creepy fascistic tapestry of nationalism, the military and football. If it makes you shudder to see old newsreels of stadiums full of Germans in the 1930’s pledging their fealty to the Homeland, it’s not very far off when multiple times during the Super Bowl one watches and listens to the many choreographed moments of militaristic and nationalistic imagery and theater resulting in orgiastic, ritualistic and ecstatic fervor. At the core of both events are notions of national superiority, false pride, violence and fear. George Carlin's classic piece "Baseball vs Football" cleverly describes the infatuation with military language, culture and names. "The quarterback aka field general,” has to be "on target with his aerial assault, riddling the defense, hitting his receivers with deadly accuracy, in spite of the blitz, even if he has to use the shotgun,” “with short bullet passes and long bombs he marches his troops into enemy territory, balancing his assault with a sustained ground attack."

The most obvious change has been in the Super Bowl Growing up I can’t recall holiday-like gatherings with feasts bigger than Thanksgiving and major, big-scale Hollywood production sets, not until the 80’s (yeah, that decade which was the worst culturally, politically and musically). Now every Monday Night game is a spectacle, as are each playoff game. And to think, the NFL made $10 billion this year. How are they considered a non-proft business? It is the same kind of mockery of Exxon/Mobil paying no taxes, or subsidizing farms not to harvest crops, or not taxing all financial transactions. When will the jig be up? We’ve been screwed, by a system run of, by and for the plutocrats.

Even the stadiums themselves have become high altars to consumerism. They feel like malls first, playing fields second. Shea Stadium, or whichever bank or corporations bought the rights for its name which I refuse to use, has become a vile and ugly faux heritage-style stadium. Being there twice when there wasn’t a game is when you see it in its nakedness. They’re now McStadiums, a place whose only purpose seems to be that from which to hang as many corporate banners as can be affixed. The last 20 years have seen many new stadiums, and for the most part they’ve conformed to this crass setup, with few exceptions. A seamless flow from shopping mall, to franchise food to sports stadium. Shop and eat, repeat. Shop and eat, repeat. A full stomach and an empty head, ready to be filled with advertisements.

Which makes sense. You’re no longer there to just watch a ballgame. You’re also there to shop, which in contemporary America means your ultimate civic duty. That’s as much as the last President said,, in response to 9/11. He went even further, offering specificity in a refrain familiar to any who watched football in the 80’s. That era could have been the beginning of the end, when we had to endure the banality of a player - engaged in the biggest battle of his career, being watched by hundreds of millions around, look into the camera and say “I’m going to Disneyland.” It’s surprising the team uniforms don’t yet have corporate logos on them like they do in Europe. Perhaps we shall hear I the not-too-distant future Al Michaels say, “This fourth down is being brought to you by All-State.”

So it’s no surprise that NFL franchises operate the way Corporate America does: if you don’t give us tax-free investment we’re gonna take our ball somewhere else. Corporations in all fields of business use this canard(see Boeing in Seattle now – which surely will get no mention on Sunday - and dozens and dozens of other companies). Threaten to move the operation to where there’s an offer of tax breaks and cheap labor. The American way is to depress worker wages and be rewarded with a windfall of money from a desperate small cities willing to fork over local tax money. It’s another form of outsourcing,; the only thing different is that the greedy monomaniacal businessmen owners can’t take the Patriots or the Redskins to Bangalore or Ho Chi Minh City. The one bright spot is the Green Bay Packers, who are owned by the people of the small city in Wisconsin, and not by some vainglorious .01%er looking to dabble in football for a little fun.

This Sunday I will at some point be thinking of how green with envy Leni Reifenstahl and Joseph Goebbles would be over the spell the NFL has cast over the American people. The mass indoctrination of American nationalism ranks for me as one of the most dangerous developments of the NFL. With this help from the NFL, non-stop warfare around the globe, corporate fealty and a lemming-like culture of consumerism is made easier.

The NFL, the tv networks and corporate America cultivate this fascistic union by weaving together American nationalism, consumerism and an obsession with the military all throughout the game. Every few minutes the announcers are telling you what the tv program is for the rest of the week (“Don’t miss tonight on Fox ----“), the ads come pouring in after every kickoff, change of possession, scoring play, carefully crafted to make you think of something you had no interest in or to gently nudge you to a favorable feeling for a product brand (allegedly the banks have been the biggest spenders this year… cue sympathetic music, video clips of diverse, multi-cultural people cooperating, gleaming shots of progress, etc – all from Goldman Sachs, who led the way in the financial meltdown). There will be a great attempt by the banks to makeover their image and the NFL is all too happy to oblige.

