I am a Victim of Violence (or why I wrote "No, This is Not Effing Okay)
[video:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WpqJ-wWcCU8]
Shorter version:
When I was in my early 20s I was beaten twice while living in a gay neighborhood. Once coming out of a gay bar.
The other time I was beaten unconscious when I was cut off by a van in the same neighborhood and rear ended them. While I looked for my ID they pulled me out of the car and kicked the shit out of me. Saved by a Taxi driver who saw them do it. All three were white Aryan brotherhood types with criminal records for violent crimes. I don't know if they assumed I was gay (I am bisexual) or not, but I was in the hospital for a week because I lost my balance and could not walk. That and a lot of cuts to my face that required stitches.
So I have a understanding about what it is like to have a target on my back.
The three men who beat me unconscious? The one with the worst record got away and the other two blamed him for all my injuries. I was the only witness who had a close look at them but all I could recall was the boots one of them wore. Same boots he wore at the Prelim hearing at which I testified. The two who were arrested got off. No one gave a damn about informing me of that decision by the prosecutor because at the time I was a poor likely faggot in their minds, or so I believe.
The other beating was by some random guy, and I was too scared to tell the police about it (the ones who stood outside the bar) because I was told it would only get me in trouble. This was about 1980 or 81. Not happy memories.
I made a choice to no longer explore my sexual attraction to men. I married a woman I met in Law School, a person I love and care about very much and we have stayed together through 30 years, good and bad and raised two children to adulthood. I repressed the memories of the violence inflicted upon me, but the scars to my psyche never really went away.
When I began blogging at Daily Kos and Booman Tribune, I found myself attracted to stories of people who were victims of violence, whether from war, the police or hate crimes. It wasn't the only subject upon which I focused, but it did amount to a significant number of the stories I posted online, from US military attacks on Iraqi citizens, the use of torture by our government in the "war on terror," police violence against minority communities, especially African Americans, to any hate crime I came across, including those committed against LGBTQ folks and women.
So, when I see a story about violence done to anyone, it acts as a trigger to bring back those memories of when I was a victim of hate and violence. Obviously I did a poor job yesterday of communicating that fact as my principle motivation for writing about my friend's assault. It took reading the comments to my essay here, and at the the links to it I posted at the reddit sites K4S and The Way of the Bern, for me to recognize why this particular incident involving someone I knew personally triggered such a strong response in me. I took a great deal of time last night thinking about my own personal history to understand that my need to tell my friend's story was triggered by the physical violence inflicted upon me by people motivated by hate.
So, that's why I wrote about the attack on my friend, and why I made this video today detailing my own personal history of violence. If you take anything away from this post or my YouTube video, please, make it this:
Don't treat stories about these recent attacks as merely one more instance of "identity politics" that you can dismiss out of hand as not productive to "moving forward" or demonizing Trump voters, etc. Because, when you do that, you dehumanize the pain and suffering of the victims of this violence. And this applies to people who have been attacked for supporting Trump just as much as it apples to my friend, or to the many members of racial and religious minority groups who have come under attack in the wake of Trump's victory over Clinton.
Try to see the people who are being assaulted, abused and harmed in the aftermath of this ugly election season as real human beings like you and me. People who have suffered bodily harm in the wake of this recent post-election wave of violence, or who may have been threatened with physical harm. All of them are likely dealing with mental torment, from anxiety and panic attacks, to depression and feelings of guilt and shame, that very well may stay with them for the rest of their lives. Recognize the reality of their suffering.
That's all I'm asking of you today.
Thank-you.
Steve
Comments
Thank you for this
It's not identity politics to be horrified by this kind of violence and empathetic to the victims, regardless of who they are or why they were attacked. These are the threads that hold us together as thinking, feeling human beings and we forget them at our peril.
The smaller the mind the greater the conceit. --Aesop
Thank you Steven D
To be sure, the attack on me that I detailed in your other thread was not the only physical attack...I am, in fact, very aware of the ways, reasons, and justification these attacks come in...which is why...yes, I am one scared motherfucker right now who's not entirely trusting or believing anything that anyone has to say at this point in history...and no, I never went to the police with any of these attacks...
...so...no, you aren't the only person triggered by some of these things
Steven--
I think there's a very deep, very important discussion to be had here. But it's also one that could explode in our collective faces, which is why I didn't respond to your diary.
Short version: we're in a trap. We're supposed to choose between bigotry and corruption, no other choices. Basically, the establishment has got a hostage situation going here: "Back off, or the Black guy/gay guy/Latino immigrant takes it in the face!"
"More for Gore or the son of a drug lord--None of the above, fuck it, cut the cord."
--Zack de la Rocha
"I tell you I'll have nothing to do with the place...The roof of that hall is made of bones."
-- Fiver
I don't disagree with you...
and, of course, "the Black guy/gay guy/Latino immigrant takes it in the face!" regardless of the choice, in this specific situation...
I do probably take a somewhat longer and more historical POV on the corruption piece, though...among other things...
EDIT: I also think that much of the public is far more tolerant of bigotry and/or corruption than we like to admit to.
58% unfavorables for Trump--
60% for Clinton.
At the time of the election.
So 58% disapprove of bigotry, and 60% of corruption.
Not great numbers, but not too bad, especially given the rotten circumstances. Media in particular are being horses' asses.
"More for Gore or the son of a drug lord--None of the above, fuck it, cut the cord."
--Zack de la Rocha
"I tell you I'll have nothing to do with the place...The roof of that hall is made of bones."
-- Fiver
Hi
This post and video were not intended to spark a controversy, just explain why I felt the need to blog about what happened to my friend and former online writing coach.
