Resilience: Democratic-Socialism & Appropriate Tech Revive A Rural Town

Resilience1.jpg
Would you like to find ways to make your local community more resilient, more viable, more self-sufficient? Democratic-Socialism emphasizes appropriate technology to develop local communities, especially in rural areas. We'll look briefly at E.F. Schumacher's chapter on Appropriate Technology in Small Is Beautiful. Then we'll look at the example of a small town in Bavaria, called Wilpoldsried, which macgyvered its way out of where corporatist "development" had left it for dead and into a profitable future using Renewable Energies, the very best appropriate technology for small communities. More below.

Might as well listen to Jack Johnson.


My understanding of democratic socialism comes from a famous book that came out when a young Bernie Sanders was forming his economic philosophy: Small Is Beautiful (1973), by the post-WWII British economist E.F. Schumacher. It is subtitled "Economics As If People Mattered." It is not a textbook, there's no technical language, or math (or any Marx), but a book of popular economics aimed at the general readership. I have read it a number of times and have made a summary, mostly in Schumacher's words - there's lots of excerpts. I cut out the 70's rock...

Part Three deals with the matter of development in the emerging world.
Now, why would the emerging world be important for our towns' becoming more resilient?
Because the lessons from corporatist failure in global "development" apply also to our local towns: since the 70s, corporatist globalists have "developed" our local communities in exactly the same way they distorted towns in the emerging world. In chapter twelve, Schumacher addresses the the need for appropriate technology in developing rural towns ("intermediate" in 70s terminology.)

Twelve - The Development of Appropriate Technology

Schumacher summarized his thoughts on the technological aspects of development as follows:

1. The "dual economy" in the developing countries will remain for the foreseeable future. The modern sector will not be able to absorb the whole of the undeveloped economy.

Not much has changed since then. Most developing economies still have huge disparities between their developed and developing sectors. Since the 70s, corporatist globalism has created in rich countries as big differences between wealthy areas (that profit from globalism) and poor areas (destroyed by globalism).
The historic scourge of civilizations (apart from climate change) - great inequality - has hollowed out the rich world almost completely.

2. If the non-modern sector is not made the object of special development efforts, it will continue to disintegrate. This disintegration will continue to manifest itself in mass unemployment and mass migration into the metropolitan areas; and this will poison economic life in the modern sector as well.

Schumacher would be unsurprised by the disastrous acceleration of these trends over the decades since. It has continued in the emerging world and has destroyed vast swathes of rural America.

3. The poor can be helped to help themselves, but only by making available to them a technology that recognises the economic boundaries and limitations of poverty.

The poor - in the emerging and the rich world - need appropriate technologies.
Our dying rural towns need appropriate and local technologies to become more resilient.

4. Action programmes on a national and supranational basis are needed to develop appropriate, sustainable technologies suitable for the promotion of full employment in developing countries.

Neo-liberal developmental programmes - such as those of the western countries, IMF, World Bank, etc., - tend to create projects that favour the local elites rather than the poor. How this surprises anyone is a mystery: corporate capitalism is by and for western elites. Of course they would just replicate their model in development projects.

What would it look like for a local community to embrace the route of appropriate technology to develop out of the capitalist trap into resiliency and a democratic-socialist economy?

The example of Wildpoldsried

The village of Wildpoldsried in southern Germany is an example of a town that used RE to develop itself by its own bootstraps.
Ortsansicht_Wildpoldsried.jpg
Wildpoldsried, Germany (Wikipedia)

Wildpoldsried is a small agricultural village, which has a population of 2,600 and prior to catching the RE vision, there were no industries or jobs. Today, the village produces 321 percent more energy than it needs. What does it do with the excess? Well, it receives $5.7 million in annual revenue by selling it back to the national grid. Not bad, eh?