The screen will be filled with glittering images of giant American flags, fireworks, military flyovers and of course, multiple shots of military personnel. David Zirin of the Nation watches the Super Bowl every year with guys from the Iraq Veterans Against the War. “As the troops said over and over again, ‘this is about exploiting the soldiers for the purpose of selling the war.’” He also notes that the commercials “depend very heavily on selling women’s bodies.” The problem, he says, is that “you can’t separate the camera lingering on Kim Kardashian’s body to sell some product or another, and then the shots of the troops. It’s all sort of woven together in one large tapestry that says ‘Join the Army, sex, Rock n Roll, the Super Bowl, flyovers. It’s the same way you can’t separate Top Gun from Tom Cruise getting to sleep with Kelly McGillis. It’s all the same package. “ Even though I reflexively mute every commercial, including the in-between commercials from announcers which are cleverly thread throughout the broadcast, it is still pretty overwhelming.

The story of Pat Tillman should be remembered here too, because his tragic death was a result of that nefarious alliance . He met his demise literally in the crosshairs between football and the Army. Here was a dynamic, intelligent, well-liked standout defensive back for the Arizona Cardinals., who was killed by “fratricide” in Afghanistan. But that’s not what the Army wanted reported. They concocted a more “heroic” story, because they wanted to use him as the patriotic poster boy for the war. His family wouldn’t accept the company line and despite being stonewalled by every rank in the government concluded finally that he was killed by his own men. Tillman had also been reading Noam Chomsky. The ardor with which he left professional football to defend his country after 9/11 was waning as the reality of the war shone clearer to him on the ground. He had arranged to meet with Chomsky upon his return.

Another level-headed guy who also read Chomsky and willingly gave up his chance to be in NYC right now, reveling in the anticipation of playing in the Super Bowl on Sunday, is John Moffitt . He was playing for the 8-1 Denver Broncos when he quit in the second week of November, having had his fill of football and blocking for Peyton Manning who was on an unbelievable streak. He’s also a Buddhist. "I just really thought about it and decided I’m not happy,” Moffit said. “I’m not happy, and I think it’s really madness to risk your body, risk your well-being and risk your happiness, for money… How much do you really need? What do you want in life? And I decided that I don’t really need to be a millionaire.” Similarly, Dave Meggyesy, a linebacker for the St. Louis Cardinals in the late 60’s, decided he’d had enough too. Surprise, he was also a highly literate guy who concluded in his prime that football was “institutional violence,” comparing the game to the military, with its obedience to authority, the players plagued by fear and subservience to titillation.

Football, like the Army, depends on malleable, loyal pawns who for the most part don’t really take to literature, philosophy or politics. They’ll take guys like Dexter Manley, the All-Pro defensive end for the Super Bowl champion Washington Redskins who actually never learned to read until he was almost 30 years old. Just pushed through the system for his athletic ability, herded like cattle. In the minds of its superiors the Army and NFL functions more smoothly when the employees are incurious about the world at large. Maybe then they could use a guy like Mitch Daniels to run things. Remember that RW ideologue clown/former Governor of Indiana, who went on to become President of Perdue University? As Governor he attempted to ban Howard Zinn books statewide from all public colleges. Banner of books becomes university president!

I’ve noticed I don’t quite watch football the same way anymore. Especially after the Frontline investiagtions revealed the NFL’s denial and coverup of the epidemic of consussions. Every time a player goes down I used to just get up to grab something to eat or go to the bathroom. Now I imagine a guy closer to agonizing dark depression, memory loss and debilitated physicality in the years to come, the pain his family goes through.

These days it’s hard to see a professional football game as more than it being a vessel upon which Corporatism, Militarism and Sexism can attach their brands to, and not much more.

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

I was a San Diego Charger fan from the late 70's until last month, when they moved to LA for more money.

I decided that I required at least the superficial pretence of loyalty from the team. Otherwise, fuck them.

Now I'm not sure what I'll do.

up
0 users have voted.
Mark from Queens's picture

@gjohnsit Sorry to hear that, man. Must be disorienting, having been a fan for so many years.

I'm so fed up with everything concerning the NFL.

