Johnstone on the lameness of US Politics
US Politics Is Just Nonstop Fake Revolutions Now
It’s so silly how American politics is just nonstop fake revolutions now.
Millions flooded the US streets for the “No Kings” protests over the weekend to oppose a monarchy which does not exist without making a single tangible demand. Power was not challenged in any meaningful way. The status quo wasn’t disrupted in the slightest. People held up some signs saying the president is orange and that if Kamala were president they would be at brunch, and then went home.
The whole thing was just one big pep rally for the Democratic Party, designed to accomplish nothing beyond getting American liberals excited about the prospect of someday voting for Gavin Newsom. A bunch of boomers showed up to dance around and hold signs and feel as though they are fighting the power in their feely bits, while drumming up support for the same status quo which gave rise to Trump in the first place.
You see the same fake revolutionary astroturf zeitgeist on the Republican side. American rightists are constantly pretending they’re fighting some kind of populist rebellion against an oppressive establishment even while their party controls every branch of the US government. They act like Trump is ending the wars and fighting the Deep State even as he stomps out free speech on behalf of Israel, rolls out a Palantir surveillance system, pours weapons into facilitating Israel’s genocidal atrocities, bombs Iran and Yemen, ramps up for war with Venezuela, and perpetuates the horrific proxy war in Ukraine.
It’s two plutocrat-owned warmongering imperialist parties whipping their respective bases into the mass delusion that they are participating in a heroic act of revolutionary defiance by voting Democrat or Republican. They get everyone fighting a fake revolution so that nobody thinks about fighting a real one.
It didn’t used to be this way, for the record. The US has been a murderous and tyrannical oligarchic bloodbath for its entire existence as a nation, but up until fairly recently its politics looked more or less like the politics of other western nations. Politicians had campaigns where they’d try to argue that they have the best policies, there’d be an election, and then they’d spend their time in office philandering and pretending to make themselves useful. There wasn’t this constant LARPing about how voting for one of the two mainstream parties is participating some kind of a courageous insurgency against monarchy or communism or the Deep State or whatever.
That’s changing because public discontent with the status quo is soaring to all-time highs as Americans get poorer and everything gets shittier. The establishment order is no longer accepted and people are starting to push for real change, so their outrage needs to be harnessed and corralled into politically safe directions.
Donald Trump’s entire political career has been all about this. He introduced a new WWE-style kayfabe theatrics into American politics where both Democrats and Republicans feel as though they are fighting the power in a very important and relevant way — Republicans because they believe Trump is a populist rebel and Democrats because they believe Trump is an unprecedented threat to freedom and democracy. Really his whole thing is about protecting the status quo of the US empire, but both mainstream factions are duped into seeing the exact opposite.
Now you’ve got the two main strands of American political thought falling all over themselves to be the first in line to support the establishment, all while being told that they are fighting the power. They remain mollified because they think they are doing something, and the powerful get to keep everything they’ve stolen.
It’s truly a brilliant scam. Evil, destructive and tyrannical, to be sure, but you’ve got to admire the skill with which this psyop has been pulled off.
In my opinion, Caitlin is right on the money here.
The bolded paragraph spells out the wrestling connection that is almost totally ignored by almost everybody with an opinion about The Orange Fart Cloud.
Most of the commentary on Trump, whether pro or con, embraces the premise that Trump runs the country by dint of his own "ideas," aka whims
His nonstop whim is to be the biggest deal on earth, no matter how. Most of his criticism helps him get there.

Comments
Very weird this astro-turfed
.
demonstration
and how the sheeples respond
A pic from yesterday's affair ..
(after all, this is Rhode Island)
Clown show.
Zionism is a social disease
You may see it as a clown show
But those people get my vote as the ones less likely to be beaten with batons or shot with rubber bullets. And though they probably can't flee very fast, can you imagine a storm trooper tackling a guy in a duckie suit.
He would be laughed out of the police station and have to endure years of ribbing.
I think it's kinda brilliant.
But that's just me.
Neither Russia nor China is our enemy.
Neither Iran nor Venezuela are threatening America.