Here's the town's 2014 energy generation (Erzeugung) versus usage (Verbrauch). Bear with me, I read German at the elementary school level.
Wilpoldsried RE Gen vs Use.jpg
(http://www.wildpoldsried.de/index.shtml?Energie)

Im Jahr 2014 wurden im Gemeindegebiet 30.440 MWh Strom regnerativ erzeugt.
Der Verbrauch im Gemeindegebiet lag bei 6.323 MWh ( - 2,4 % zu 2013)

in 2014, Wilpoldsried produced 30.4MWh of RE:

  • 0.055 from the water treatment plant,
  • 8.561 from the biogas plants,
  • 5.034 from the PV panels, and
  • 16.789 from the wind turbines

and the town used barely 6.3MWh (which was 2.4% less than the previous year.)
Wilpoldsried energiedorf.jpg

How did this happen?

In 1997, a new village council was elected and it decided on the following goals:

  • to build new industry,
  • keep initiatives local,
  • bring in new revenues, and,
  • create no debt.

Luckily, it found itself in Germany, one of the most RE friendly countries in the world, where federal and state governments run several initiatives to support RE development on a consistent, ongoing, wildly successful basis.

In 1999, the Village Council crafted a mission statement — WIR–2020, ‘Wildpoldsried Innovativ Richtungsweisend (Wildpoldsried Innovative Leadership) — which became the blueprint for how it should consider its citizens’ demands, community projects and future development and growth. In turn, the council hoped that the guidelines would inspire people to get involved, begin thinking greener and create jobs and businesses for the community.

The W.I.R – 2020 focused on three main themes:
1) Renewable Energy and Saving Energy;
2) Ecological Construction of Buildings Using Ecological Building Materials (mainly wood-based); and
3) Protection of Water and Water Resources (both above and below ground) and Ecological Disposal of Wastewater.

Source:BioCycle magazine https://www.biocycle.net/2011/08/16/german-village-achieves-energy-indep...
Wilpoldsried wind turbines.jpg
Wind Turbines (www.biocycle.net)

Energiedorf (meaning Energytown) Wilpoldsried

In the years since 1997, the village has built:

  • nine new community buildings complete with solar panels,
  • four biogas digesters with a fifth under construction,
  • seven windmills with two more on the way,
  • 190 private households equipped with solar,
  • a district heating network with 42 connections,
  • three small hydro power plants,
  • ecological flood control, and, a
  • natural wastewater system.

Wilpoldsried biogas plant.jpg
Biogas Facility (www.biocycle.net)

Wildpoldsried has become known far and wide for its innovation in RE and the accompanying jobs it created. The village has several B&Bs for visitors and hosts regular energy tour groups.
The community leaders are invited all over Europe to give presentations on their success.
It has become a model for successful transition to RE and a low-carbon, sustainable future.
Wilpoldsried natural wastewater treatment plant.jpg
Natural Waste Water Treatment (www.biocycle.net)

Is this model feasible in North America, with it's corporatist bias against rural development and RE?
More difficult than in RE-friendly Europe, but possibly yes.
The key for Wilpoldsried was the federal and Bavarian subsidies for RE. Could North American local communities receive such subsidies? They could in Ontario, where I live.
But the 50 U.S. states have 50 different points of view on RE. You tell me.

Could a North American local community that has the vision, as the 1997 Wildpoldsried town council had, carry it out even without subsidies in hostile U.S. states? Could it find other agencies to help offset the initial high RE costs and so provide the bootstrapping to turn the town around? I don't know enough to guess.

What do you think? Are there local communities in North America on this same RE trajectory? I welcome your thoughts, ideas, and experiences.

Peace be with us, if we use appropriate tech, like RE, to transform our local communities,
gerrit

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

Martha Pearce-Smith's picture

is being discussed in the Resilience Group actually being in practice around the world... and yes, IMO, IF communities employed the Community Rights techniques that we have been discussing, I think it is HIGHLY possible to accomplish these things not only in small towns but perhaps in big ones too.

Thanks Gerrit! This is a great example of just how we can fight back against the damn MegaCorps...

up
0 users have voted.

