b'tzelem Elohim

In case you don't speak Hebrew (I sure don't), the title phrase translates to "In God's Divine Image."

Now, I'm not religious, identifying as Taoist if asked, but I'm always interested in contextualizing the attacks made by the religious right against trans people. One of the more recent attacks has been that God has a limited view of gender.

Gender identity confusion should not be exploited by social activists — like those in the Obama administration — who want to deny the God-given distinction between the sexes.This is a rebellion against God's plan.

The Bible says 'God made them from the beginning male and female.' Not male, female and question mark. God has determined how many sexes there are—there are two, not three.

--Robert Jeffress

Fortunately, people like Jeffress do not have ownership of religion. Southern Baptists are not the only game in town.

In May the Rabbinical Assembly, which is an international association of Conservative rabbis (to allay confusion: in Judaism, "conservatives" are the center-left moderates, with reform jews on the left and orthodox on the right.) approved a resolution stating

Our Torah asserts that all humanity is created b’tzelem Elohim, in God’s Divine Image.

Including transgender people. All is all.

For Max Guttman, an educator and self-identified trans Jew, the news offered relief after a life long struggle with gender identity. For Guttman, religious holidays often carried the burden of dressing up in traditionally feminine outfits.

I never felt more like I was lying than [on Yom Kippur], the day of atonement, when I needed to be unmistakably feminine to be respectful.

--Guttman

The resolution acknowledged the struggle of transgender Jews and the broader discrimination that exists toward transgender people in society — particularly in the realms of health care, employment and retirement benefits. It called upon synagogues to adopt certain accommodations that will protect the rights of all people regardless of gender or sexuality.

The Rabbinical Assembly encourage all Conservative Movement synagogues, camps, schools, and affiliated organizations to work toward becoming explicitly welcoming, safe spaces for transgender and gender non-conforming people and evaluate their physical site needs, workplace needs, and language that impact gender and gender expression.

--the resolution

Due to recent events in the United States, and the emerging issue of transgender persons’ rights, members of the Rabbinical Assembly felt it was time to deal with the issue of transgender persons or gender non-conforming persons exclusively.

--Rabbis David Baum and Edward Bernstein, resolution committee

The Reform movement passed a similar resolution last year.

Since Talmudic times, our people have recognized that the human condition is not just binary.

I hope this resolution will go far in promoting this deep truth of our religion in our society and in the world.

--Rabbi Gil Steinlauf, Adas Israel Congregation

Guttman calls the action by the Conservatives to be tikkun olam (world repair) in each paragraph

I don’t believe there was opposition to it at all. I think it really comes out of a basic set of values, to see the infinite and equal worth in every human being. I think it speaks very directly to Jewish values. This is one of the examples of how the Torah’s fundamental values keep reasserting themselves as society grows and matures.

--Rabbi Julie Schonfield

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

Bisbonian's picture

but it looks like there are a few other groups that 'get it'.

up
0 users have voted.

"I’m a human being, first and foremost, and as such I’m for whoever and whatever benefits humanity as a whole.” —Malcolm X

enhydra lutris's picture

up
0 users have voted.

That, in its essence, is fascism--ownership of government by an individual, by a group, or by any other controlling private power. -- Franklin D. Roosevelt --

Meteor Man's picture

Here on Skid Row we have a church without walls http://www.therowchurch.com

where the preacher has a little bit different take on the Good Book.
Just last week he made the observation that in most homes the first room you enter is the living room where you welcome guests. So why is it that the very first room most American preachers wanna talk about is the bathroom? For some of them they head straight for yhe bathroom and it's like they get trapped there. They talk about sex and body parts like there was only one commandment instead of ten.

Rather good point I thought.

up
0 users have voted.

"They'll say we're disturbing the peace, but there is no peace. What really bothers them is that we are disturbing the war." Howard Zinn

wilderness voice's picture

and create a Diety in their own image, who curiously has all the same prejudices.

Props to the Rabbinical Assembly for getting this right.

up
0 users have voted.
Haikukitty's picture

by it's very nature of being a higher being, I have to assume it will not hold the narrow, prejudicial views of a lesser being.

Fundamentalists basically worship themselves in the form of God. Whatever they believe is right is right and what they believe is wrong is wrong, therefore, obviously, God also believes those things are right or wrong.

If I ever discover there is a divine being, I would be horribly disappointed to find out she thought just like a human. What a depressing Divinity. Which has always been my main issue with the Old Testament God. I wouldn't tolerate that guy if he was my neighbor, much less worship him. And I reached that decision at round 6 years old.

up
0 users have voted.
RejectingThe3rdWay's picture

For the record I am a reform Jew and am very happy that they continue to show people the light that you can hold religious values and not use them as an excuse to hate on people.

To the part of your comment & the diary topic that sparked an interesting thought.

If I ever discover there is a divine being, I would be horribly disappointed to find out she thought just like a human.

I am going to have to disagree with the word she.

If we are all (as in EVERY PERSON) made in G-d's image (use of wording to specifically avoid pronouns), then is it possible that cis-men, cis-women, are just literally 1/2 of G-d's image. Is it possible that trans-people are actually MORE CLOSER to G-d's image having some of both M/F componets (body,soul,personality)?

Like I said just a thought that popped into my head reading the diary and your comment.

P.S. I am a cis-male and hope I haven't offended anyone with this

up
0 users have voted.

When I was a kid, Republicans used to red scare people, now it's the Democrats. I am getting too damn old for this crap!

"Is it possible that trans-people are actually MORE CLOSER to G-d's image...."
You might be on to something and I might bring this up next time I find myself in the company of my fundie relatives.They always talk about 'love and compassion for our fellow man/woman'but in reality they condemn everyone who doesn't think as they do.
Whatever happened to 'live and let live'?

This diary reminded me of something that happened a lifetime ago when my son was about 5yo .One of my nieces took him to her church,against my wishes and knowing very well how I felt about church etc. He came home with a picture of a little boy and the caption read: " I'm special 'cause G*d don't make no junk"

up
0 users have voted.

" El pueblo unido jamás será vencido. The people united will never be defeated "

Technically, Elohim is derived from the Sumerian language and it is plural. So it means in the image of the Gods.

Hebrews, Christians, etc. like to gloss over that Genesis doesn't actually refer to a singular god, but says we were created by the Gods in their image.

up
0 users have voted.
lotlizard's picture

up
0 users have voted.

That an invisible hand guides the markets and socialism is evil, that people on welfare are lazy and teenagers should just abstain from sex.

up
0 users have voted.