Used to take an annual football trip with 5 or so good friends, spend a weekend in a different city and go to a game. We were on our way to the R&R Hall of Fame in Cleveland, as it starting snowing, when we noticed a crowd assembled in front of the City Hall downtown, with signs protesting the sudden announcement that the Browns would be leaving for Baltimore at season's end. Was surreal. Needless to say at the game the next day was a mixture of stunned disbelief and roiling anger as it began to sink in. Hard to compare Cleveland's long storied history with San Diego with regard to football, but what was it like in town when the announcement was made?

How many teams has LA now had? The Rams, the Raiders, and now the Chargers? Par for the course for such a fickle place known for its transplants. Went to a Raiders game in the early 90's at the Coliseum. Felt so far away from the field; the place is too big.

Forgot to mention in the intro the latest installment of the ongoing propaganda of the NFL is now something about, "Football is Family." Caught in passing Bill Cowher in a clumsy attempt to admonish Kaepernick for his noble protest stance, finished by repeating the slogan, as if that settled it. I've come to see very clearly how all the pomp and circumstance of the game is such a huge turn off to me: the blazing Nationalism, the worship of the Military and the fire hosing corporatism in every nook and cranny.

I've precipitously watch less and less football these days; whereas in the past I'd never miss a Sunday with at least watching one game, many times 2 or 3. I don't think I'm going back, which doesn't mean I'll foreswear it forever, but that it's highly likely I will never engage with the sport the way I had.

up
0 users have voted.

"If I should ever die, God forbid, let this be my epitaph:

THE ONLY PROOF HE NEEDED
FOR THE EXISTENCE OF GOD
WAS MUSIC"

- Kurt Vonnegut

Pricknick's picture

all major sports are a distraction from what the ruling class is up to.
More people pay attention to what the modern day gladiators are up to while ignoring the corruption within their so-called government.
When it became too expensive for those who live nearest the current colosseums to attend, it became a waste.

up
0 users have voted.

Regardless of the path in life I chose, I realize it's always forward, never straight.

Mark from Queens's picture

@Pricknick Last decade, when the phony growth economy of Wall St was filling all the Get Rich Quick wannabes with thoughts of joining the Big Club too, the masses got a pretty rude surprise when the bread and circuses of American sports to which they were addicted began greedily charging astronomical prices for admission.

All of a sudden it seemed, a family of four couldn't go to a baseball game for under $200. Exorbitant ticket prices, luxury boxes for the wealthy apart from the rabble, ridiculous food prices, no permitting of outside food or drink, costly merchandise, unnecessarily expensive parking fees - it's a recipe for disaster. Attendance and tv viewership is down across the board. Instead of stadiums full of die-hard fans, of guys who worked all week and saved up, follow the team religiously, taking their kids along generation after generation, you now have glassed-in box seats for corporate criminals with which to impress their accomplice colleagues, leaving the stadium early to get in their limos to get whisked back to their palatial environs, safe again from the throng they know will one day rise up against their brazen ostentatious living.

Corporate greedheads in every sector are the ones who will usher in the revolution. Like you say, once the last vestige of distraction (sports) becomes out of reach for the common man to afford, as it did with the Romans, they will finally get the message. Or will they?

up
0 users have voted.

"If I should ever die, God forbid, let this be my epitaph:

THE ONLY PROOF HE NEEDED
FOR THE EXISTENCE OF GOD
WAS MUSIC"

- Kurt Vonnegut

Big Al's picture

Don't know if that's still happening but talk about ruining a game, having a war criminal psychopath honored right before kickoff?
If I watch it certainly won't be until after it starts.

up
0 users have voted.
Mark from Queens's picture

@Big Al Had a little flirtation during the playoffs with the comeback Packers, watching with an activist friend who is originally from Wisconsin. That's was fun. If they had made it I'd feel differently about watching. Going forth if I do watch, the Packers will be my team. The only team in all of professional sports to be owned by the citizens of its city. Most owners are RW extremists (i.e. the pick for Sec. of Education's family owns the Orlando Magic). David Zirin writes so well about the confluence of this in sports, as well as doing a great job explaining the untold history of dissent in sports (wrote a book on '68 Olympic Medalist John Carlos's radical activism).

But I don't feeling like watching, with that little tyrannical, Napoleonic, one-dimensional Belichick, the Head Cheater, and the nefarious crew of henchmen and kamikaze mercenaries he always seems to assemble around the preternatural, but also cheater, Tom Brady.