Please help the Resilience Resource Library grow by adding your links.

First Nations News

Gerrit's picture

NGOs with experience in helping local communities fight off the corporatists and change their towns through app-techs like RE.

We don't need to wait - for feds, for Bernie, for state/prov govs, for the gods, or Moses, for anyone else. We can just do it. Any and all of us - well, us introverts and mental-health-challenged perhaps more in the engine room :=) Have a great day, my friend,

BTW, I saw in a Council of Canadians email that community orgs + the COC made a big push against energy East in North Bay this week. That's how local communities fight off the corporatists! Very cool.

up
0 users have voted.

Resilience: practical action to improve things we can control.
3D+: developing language for postmodern spirituality.

Lookout's picture

I think we here in the states find corporate power difficult to overcome. I get power from a rural coop. You would think they would encourage local power production. However they refuse to buy or exchange power from local producers. There's pretty good potential for solar production here in Alabama. Currently they buy cheap power from the nearby TVA (the largest gov't corporation, whose CEO is the highest paid gov't official at several million/year). Short term profits lead to short term thinking. I also think it's a control issue. They want to be the one source, and if we move to solar they want to dictate how much and when.

We have great potential. I think we will have to seize it for ourselves. I do largely heat my house with the sun using solar hot water and radiant floor heat.

up
0 users have voted.

“Until justice rolls down like water and righteousness like a mighty stream.”

Martha Pearce-Smith's picture

what you are doing the sooner we can drive the corporations off....if they are not making profits they will leave...and leave the field wide open for consumer driven, grass roots innovation. By using as little of the corporate products as we can we can STARVE them out eventually.

up
0 users have voted.

Please help the Resilience Resource Library grow by adding your links.

First Nations News

Gerrit's picture

local communities. It's our only hope:

In our town X, if you want to run a business by date Y, it must be in the forms of single owner, partnership, or cooperative; no corporations allowed in our jurisdiction.

Then we work at helping all the local business owners who conduct their business as corporations convert their legal form as no-hassle as possible.
And we help buyers of the franchises find local financing.

And we take the short-term hits for long-term gain. And the gains will be rapid, if we have done our homework on using app-tech to revitalize our town locally, from the ground up.
Wilpoldsried did so. So did Totnes. And Lewis. And scores of others.

Our biggest problem is a lack of vision. Our minds have been formed by our corporatist culture and society, and we cannot even imagine what is possible. They have converted us from the eagles we were to fat, grounded, blind turkeys, bred for food and reproduction only in corporate-farmed suburbs.

Enough is enough.

Our second problem is a lack of courage. We have allowed them to enslave us and enmesh us so deeply into their matrix that we are scared witless of action. We prefer to babble on endlessly about things we cannot control; for it provides us with the safe illusion of protest while changing nothing. All the sages of every era have said that real change begins with us - with me first, within me first. Only when I am changing first, can I change my world without. We must move ourselves off from the safe, consequence-free perch of outrage into the many places within ourselves where change is required: first in vision, then in personal courage to act. Oh good grief, listen to me rattle on! Lunch is over, back to the garage :=) Until later, my friend,

up
0 users have voted.

Resilience: practical action to improve things we can control.
3D+: developing language for postmodern spirituality.

Gerrit's picture

with it. It's real high on our list. I was just looking at a realtor listing for an acreage in North Ontario where the RE is already in like lots of others up there. The hydro network just doesn't penetrate in rural areas that far north (north of Timmins, Ontario, famous for producing hockey players and Shania Twain :=) it would be so cool to buy the property with RE already in!

You're right: where corporate power is too big or the local mindset is too rigid, we have to do it ourselves, from the ground up, one house and one local community after another.

We're now working on getting a grip on our electricity usage. In the next place, first job in our house is insulation, then solar hot water and radiant heating - like you have done, then PV & wind.

Thanks and enjoy your day. Oh yes, I loved that Bernie fly poster :=)

up
0 users have voted.