That and just to impress upon people that dismissing the stories of people who have been attacked or threatened, whether they opposed Trump, supported him or didn't bother with the election but fell prey to those who felt enabled to harm others because of the outcome, whether from the right or the left, is wrong, and it should deeply disturb all of us. Because, in the final analysis, we all have targets on our back unless we are among the .01% in my view.
Most people have responded with empathy, but others seem hung up on labeling people or politicizing their reports of the criminal acts committed upon them, and that does no one any good, unless one's goal is to win an argument online, or reinforce some pre-conceived idea about those of us who find this upsurge in violence (and it is an upsurge based on past election cycles) deeply troubling. And if it is wrong to label everyone who supported Trump one way (and I have stated I do not consider all Trump voters racist or sexist or whatever), it is also wrong to label anyone who has been a victim of the violence that arose in the aftermath of his election as purveyors of "identity politics" or "SJWs."
In the end it doesn't matter if the violence people have reported was perpetrated by a small group of extreme Trump supporters or by a small group of people upset at his victory. What matters is recognizing our common humanity, and that's why I post on this blog and why I shared my story on You Tube.
All my best to you,
Steve
"You can't just leave those who created the problem in charge of the solution."---Tyree Scott
Your video was quite moving, Steven D
The long version is worth taking the time to go through...
Assaults such as these and the trauma that results from them are very difficult to process...and sometimes, that "process" takes on some very unusual forms, in my experience.
I've never spoken much about my own, to a therapist or anything.
I have written about a couple of incidents where I was complemented for my "bravery" in telling this part of my life...which always strikes me as an unusual thing to say in those situations and I'm never quite sure how to respond to it.
Thank you Kev
And thank you for what you've shared about your experiences. It is a tough thing to talk about. When I made the video I didn't realize how long it was going to be, and there was so much else I wanted to say that I forgot to include.
Good to see you here. May you stay safe in the days to come.
Steve
"You can't just leave those who created the problem in charge of the solution."---Tyree Scott
I worked with many victims of assaults
And I know that any person violently assaulted in a face to face encounter, either by beating, stabbing, shooting or rape, is never the same again. Many are able to work through the immediate shock and terror, but 100% of assault victims are changed forever. And because they are changed, everyone close to them is also affected. There are very real fears now because ugly hateful people feel empowered to act out. Some people feel they are or will be targeted because of who they are. Because any leadership from our president elect appears to be lacking, its up to us all to support people who are threatened by the snake he's let loose.
dear steven
my friend, fellow survivor
you know my story, now i know yours
i marched with you, you've marched with me - we will continue to do so
I just got my wounds and scars covered by an incredible tattoo artist. 31 years later, my skin is my own. I took back my skin today.
"Love One Another" ~ George Harrison
Yes we do
Thanks Janet. BFF you and I despite the distance.
"You can't just leave those who created the problem in charge of the solution."---Tyree Scott
Since I no longer have front page privileges and none of my...
...recent diaries have been deemed worthy of promotion, I doubt I will be posting here any longer.
I didn't know that Robyn
I am deeply saddened to hear this.
I haven't commented on every post you made here, but I read each one I saw and recced them.
I will miss your work here a great deal.
If I had the right to front page your work here I would do so, because it is important to me. But I do not.
I hope something can be done to change this.
Love,
Steve
"You can't just leave those who created the problem in charge of the solution."---Tyree Scott
Robyn...
thanks for bringing that to my attention.
I just checked and you are right, I have no idea how that happened, the site's been a bit wonky the last couple of weeks.
Any way, I fixed it and your front page privileges are back as they were.
Your're a good man JtC
I figured it had to be something like that. And I've had trouble accessing the site at times the last few weeks so that makes sense to me.
"You can't just leave those who created the problem in charge of the solution."---Tyree Scott
I hope you don't leave
I read a great many of your diaries. I just don't post in them very much. I hope I shared enough in them to let you know that you have allies i me and in my home.
"Love One Another" ~ George Harrison
Robyn, don't go!
You have sensitized many of us to the unique plight of trans-folk. I just found out that an elementary school friend has transitioned from he to she. She is safe for the moment, has had a tragic but interesting life. We may be soulmates. Kathleen and I.
Hey! my dear friends or soon-to-be's, JtC could use the donations to keep this site functioning for those of us who can still see the life preserver or flotsam in the water.
Hello Robyn
Okay, this is weird. For the last hour I was browsing the site, starting from the first page. I am relatively new here, so I was not aware of all the really important articles you had written.
So, anyway I popped back to the present, and what did I see but this! Well I am glad that JtC corrected the glitch. Otherwise, I would have been a bit upset and would have given the site managers a piece of my mind.
May I make a suggestion to any that might care to listen to an old hand at site administration. If something changes suddenly, always (and I do mean always) contact an administrator to clarify the situation. I cannot count the number of ways things can go sideways, wonky, et cetera and not be caught by an administrator.
I thinkj it's the election and its consequences
that have been using up all the oxygen. Maybe now that things are starting to settle out, people will have attention to spare for topics that don't just come around every 4 years but are with us day in, day out.
I haven't said much, but I've got your back. People should be who and what they want to be, and other people should back off and let them be. And that's the bottom line IMHO.
There is no justice. There can be no peace.
Thx for sharing, Steven and thx JtC for restating Robyn
Both are important voices here that remind me every single day to stand-up for others as well as for myself.
It seems I can't turn on the news, or browse the web anymore
without ending up in tears.
Thank you for your story Stephen. My admiration for you continues to grow.
The people, united, will never be defeated.