The forgotten black working class

Politicians and the media generally like to talk about the middle-class.
On the rare occasion that any of them mentions the working class, they always put the word "white" in front of it.
It leaves one with the impression that blacks are a monolithic entity, and thus are single-issue voters. This impression, which does the black community a tremendous disservice, breaks down under close examination.
It turns out that blacks are as interested in kitchen-table issues as whites are.

But in an election where racial rhetoric was so prominent and pointed – and where the first black president exhorted voters to choose Hillary Clinton – Trump’s showing came as a surprise. Among black men, Trump won 13 percent...
“I’d much rather have a guy look me in the eyes and tell me what he really feels than try to tell me what he thinks I want to hear,” he says. “That’s a man whose hand I’ll shake. And that’s why I have no worries about Trump.”
The data don’t point to a “success” for Trump in courting black voters, but they do point to important nuance. For some black working-class men, like Melendez, Trump’s economic rhetoric resonated more than his racial rhetoric. In short, like their white working-class counterparts, they saw in Trump the man who would bring back their jobs and their dignity.

This should be surprising to no one except for white liberals.
A far higher percentage of African Americans than whites are working class, and have been historically.
Black American wealth was absolutely crushed over the past decade. If current trends continue, median wealth for black Americans will fall to $0 by 2053. That's a crisis by any definition. A crisis that liberal Democrats like to put into a non-economic context.
wealth_0.jpg
There is a political cost for ignoring this crisis.

Eighty-four percent of the 582 working-class African-American voters in central Ohio that were interviewed by Working America say they disapprove of Trump’s job performance. And 26 percent have engaged in a political action since Trump was elected. That’s a higher proportion than Working America found among white Clinton voters when they surveyed swing voters in central Ohio in March. But of the black voters surveyed only 33.9 percent said they were familiar with the term “resistance.”...
Given all that was at stake, why did black turnout for 2016 election drop 10 percentage points to 61.8 percent in Ohio? Working America canvassers found that the people they interviewed were suffering economically and did not think the government would help them, or that having a Democratic president would make a difference.

The attitude of the Democratic establishment is that black America is all about racial issues, and economic issues won't resonate with the black community. That's why Bernie Sanders' focus on economic issues will fail to attract black voters.
Recent polls have shattered that myth.

The lack of nuance that white liberals have in viewing the black community can be seen in the issue of immigration.

Measures of economic self-interest more strongly account [than estimated collective-interest] for the opinion of African American members of the working class when compared to their middle-class brethren … [and] it appears that class membership is a more powerful force in shaping the attitudes of Blacks in comparison to Whites

For African Americans who lost a job to an immigrant, working-class membership resulted in a 13 percentage point increase in the probability of support for an increased federal role in workplace oversight [against employment of illegal immigrants] when compared to middle-class African Americans who experienced a similar loss.

Working-class African Americans are significantly more supportive of policies that seek to: decrease the number of immigrants coming to the United States, increase the federal role in verifying the employment status of immigrants, and attempts to amend the Constitution’s citizenship provisions.

immigration.png

This is the danger of the Democrats' full-embrace of immigration.
They lightly disregard the white working-class rejection of open immigration as they are all racists.
But how does that work with the black working-class rejection of open immigration?
How does that work with the historic rejection of open immigration by the black working-class?
It doesn't make sense on a skin color spectrum. It only makes sense on a class-based spectrum.

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

Anja Geitz's picture

They lightly disregard the white working-class rejection of open immigration as they are all racists.

It's been eye opening seeing the identity politics play out the way it has the last two years. But if were brutally honest with myself, I would've agreed with the "my side" prior to 2016 election about those "racists" immigration stances without even scratching the surface to see if there might be another reason why working class whites were against open immigration. Or even if there were two reason existing at once.

up
0 users have voted.

There is always Music amongst the trees in the Garden, but our hearts must be very quiet to hear it. ~ Minnie Aumonier

@Anja Geitz
Along with religious heretics.
So I distrust anyone blaming them for our problems.