Resilience: practical action to improve things we can control.
3D+: developing language for postmodern spirituality.

Haikukitty's picture

We're adding a bedroom, and we don't have the ability to do the water radiant lines, but there are electric versions. I had radiant floors in an old rental, and I loved it. I'm wondering if you came across it in your research when you got your floors, although you might have done it long ago.

up
0 users have voted.
Lookout's picture

I just don't know about it. FLWright used electric radiant, so its been used for a while. Baseboard radiant is another option to consider.
Here's Home Depot descriptor:
http://www.homedepot.com/c/how_to_install_radiant_floor_heating_HT_PG_FL

up
0 users have voted.

“Until justice rolls down like water and righteousness like a mighty stream.”

Haikukitty's picture

I'm going to look into it further. Its not all that large of a room, more's the pity, but I believe it would be fairly affordable to cover the area with electric coils over ceramic, and from what I've read, installation isn't very difficult.

up
0 users have voted.
Gerrit's picture

at Home Depot Canada and chatted with one of the sales rep. But I haven't done any proper research. They should work well, depending on their manufacture. If you have decently-priced electricity, it should be financially doable too, eh.

The reason I didn't pursue electric radiant heat further was because I wondered about losing heat in a power outage in a grid-connected house. Here in Canada, the solar hot water systems run on glycerol. I want to connect the hot-water tank and radiant-floor heating from the same solar rooftop coils.

I think though, that electric radiant-heat in a grid-connected system could work fine if there is a big genny back-up. In our present, grid-tied house, I have a 50A 11KW diesel genny and wonder now if it would run an electric-radiant floor system, in addition to the nat-gas furnace, hot water tank, the freezers and fridge, and a few outlets.

Thanks for a real interesting question, Haikukitty. I hope some of our more tech-savvy friends could comment for us on this question.

up
0 users have voted.

Resilience: practical action to improve things we can control.
3D+: developing language for postmodern spirituality.

Haikukitty's picture

I'll do some more research. Just hoping someone had actually had some experience of them. I'm stuck with electric for the forseeable future. And we can't even get solar, our tree cover is too dense. But our electric is pretty affordable, and we have oil backup for heat in winter. BGE allows us to specify our energy provider, and I've chosen one that is 100% sustainably sourced by wind and solar, and that's the best I can do for now.

I'd love to get the radiant flooring heat in the bedroom on a switch of some kind, and then we could basically keep the house heat at 50 and heat the bedroom at night only. We're looking at ceramic flooring in there, which would help keep it cool in summer, and in winter, with the floor heating, would keep it comfortable when its cold.

up
0 users have voted.
Gerrit's picture

ceramic tiles with the wires inside is, like you say, a double-bonus - for both big-expense seasons. I hope we get some tech-savvy comments, but it should work in your situation. Radiant floor heating is a brilliant solution because it gives so much better indoor climate control throughout the year. I'm sure Lookout has that benefit with her system. If you proceed with the project, I sure would be keen to hear more about it all. Maybe I could install it here as a selling feature :=) Best wishes with it. Hooray for you,

up
0 users have voted.

Resilience: practical action to improve things we can control.
3D+: developing language for postmodern spirituality.

LeChienHarry's picture

Our old house had a lot of tree cover even though the roof pitch direction was great for solar. We love our Oaks.

But it turns out that the PV panels can be mounted elsewhere, as in our case the south facing slope of the garage roof.

The DC power was converted to AC by an inverter mounted just below the roof trusses and on a panel with a small electrical panel which fed outlets, lights and the door opener and the feed to the main house pane.

The run to the house which is a separate building did not diminish the power through line loss because AC travels well and it wasn't too far. This can be calculated.

Lacking a ready-made roof, a structure like a carport or storage area, roofed patio, can be made for the purpose.

Best luck.

up
0 users have voted.

You may choose to look the other way, but you can never say again you did not know. ~ William Wiberforce

If you can donate, please! POP Money is available for bank-to-bank transfers. Email JtC to make a monthly donation.