Too much RW influence all over the game in every way. It's practically an Ode to Fascism.

up
0 users have voted.

"If I should ever die, God forbid, let this be my epitaph:

THE ONLY PROOF HE NEEDED
FOR THE EXISTENCE OF GOD
WAS MUSIC"

- Kurt Vonnegut

OLinda's picture

America's obsession with the game was on display at the grocery store. I made the mistake of shopping for groceries today. More crowded than I've seen since... I don't know when. Longggest line also since probably ever. I have to think I was the only one doing regular shopping, and everyone else was there getting items for their Super Bowl Party. No other reason for it to have been so ridiculously busy.

Living in Denver Metro, I have learned the best time to shop is when a Bronco game is on. The stores are empty.

I forgot today, and should have waited until the game started.

Thank you for the excellent essay, Mark. I guess I got a little off topic.

up
0 users have voted.
Bollox Ref's picture

@OLinda

Food shopping is a breeze. Empty stores, and empty roads.

up
0 users have voted.

Gëzuar!!
from a reasonably stable genius.

gulfgal98's picture

We used to have season tickets to FSU before FSU really hit the big time. Heck, when I was single, I had end zone tickets when they were practically giving them away. Watching form the end zone was cool because you could see the plays develop. I was there during the 0-11 season. Then FSU became successful and all sorts of changes were instituted. Our season ticket seats were great ones that had been held by my husband's family for decades.

When FSU hit the big time, the cost of our seats went up. Then in order to keep them, we were required to give a donation to the boosters. That donation kept going up and all the folks who sat around us year after year were gradually being replaced by donors and corporate seats.

We used to buy two chicken boxes and carry them in with us to the game. That became forbidden and the cost of a cheap drink was at least $3. Food was awful and its cost was through the roof. A new stadium with many sky boxes replaced the old field. Parking, which was originally available on site, was non-existent unless you were a big donor. What was once a enjoyable outing became sterile and a pain in the butt. The last two years we had tickets, I quit going. It ceased to be fun.

up
0 users have voted.

Do I hear the sound of guillotines being constructed?

“Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable." ~ President John F. Kennedy

travelerxxx's picture

You've put into words how I feel about the NFL. Sadly, a lot of the same poisons which have infected the pros have trickled down. Here in Texas, it's trickled all the way down to the organized school games.

I still like to watch, but now I'm satisfied to pull over in my car and spend a little time watching some impromptu kids game in a vacant lot. When one of those is over, the players can all walk down to the corner store and get a soda together.

up
0 users have voted.

When teams like Golden State Warriors come to town, ticket prices for even the cheapest tickets go up. Same when teams with marque players come in. How can working class families afford the ticket prices without putting everything on a credit card? Even my stepson can only go to games when his investment house has extra tickets. He will only go if he can get two tickets, as he always takes his mother.

But all really mute for me, as I got rid of cable TV, and now cannot watch any sports online as logging into your cable TV provider is required. I am sure there are websites that will stream the stream, but those tend to be malware and virus traps.

up
0 users have voted.
karl pearson's picture

Thanks for sharing your personal story of NFL football and writing the following:

Far more dangerous than the corporatization is the collusion with the military to neatly weave this creepy fascistic tapestry of nationalism, the military and football.

I didn't realize the fascist/military components of NFL football, but where there is much corporate influence there is bound to be fascism. I used to watch a lot of major league baseball, but got disgusted after all the doping scandals. The whole professional sports environment has been repugnant for a couple of decades.

up
0 users have voted.

Now go look at College Football. Holy fuck.
No Socialism there. Young men, most of whom will never make the pros, earn a ton of money for their schools. They are "repaid" with an education. Nice. But nowhere near their value and that assumes they don't end up maimed for life as well.
I went to a Ta Nehisi Coates talk recently where he pointed out this as a minor point in his lecture. How much of our college campus's wealth has been built on the bodies of young black men? (As a majority of athletes in the money-earning sports are black and men).

up
0 users have voted.
Dark Knight's picture

He doesn't look well.

up
0 users have voted.

@Dark Knight

Hah, I hope he's hoping that there really is no god waiting to judge him after death... may the notion keep him up nights and lead him to make a full, public confession.

up
0 users have voted.

Psychopathy is not a political position, whether labeled 'conservatism', 'centrism' or 'left'.

