Presidential Elections and Liberals: A Love Story? (Part 5)

Part 4 of this series1 ended with Democrat Woodrow Wilson's2 victory in the unique election of 1912. This Part 5 skims some highlights of Wilson's highly eventful tenure.

With a degree in political science, Wilson was a university president and scholarly author, writing about political science and public administration. Although he had never held political office, he let people in power in the Democratic Party know that he would like to be on the ballot in 1908--and not as Vice President! While that did not happen, Democratic Party bosses did choose him to run for Governor of New Jersey in 1910. He won, taking office in 1911. That same year, he began assembling his Presidential campaign team and launched his Presidential campaign in 1912. He left the Governor's office on March 1, 1913, winning the Presidential nomination and the election that year! On March 4, 1914, Wilson began his first term as POTUS. Wilson's talented wife, Ellen Axson Wilson, had suffered an "ugly" fall on March 1, 1914, which damaged her already delicate health.

With a Democratic majority in both houses of Congress until 1919, the Wilson administration saw a number of landmark laws, including the Federal Reserve Act, the Federal Trade Commission Act, the Clayton Antitrust Act, the Federal Farm Loan Act, the Revenue Act of 1913 (soon after ratification of the Sixteenth Amendment)4 and various war-related acts, some of which are mentioned later in this Part 5.

Depending upon the source, the Great Migration to northern urban areas of African Americans, who tended to be "Lincoln Republicans," was well underway when Wilson took office or started during his first term.3 The Great Migration would soon begin impacting Democrats significantly, especially those seeking the Presidency. However, Wilson seems to have been oblivious to a potential problem for his Party.

Born in Virginia in 1856 to a family that "owned" slaves, Wilson staffed his administration with Southern Democratic segregationists, affording them autonomy. When questioned by the NAACP (which had formed in 1909), Wilson opined that segregation promoted racial harmony. (So much for decency and Constitutional guaranties.) For her part, Mrs. Wilson had gone to lengths to assure that her children were not "born Yankees," including once traveling to Georgia on the day she was to give birth. Nonetheless, one of her three daughters was born in Connecticut. Both Woodrow and Ellen were children of Presbyterian ministers who had co-officiated at the Wilson wedding.

On July 28, 1914, less than eighteen months after Wilson's inauguration, World War I began in Europe, with Wilson pledging neutrality. (Spoiler alert. He broke that pledge.) On August 6, 1914, the First Lady died of Bright's Disease. Although she had been First Lady only a short time, during which she had been ill, she accomplished much, including advising her husband, improving housing in the slums of Washington, D.C. and arranging White House weddings for two of the couple's daughters (the third having spent the last four years of her life as a Hindu nun!).

Rumors around Ellen's death included adultery and murder!5 In 1907, Woodrow had begun at least an emotional affair with socialite Mary Hulbert Peck, breaking it off only after betrothal to his second wife. However, I don't know if he had had any kind of affair with the winsome, wealthy widow Edith Bolling Gault before Ellen died. Edith became Wilson's second wife in December 2015, after a secret engagement. (Shades of The American President!) Nothing, however, seems to substantiate rumors that Wilson had blackmailed silent film actress Florence La Badie into an affair, then had her killed. (And some Democrats imagine these sorts of rumors began with the Clintons!)

Wilson was supposedly focused more upon the war in Mexico than the war in Europe.6 As always, I, of course, believe the official story. Still, ramping up military recruitment and the requests Wilson made of Congress during his 1915 SOTU7 did mesh rather conveniently with entering World War I in 1917. In his 1915 SOTU, Wilson asked Congress for laws against espionage and sedition, in part to suppress anti-draft activists, including many U.S. ssocialisstss (sic). (Candidly, I don't understand the comment about anti-draft activists, which derives from wikipedia: Wilson did not ask Congress for the draft until 1917. Were the anti-draft activists of 1914-15 prescient, or was the public aware that a Selective Service Act might be in the offing?) In any event, the laws that Wilson requested were, IMO, against the intent of the Founders.8