Nevertheless, there is a non-racist reason to not want mass immigration.

up
0 users have voted.

@Anja Geitz The eye-opening has been at many levels.

I had perceived identity politics as a well-meaning (despite awkward side effects) result of class politics being pre-empted by Right wingers' appeals to White working class racism.

When Bernie proved that this channel of pre-emption can be overcome, it was a shock to see identity politics itself used so widely and zealously to pre-empt class politics.

The only way this could be seen as "well-meaning" is that recent generations of Democratic political 'leadership', Black as well as White, is willing to be as "mean" as necessary in order for them and their friends to "do well". Whatever desire they once had to "do good", for working class Blacks, has been deeply buried by the economic and psychological rewards of resisting a transition to class politics.

up
0 users have voted.

american understands the situation quite well.

up
0 users have voted.

The earth is a multibillion-year-old sphere.
The Nazis killed millions of Jews.
On 9/11/01 a Boeing 757 (AA77) flew into the Pentagon.
AGCC is happening.
If you cannot accept these facts, I cannot fake an interest in any of your opinions.

snoopydawg's picture

" If current trends continue, median wealth for black Americans will fall to $0 by 2053. "

Will we humans even exist in 2053? All kidding aside, I'm not surprised by this. I had read that the economy for blacks sucked during the Obama administration. But how many of us saw our economic position get better during his tenure?

Given all that was at stake, why did black turnout for 2016 election drop 10 percentage points to 61.8 percent in Ohio? Working America canvassers found that the people they interviewed were suffering economically and did not think the government would help them, or that having a Democratic president would make a difference.

I can see why they felt that way. And why they voted for Trump. The same reason that others voted for him. What did they have to lose by doing so? We've seen how voting for democrats have worked out for us. Trump was offering his brand of hope and change.

up
0 users have voted.

Was Humpty Dumpty pushed?

@snoopydawg
and he pointed out how Social Security isn't just extremely popular with the white working class, it's extremely popular with the black working class too.
Same with Medicare, unemployment insurance, public school teachers, etc.

When you target a certain group for a program it's human nature for everyone else to say, "What about us?"

When you make a program available to everyone, even if some groups use it more than others, there isn't the resentment.

up
0 users have voted.
snoopydawg's picture

@gjohnsit

I'd like to see the people who are so against people who are on food stamps and the other social programs to realize that people are on them for various reasons such as they were injured, had medical problems that cost lots of money that they were prepared for, are elderly and other issues and if they had the chance to be working or they didn't have other issues they would be.

The comments I read are so dismissive and hostile because they really do believe that people are lazy or just don't want to work. They seem to not have read that many people who are on them are already working and sometimes more than one job.

I think some of it is racist though. They think that it's black moms who are on them because dad is in prison and things like that. And they are the type of people who believe that unions are bad for company's profits, when the reality of what unions have done for them is unknown.

The 99% really do have a lot in common with each other.

up
0 users have voted.

Was Humpty Dumpty pushed?

thanatokephaloides's picture

@snoopydawg

The 99% really do have a lot in common with each other.

And far more in common with each other than with the 0.1% who own damn near everything!

up
0 users have voted.

"US govt/military = bad. Russian govt/military = bad. Any politician wanting power = bad. Anyone wielding power = bad." --Shahryar

"All power corrupts absolutely!" -- thanatokephaloides

Strife Delivery's picture

It leaves one with the impression that blacks are a monolithic entity, and thus are single-issue voters. This impression, which does the black community a tremendous disservice, breaks down under close examination.

The forgotten black working class

I would posit that the working class in general is forgotten; however, if I had to push back some, I wouldn't say that the Black working class is forgotten.

Either folks say working class or someone will throw in white working class.

Who ever talks about Native American working class?
Asian working class?
Any other working class?