LeChienHarry's picture

We had wire loop put in standoffs made for the purpose in the quickset under the tiles. A wall-mounted controller can be used to set for certain times and heat amount.
There are two under tile types of direct electric heat: mesh or snaked wire. We opted for the wire type as not all areas needed to be heated evenly.
It's very solid, and flexible. It does help if your electrician has used it and the tiler know how to work with it.

up
0 users have voted.

You may choose to look the other way, but you can never say again you did not know. ~ William Wiberforce

If you can donate, please! POP Money is available for bank-to-bank transfers. Email JtC to make a monthly donation.

Gerrit's picture

big TY for these tips. Enjoy your weekend, mate,

up
0 users have voted.

Resilience: practical action to improve things we can control.
3D+: developing language for postmodern spirituality.

LeChienHarry's picture

customer paid for monthly, bragging how they had gone with the other coops in the state to the legislature to ask to be excluded from the aid to local producers that the for-profits had been participating in. They won their lobby efforts and were excluded from supporting renewables, solar, wind and insulation.

While they are technically a non-profit, they sure act like one. They did put an old analog meter on our line so that when we generated more than we used, the dial would actually go backwards. We have summer months with no bill. They were convinced we couldn't generated enough to make a difference.

Well fourteen panels rated at 3.4 kw we would exceed the rated generation in February.

I actually got a couple of the employees interested in rooftop solar once they understood what we could do.

We got some Fed and state tax deductions but couldn't use them all. $19K for the system and engineering; $6.5k was up to us over four or five years with the tax deductions.

We didn't save money at .06 cents/kwh (hydro is cheap), but we cut down our use by 4-6,000 kwHrs/annually. Overall we started at 21,000 KwHrs/year and with all the insulating, wiring, energy saver appliances got down to 8,000 KwHrs/year.

Feels good. Added bonus was as an all electric home with heating from zoned mini split heat pumps we were required to put in a solid fuel stove. We opted for a Hearthstone Tribute: a tiny soapstone and wine enamel beauty, which could heat the whole house on a 30 degree day. We loved that little ball of warmth, and had a breakfast area where we could sit and watch it. Very efficient and extremely low pollution. No particulates as it had three burns in the box before anything went up the flue.

Cool beans.

up
0 users have voted.

You may choose to look the other way, but you can never say again you did not know. ~ William Wiberforce

If you can donate, please! POP Money is available for bank-to-bank transfers. Email JtC to make a monthly donation.

Gerrit's picture

is high on my list of "looking for advice." I've now make a note of the Hearthstone Tribute, to go look up it's specs. A soapstone and enamel stove; looking forward to learn more. Big TY for all these examples and tips, my friend,

up
0 users have voted.

Resilience: practical action to improve things we can control.
3D+: developing language for postmodern spirituality.

Sandino's picture

is the kind of thing that the TPP will outlaw. Showing favoritism to a local company over a multinational benefitting from distant sweatshops would be grounds for a suit under ISDS, which would be decided by unelected, unaccountable private arbitrators.

Just recently, a WTO panel has ruled that the domestic content requirement (DCR) imposed under India’s National Solar Mission (NSM), is inconsistent with its archaic treaty obligations under the global trading regime. The requirement in question mandates a percentage of components to be sourced locally, to boost homegrown production of solar cells and solar modules.

This is another reason why another President Clinton would be so deadly.

up
0 users have voted.
Gerrit's picture

I hope you're having a great day, mate. I don't know if folks understand this, but the time for a political revolution is Right Now, before the TPP becomes the law of Earth. There will be only one type of revolution after TPP. We'll be needing the second coming of revolutionary general George Washington.

I'm fairly sanguine about TPP. I think the coming fascist takeovers in many European countries will kill European unity, install trade-protectionist policies, and leave North America and Asia to TPP itself. The first domino is Austria last week. The Nordics are having lotsa problems with the fascists. Greece and the rest of the European underbelly will follow soon. And the odds in France are shortening, eh.

