Corruption, reciprocity, and the influence of money

Bernie Sanders' message about corruption is a significant part of his campaign. He speaks forcefully about a system in which legislation and political favors are essentially bought by donations from large donors. He does not call out any individuals as such. There's a good reason for that: the kind of corruption Bernie is talking about isn't bribery. It's a systemic corruption that relies on the concept of "reciprocity": a person's sense of obligation or indebtedness to a person who gives him or her a gift. An individual doesn't have to "be corrupt" in order to facilitate and propagate systemic corruption if it exists.

This isn't as well studied a phenomenon as some others, but there are studies about it. NPR had a recent story that indicated it's at work in our health care system. Physicians prescription habits are closely correlated with the funding they receive from pharmaceutical companies. The same phenomenon reaches an "extreme" point in politics when bribery or campaign funding violations occur.

In our political system, corruption does exist and it is systemic. Studies show that wealthy, connected individuals and lobbyists (funded by the wealthy) have a near monopoly on our politicians' attention. This isn't because they're the only ones trying, it's because they're the ones who control the funding and media for politicians. They also influence strongly political parties' support, and therefore have a hand even in selecting candidates to run for office. This kind of corruption isn't always explicit bribery or influence peddling. It's tacit, implicit; an "unwritten rule" that everybody who's anybody just knows and absorbs.

So when Bernie brings this issue up in debates or at rallies, he's not talking about his opponent as an individual who is corrupt, but about a system in which the kinds of political funding she takes has a corrupting influence. It's a real problem, and it's self perpetuating. There are ways to reduce its impact on our political process. One is to have a candidate who inspires lots of small donations, as Bernie has. However it's too easy to get cash the corrupting way (on purpose), so this isn't sustainable. Changing this systemic corruption will require a radical change to the way our elections are conducted: they must be free, and entirely publicly run and funded.

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

The Clintons are as dirty as they come and so is the system. Anyone who tries to cut either any slack for what they are, won't find me as an ally.

up
0 users have voted.

"Religion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich."--Napoleon

Bernie may not call Hillary corrupt explicitly, but he accurately and fearlessly describes the system in which she thrives as corrupt. In order not to be corrupted by the system, you have to not take its money. For this reason, you can count those in Congress or the administration who have been uncorrupted by the system on your fingers.

Corruption has long been my most important issue, because the corrupt system creates -- or prevents solving -- almost all our other problems. One of Bernie Sanders' greatest contributions to our politics has been to name the corrupt system for what it is. Most Americans know this, but the opinion shapers in the media maintain a rigid silence on this truth. Bernie is telling people what they already know but never hear. That might be the biggest reason why he's trusted in a deeply untrustworthy profession.

up
0 users have voted.

Please help support caucus99percent!

Phoebe Loosinhouse's picture

of doing good and instead they end up doing well (for themselves). And look at how many of them end up as lobbyists as their golden parachute out of politics.

I have come to believe that having an entrenched long-term or life-long political class is not a good thing and I think I have to put myself on the side of term limits. Yes, we lose some experienced good people, but term-limited Reps and Senators would bring back much closer to the citizen/legislator model.

up
0 users have voted.

" “Human kindness has never weakened the stamina or softened the fiber of a free people. A nation does not have to be cruel to be tough.” FDR "