Next:9 The election of 1916 and Wilson's consequential second term. Who knows? I may go wild and even get to the Presidential election of 1920, but I'm not promising.
_________________________________________________________________________________________________

THE "THIS THREAD IS USELESS WITHOUT PICS!" SECTION

With Mary Hulbert Peck, whom he met in Bermuda in 1907, while Ellen was home in the States, ill herself and/or with a sick child, depending upon the source


With first wife, Ellen Axson Wilson, in Staunton, Virginia, his birthplace, as President-Elect


With second wife, Edith Bolling Gault Wilson


(Unknown photographer, found at http://www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi?page=gr&GRid=7688868, via wikipedia)

Florence La Badie--Despite the lack of evidence of an affair, she merits a moment, and so do her moms (sic). When she was three, her father died and her mother, being unable to provide for her, had to give her up to a Canadian couple for adoption. (Imagine losing a young spouse and a baby at the same time.) The title of the first film in which Florence was credited was The Politician's Love Story. (I wonder if that led to the rumors.) Known as "Fearless Flo" because she did many of her own stunts, she was very popular from about 1911. After a fan in the Canadian military sent her photos of World War I casualties, she became something of an itinerant peace activist. (Canada had entered the war in Europe as soon as it began.) A car accident due to faulty brakes brought her septicemia. It led to her death about six weeks later, in October, 1917, at age 29.

________________________________________________________________________________________________

FOOTNOTES

1 Links to Parts 1-4 of this series: http://caucus99percent.com/content/presidential-elections-and-liberals-l... http://caucus99percent.com/content/presidential-elections-and-liberals-l... http://caucus99percent.com/content/presidential-elections-and-liberals-l... https://caucus99percent.com/content/presidential-elections-and-liberals-...

2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woodrow_Wilson Because I cannot summarize Wilson fairly, I encourage you to read this article. See also, http://www.u-s-history.com/pages/h1061.html

3 E.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Migration_(African_American) (1910) http://www.blackpast.org/aah/great-migration-1915-1960 (1915); http://www.history.com/topics/black-history/great-migration (1916)

4 Wilson's Wikipedia article characterizes Wilson as a leader in the Progressive Movement. I have two reactions: First, was it Wilson, or Wilson's Congress that was Progressive, or both? Second, in my observation, one party's dominating the Oval Office for a relatively long time, as had Republicans, has profound effects on both the zeitgeist and the opposing Party (and likely vice versa). So, was Wilson (and/or his Congress) actually leading the Progressive Movement, or simply following the lead of the oft-elected Republicans, possibly for fear of being voted out of office or having their Party become largely irrelevant? Despite all the nonsense to the contrary, American voters appreciate government policies that benefit the 90%, especially when they seem normal for government (as they always should).

IMO, we saw similar behavior from Eisenhower/Nixon after only twenty years of FDR/Truman; and Eisenhower had been elected to his first term by a much greater popular vote than Wilson's 41.8% percent plurality. Moreover, when Wilson was elected in 1912, Republicans had dominated the Presidential polls since 1856, save only for Grover Cleveland's two non-consecutive terms, rather than "merely" the twenty years of FDR/HST. (Culture war issues aside, one might argue that, at most, 1.3 parties have dominated since Hoover, save for Presidents Roosevelt, Truman and Johnson.)

5 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woodrow_Wilson; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edith_Wilson; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ellen_Axson_Wilson. Remarriage made Wilson one of very few to marry while serving as POTUS. Coincidentally, so was the only other Democrat elected POTUS since Buchanan, Grover Cleveland, who is also the only President to have had his wedding ceremony in the White House and the only POTUS to have served non-consecutive terms. Très unique! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grover_Cleveland

6 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_the_Mexican_R... http://millercenter.org/president/biography/wilson-foreign-affairs

7 Wilson reinstated spoken delivery of the State of the Union address, discontinued by Thomas Jefferson because Jefferson thought it too like the King's address to each new Parliament. http://heavy.com/news/2015/01/state-of-the-union-history-bill-clinton-ba....