But our job is to get cracking on the political revolution and on personal and local community resilience. I've got more of these local success stories somewhere in my mac's gizzards :=) Gotta go find them! Best wishes, my friend,

up
0 users have voted.

Resilience: practical action to improve things we can control.
3D+: developing language for postmodern spirituality.

LeChienHarry's picture

up
0 users have voted.

You may choose to look the other way, but you can never say again you did not know. ~ William Wiberforce

If you can donate, please! POP Money is available for bank-to-bank transfers. Email JtC to make a monthly donation.

Sandino's picture

fuck 'em.
USA USA USA!

up
0 users have voted.

watching a video clip in j.s.'s evening blues post. It was an example of the failure of our society to invest in basic and simple infrastructure for a First Nation community in NW Ontario. I was astonished and horrified by this story. I know this same thing happens in the U.S. The thing that is tragic is that this problem is easily solved and so unnecessary.
This Resilience thread is relevant in so many ways. If all of us plumb the depths of these ideas as much as possible, we can solve some problems. Thx as always.

up
0 users have voted.

referenced by j.s. in his evening blues post. Your post here Gerrit goes so well with that clip since it is an example of exactly what you are talking about.

I love your success story example for juxtaposition. The German town of W. (I forgot how to spell it) It's inspirational and shows us in no uncertain terms how it can be done.

up
0 users have voted.
Gerrit's picture

Lake clip and it's in our news cycles now. You're right, RE could lift Shoal Lake, Attawaskapat, and all similar First Nations communities out of the cycle of poverty that racist corporatist governments have inflicted upon our First Nations brothers and sisters.

Like you say, these disasters are tragic and unnecessary, there is lots of ways RE and other app-tech strategies could transform local communities suffering under corporatist and racist rule. Every local community could benefit from learning more about Wilpoldsried's ER success story. Thanks for this and enjoy your day my friend,

up
0 users have voted.

Resilience: practical action to improve things we can control.
3D+: developing language for postmodern spirituality.

MarilynW's picture

Remember the Department of Indian Affairs and Northern Development?

"Indian" was changed to "Aboriginal" by the Conservative Stephen Harper Government but I had questioned why energy and resource extraction should be in the same department as Aboriginal Affairs? Maybe if there were a department of Aboriginal affairs with a focus on the people, the First Nations would be better off.

The official new name under Justin Trudeau is Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada.

up
0 users have voted.

To thine own self be true.

Gerrit's picture

Enjoy your evening, my friend,

up
0 users have voted.

Resilience: practical action to improve things we can control.
3D+: developing language for postmodern spirituality.

Gerrit's picture

Enjoy your evening, my friend,

up
0 users have voted.

Resilience: practical action to improve things we can control.
3D+: developing language for postmodern spirituality.

Martha Pearce-Smith's picture

up
0 users have voted.

Please help the Resilience Resource Library grow by adding your links.

First Nations News

I was actually thinking of you when I was watching this because you were the one who brought my attention to the issue of First Nation communities and their suicide rate.
It is all interrelated with poverty, lack of opportunity, and lack of investment by the larger community. We can and we must do better.
Thx for your attention to all of this and your work on this Resilience thread.

up
0 users have voted.
Martha Pearce-Smith's picture

I will watch it presently.

I really am happy to be helping out with the Resilience Group. I think it has a lot of promise of helping to bring about a great deal of change.

up
0 users have voted.

Please help the Resilience Resource Library grow by adding your links.

First Nations News

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KHOJ0c2izbo
A community in need of basic infrastructure.

up
0 users have voted.

Or even if I should. I'll be happy to try if that's what you mean Smile

up
0 users have voted.
Martha Pearce-Smith's picture

not sure this is truly Resilience material but it certainly is part of the First Nation's News series...

up
0 users have voted.

Please help the Resilience Resource Library grow by adding your links.

First Nations News