To me, it seems to be WWC or working class which then gets referenced to AA's.

up
0 users have voted.
mimi's picture

may be because it's too painful to remember what the black working class once was in the US.
If you need a reminder that any working class folks are feeling and thinking similarly, just look to Africa or Europe. They all have similar reactions vis a vis working class people and immigrants and they all react tribal. That is not the same as racist, but people can't help to acknowledge that and don't admit that tribalism is innate to all races. Just my two cents on tribalism.

up
0 users have voted.
The Aspie Corner's picture

We have never had anywhere to go but the very bottom in terms of employment. Sure, sometimes employers might hand a decent job to a disabled person if only to keep the money they get from the feds rolling in, or for PR purposes, but it never takes very long for us to outlive our usefulness in their eyes.

Take a look at the average job posting of something almost anyone could have gotten 15 years ago and it's easy to see nowadays that they want the impossible.

up
0 users have voted.

Modern education is little more than toeing the line for the capitalist pigs.

Guerrilla Liberalism won't liberate the US or the world from the iron fist of capital.

thanatokephaloides's picture

@The Aspie Corner

We have never had anywhere to go but the very bottom in terms of employment. Sure, sometimes employers might hand a decent job to a disabled person if only to keep the money they get from the feds rolling in, or for PR purposes, but it never takes very long for us to outlive our usefulness in their eyes.

That's tokenism. The token disabled guy. Best if neurotypical and in a wheelchair.

Take a look at the average job posting of something almost anyone could have gotten 15 years ago and it's easy to see nowadays that they want the impossible.

That's almost any decent job, not just disabled folks.

I sometimes wonder why the employers go to the trouble; they publish jobs with requirements no real human could hope to meet. And then complain when applicants lie on their applications to get them.

up
0 users have voted.

"US govt/military = bad. Russian govt/military = bad. Any politician wanting power = bad. Anyone wielding power = bad." --Shahryar

"All power corrupts absolutely!" -- thanatokephaloides

The Aspie Corner's picture

@thanatokephaloides

That's almost any decent job, not just disabled folks.

I sometimes wonder why the employers go to the trouble; they publish jobs with requirements no real human could hope to meet. And then complain when applicants lie on their applications to get them.

Not to mention most employers want drivers' licenses before they'll even talk to you.

up
0 users have voted.

Modern education is little more than toeing the line for the capitalist pigs.

Guerrilla Liberalism won't liberate the US or the world from the iron fist of capital.

Strife Delivery's picture

@thanatokephaloides

I sometimes wonder why the employers go to the trouble; they publish jobs with requirements no real human could hope to meet. And then complain when applicants lie on their applications to get them.

Well, part of it is the PR lie scam of it too.

Look at the visas. Throw out lies that they aren't qualified people in the US (a lie), post jobs with outrageous requirements, then import workers for 1/3rd normal wages.

up
0 users have voted.

When are we going to learn that open immigration is not inclusive, it is an intentional policy to impoverish working people for the benefit of the employer class?
When are we going to learn that identity politics is not about social justice, it is a strategy of generating resentment of women and blacks and immigrants and gays - whoever the "social justice warriors" are "fighting for"?

up
0 users have voted.

On to Biden since 1973

Roy Blakeley's picture

@doh1304 is that the reasons that many people want to come to the US have to do with the fact that the US creates or condones the awful governments and conditions that have driven people to leave their countries. I have a great deal of sympathy for many undocumented aliens, but let's withdraw the US support of right-wind narco-dictatorships and neo-liberal pseudodemocratic governments, and lets reform trade agreements that screw over small farmers in Latin America. Too much of the Democratic Party establishment seems to want to ring its collective hands over these poor immigrants, while being perfectly happy to see that the conditions that caused them to leave their countries persist and and to take advantage of the cheap labor they are forced to provide.

up
0 users have voted.

@Roy Blakeley
so my experience was a little different. Most of the immigrants I worked with were middle eastern and eastern european and Brazillian. It was pretty much the same though, but also I saw it as a play to racism - when the drivers were mostly born Americans the public supported us, but when immmigrants exceeded the American born there was an extreme flip in support.

up
0 users have voted.

On to Biden since 1973