Cuba is a dead horse, stop beating it.
Several friends
tried to get me to go to the protests. I declined.
But apparently there were even some international protests that went along- this picture is reputedly from a No Kings protest in Scotland. Whether true or not, I approve most wholeheartedly.
I also like the idea of the inflatable costumes as a brownshirt-confuser. Apparently, somewhere in Portland, there's a place that is actually handing out the inflatable frog costumes to those who are willing and motivated to go do the protest thing...
Legit protest doesn't do anything any more, and hasn't in years, but a good mocking might still have some impact.
One can always hope.
Twice bitten, permanently shy.
I'll bet King Charles
kept a really low profile yesterday.
Heh.
Neither Russia nor China is our enemy.
Neither Iran nor Venezuela are threatening America.
Cuba is a dead horse, stop beating it.
I attended the one in Utica.
I guess my check from Mr. Soros must be still in the mail.
There were about 3000, a not insignificant number in a mostly conservative, purplish town.
Michael Wolf was on air with his weekly Brit Twit interviewer, complaining about how "No Kings" was a dumb, abstract slogan and gatherings across the country were a bad idea, there should have been One Big Protest in DC. Nice, Micheal. Only those who have the means to fly to DC and pay for accommodations once there deserve to be heard, Mr. Wolf?
The more usual kind of demonstration being referenced by Johnstone above simply Does. Not. Work. anymore. TPTS can and will promise anything to get a crowd to disperse. Then someone introduces a bill which gets sent to committee and is never heard of again. I like the No Kings slogan. It is simple and easy to understand, and it reminds people who we are. We are a people who govern ourselves under the Constitution, which we can amend if enough of us want.
In my view, the target of these gatherings was not the President or his DC fan club, at least not directly. I think it was partly to let our MAGA neighbors know they haven't intimidated us. Another target was collaborationist Democrats, to let them know we are no longer interested in voting for go along to get along. I grant you, they are not yet getting the memo, see for example Chuckie Schemer's intervention in the Maine senate primary.
Mary Bennett
I agree with much of what you have to say
"No Kings" is a catch phrase and nit picking its word choices is cheap sophistry. I have no quarrel with it as either a label for a new movement or a policy idea.
I also like the local focus of your comment. Planting your flag is a necessary First Step to building a movement that accomplishes anything. Let the other side know that you are real. Let uncommitted people know that you are real, too.
Nevertheless, I agree with Caitlin that this particular event has very little to show for itself other than as a first step. If and only if this has legs, it could be very useful.
We'll see if skepticism is in order.
I cried when I wrote this song. Sue me if I play too long.
Reuters just reported
that the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that the Cheeto can indeed send the National Guard to Portland, after all.
It is my strong belief that he's looking to kill a few people to set examples, and perhaps to make his little willy stand up. After all, it has worked so well in Gaza and Venezuela, this extrajudicial-killing thing. And the so-called "opposition" shows no interest whatsoever in stopping him- or even doing a token, performative, strongly-worded letter.
So if you are in Portland: check your six, early and often. No smiley.
https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-appeals-court-allows-trump-send-troo...
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/10/20/trump-troops-por...
Twice bitten, permanently shy.
On Emmanuel Todd's Substack there appeared this amazing piece
Hitlerism, Trumpism, Netanyahuism, Le Penism, Macronism
An observation:
He predicts:
People might wonder from time to time why Max Blumenthal does what he does. Here's a motive: survival. Blumenthal hopes to put off the Day of Reckoning.
Oh, and as for Trump, now the primary instigator of genocide according to Todd?
Trump is, in short, the heel, and the WWE crowds cheering on his every move are cheering the heel. But, unlike WWE, the politics of empire in decline has a lot more to offer in the way of consequences than an occasional murder-suicide. And we're going to see those consequences soon.