A tin labeled 'coffee' may be a can of worms or pathology identified by a lack of empathy/willingness to harm others to achieve personal desires.

Lily O Lady's picture

brand new stadium, which replaced their decrepit 25 year-old stadium. The new Mercedes-Benz Stadium displaced two historic African-American churches.

Atlanta's water system experiences broken water mains frequently, but there are no plans to modernize the pipes, in spite of the fact that Georgia and Florida have been in a water war for years.

Our priorities are all screwed up.

up
0 users have voted.

"The object of persecution is persecution. The object of torture is torture. The object of power is power. Now do you begin to understand me?" ~Orwell, "1984"

jorogo's picture

Very thorough and wide-ranging, by far the most in-depth sports-related piece I'd never have even imagined.

I only peeked because I wound up in a serious snit, having wasted my evening watching that damned game in hopes of seeing the Patriots' Trump buddies lose. Instead, my hopes were dashed in a simulated replay of a couple other snit-fit inducing events, the recent election cycle (Bernie high hopes to Trump tragic fail) and the Packers' last minute playoff collapse and loss the the Seahawks two years ago, all occurring, IMO, under unfair circumstances.

We all know the Bernie-to-Trump escapade and all the self-serving players involved there, and no, I don't mean Vlad Putin. What burns me about the NFL is the playoff overtime rules, where a team that has accumulated the same points in regulation as their opponent, can literally lose the game on a coin toss. If you're not allowed to field your offense even once in the OT, it's just not a fair game, and the officials clearly point out prior to the coin toss that it's now a new game. If that's really the case, just put another 15 minutes on the clock, give each team one time out, and have at it. This is why, though I limit my sports viewing to one team in one sport, and I am a dedicated cheesehead, I have to consider how damaged even that one-note fanship is now.

Thanks too, for mentioning the Packers' owners. I had to sign some paperwork at a local bank last week, and could only just read "Green Bay Packers" on some framed document on the bank official's wall. Turned out to be a much-desired stock certificate - I was doing business with a Packers owner. Gave the whole transaction a higher level of satisfaction for me. Hope the Pack, and the United States too, are someday soon, back.

up
0 users have voted.

"If I sit silently, I have sinned." - Mossadegh

Song of the lark's picture

A grand spectacle of our bodies hearts and minds.

" panem et circenses. Latin, literally "bread and circuses," supposedly coined by Juvenal and describing the cynical formula of the Roman emperors for keeping the masses content with ample food and entertainment."
The drama surrounding the games interests me but I don't watch it. I caught about 20 minutes of the 2 quarter last night... At my moms 90th birthday and then the last minute or so. I gather that evil incarnate won at that last minute. Seems like it's going to be a record year for up ended assumptions.
I do understand people addiction to the spectacle. It has everything humans love. Institutionalized violence, passion , tribalism etc as mentioned above so cogently. The darker side which fascinates us also, the money , the body morphing, and self damage are huge in our way of life. Pills for everything.
When things go bad as they are sure to do so. The spectacle and crowds will fade or change. I hear some soccer stadiums in the Middle East have been used for prisoners, or executions.
What goes on now will seem romantic , glorious and with faded nostalgia.

up
0 users have voted.

has been corporatized too, so I guess American football is just going with the flow. To survive in shark infested waters, ya gotta be BIG. Or too small to bother with, one or the other.

I get a kick out of watching professional boxing. It's maybe the most money-corrupted sport there is, but it's still fun to watch. There must be something in the human genome that is attracted to physical confrontations between highly skilled combatants. Maybe it comes from millennia of people fighting wars with one another tooth and nail. Or maybe it's even older than that.

According to Bob Dylan,, "This world ain't ruled by democracy, you better get that through your head / This world is ruled by violence, but I guess that's better left unsaid." Anyway, it's far better for men to get all aggressive on a football field or in a boxing ring, than on a real battlefield.

up
0 users have voted.

native

Steven D's picture

@native or "Mixed martial Arts" is replacing boxing as the most popular "combat" or "martial" sport. Far more violent - kicks, smaller gloves for punches, choke holds - in a literal cage structure - the Octagon. Extremely brutal. I thought boxing was bad, but MMA is much worse. It is almost to the point where the corporate sponsors will want to add knives and other weapons and go full gladiator.

up
0 users have voted.

"You can't just leave those who created the problem in charge of the solution."---Tyree Scott