"'Cause everything in the world we're living in is all made up and we can make it up different" -- Carsie Blanton
Katie Fang had an interesting legal observation
Concerning the "presumption of regularity" in the constitutional functions of the executive branch. The record of the Trump DOJ in the federal court system showed something like 38 cases that fell into the category of the lawyers for DOJ presenting false factual allegations or other deceptions or misrepresentations onto the courts. A second category was totally arbitrary and capricious decision making by the executive branch. The third category was outright disobedience of court orders. This in fact represents the destruction of the federal government itself. There were at least a couple of dozen cases in the last two categories. She cited the resignation of the chief of the DOJ immigration section as potentially a good sign.
A key process in the totalitarian consolidation process is the destruction of all the traditional government structures and institutional traditions to achieve effective centralized control by the party movement cadre. This process is well underway in the legal world as it is abused and destroyed in the party's pursuit of absolute power. The same is true of society's traditional civil institutions, media, universities, school systems, state governments, police, military departments, and investigative and regulatory bodies. These will all be coerced to submit to the movement. The Doge attack on federal structures, and the attack on the institutions of the first amendment were the early stage. The second stage is the attack on cities and states by militarized police with characteristic "low signature" profiles, no badge numbers, no names, masks etc., characteristic of secret special forces. The normalization of military or military like personnel in city streets with automatic weapons, body armor, etc., characteristic of dictatorships is well underway.
To a certain extent this may be viewed as a futile observation, but the argument is, that the executive is no longer entitled to a presumption of regularity, but has in fact, earned a "presumption of irregularity." In other words the institutions, customs and traditions of the government itself either no longer exist or are in the active process of being deliberately destroyed. I would argue the titular head of government no longer exists in the civic sense. There is only the movement leader and his inner circle.
The resistance of lower level Federal judges is important morally and constitutionally, as it implies a civil existence and secular order still has potential, but the reality of the Supreme Court, indicates that such a prospect has a clouded future. This court may ultimately go the way of courts in Nazi Germany. With regard to the legislature, It is actually preferable to the movement that the government be "shutdown." It will collect taxes, impound monies, spend, hire and fire, whether Congress is in session or not. Why provide a platform for opposition no matter how feckless it is contended to be? No opposition is tolerated, period.
The WWE manipulation of spectacle has application as it based on the concept of mass mind or mass id, understood in the literature of propaganda and totalitarian movements. In the later, government is irrelevant, only the party, the so called "movement" and its representation of reality, that is its mythic structure, matter. The cadre matter far more than the followers as they proceed in the destruction of civil society as well as government to suit the party tastes. The followers feel empowered by the symbolism and slogans of the movement, "stop the steal," MAGA, China Out, and the associated racism and xenophobia. The destruction and renovation of the white house, symbolizes the superiority of the movement to the institution and its tradition.
Meanwhile, minorities, immigrant communities, etc., as the sacrificial victims of the movement, live in fear. As they are publicly attacked and taken off to concentration camps by militarized thugs in the streets, appropriately televised widely, a general atmosphere of terror is created. The executions and genocide abroad further terrorize the domestic mass mind. The government shutdown, firing of government workers, cancelation, or threatened cancelation of government benefit programs, health insurance subsidies, etc., create the sensation in the public at large, except for the truly wealthy, that the ground beneath their feet is falling away. The inner movement cadre are clearly following a technique, formula and script articulated by earlier totalitarian leaders. imo
I'll leave the observations on the US religious far right for Hedges. It's a minefield. I know the party movement related NGOs, KPAC, CPAC, and people directly tied to the party inner circle in the US are supporting the far right Christian groups in South Korea against the elected democratic government. They carry stop the steal, pro Yoon, anti China signs, wave US flags, Israeli flags, etc. Signs in English are often carried. They are regarded as heretics by the mainstream religious conferences in South Korea.
The Unification Church and the Sarang Jaeil Church (led by demogogue Pastor Jeon Gwang-hun) and the Moonie like Sincheonji Church are cults. The younger people who support the far right causes are actually relatively low in number in South Korea, and are provided by these organizations for street demonstrations. political campaigns, who actively recruit them, house them, pay them and transport them. Most far right evangelical believers are elderly in South Korea who come from Christian congregations similar to those that supported the South Korean dictatorships.
語必忠信 行必正直