Military recruitment began ramping up in 1915, which wikipedia states was in relation to World War I. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_Service_Act_of_1917 However, the wikipedia article about Wilson states Wilson was more focused on the war in Mexico than the war in Europe. The more I read, the more confused I become!

8 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alien_and_Sedition_Acts; http://www.crf-usa.org/america-responds-to-terrorism/the-alien-and-sedit... http://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Alien_and_Sedition_Acts

9 When ending Part 4 of this series, I indicated that Part 5 would cover the 1920s. Obviously, it does not. (The line for refunds for those Part 5 disappointed will form behind the last Canye West concert ticketholder.) Wilson interested me far more than I anticipated. (Why, yes, I do actually enjoy learning about this stuff while I prepare these dry posts. Why do you ask?) Lord willing and the creek don't rise, I will get to the Roaring Twenties at some point. I dasn't be more specific lest issuing refunds every time I don't deliver as promised put me out of business!

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

demonstrations and actions during the civil war were on his administration's collective mind and that Wilson had been planning US entry into WW1 since 1914 or 1915. This meshes with the reactionaries already in place when Wilson took the country into the war who engaged in "slacker raids" illegally imprisoning draft age males in makeshift lockups, like warehouses, while "patriots" checked to see if they were complying with the work or fight order from the Wilson administration. Quite a few kidnappings took place after baseball games and attendance figures show a sharp decline in 1917 and 1918.

German Americans were the largest ethnic group in the USA but their numbers did not save some of them from mob action egged on by Wilson. Wilson also used the war, which was between capitalist powers, to go after those who would organize unions in the USA.

Babe Ruth grew up speaking German at home (which didn't last long because he was sent to St Mary's Industrial School - a reform school - at age seven and went home on parole a few times but it never lasted and back he went) - and briefly took a job in a shipyard to do war work, which was a common thing for professional baseball players to do. The professional patriots were all in for Wilson's war, but most of the population was not.

We still have repressive legislation on the books from the Wilson presidency and Obama uses it. War and civil liberties don't coexist well and it's the liberties that suffer. Ask Eugene Debs for one.

Wilson's campaign slogan for 1916: "He kept us out of war"

up
0 users have voted.

"The justness of individual land right is not justifiable to those to whom the land by right of first claim collectively belonged"

Bisbonian's picture

"He kept us safe."

up
0 users have voted.

"I’m a human being, first and foremost, and as such I’m for whoever and whatever benefits humanity as a whole.” —Malcolm X

Well, I'm sure you can see Rove's problem. "He kept us safe once 3000 people died" just doesn't have the same ring to it, now does it? I loved Condi Rice's first pass at it, too: Who could have predicted someone would use a plane as a weapon!"

Gee, Condi, I don't know. Maybe anyone who ever saw a film or a TV show or read about kamikaze pilots? Once she got that feedback, she changed her riff, but I don't remember how. Maybe she switched it to "commercial jet" rather than simply "plane?" In any event, her attempt at modification was lame and her first try was false. So, 0 for 2.

Same for Wilson's advisors "He kept us out of war---but wait'll next year" is just not as comforting.

We have to allow these liars political advisors some poetic license, don't we? Especially about something like war. That's such a hard sell, they just have to lie.

Don't they?

up
0 users have voted.

Thank you so much! You are always such an inspiration and an incredible source of information. I am really in awe. I so appreciate your contributions to threads like this, both mine and the ones other posters prepare. As much as I research for this stuff, the info you provide is always better and more to the point.

First, thank you for confirming my suspicions about Wilson's 1915 SOTU and his 1915 ramp up of military recruitment. As I do the research, I start to squint when I read things about Wilson's really never wanting to get into war until he was forced to do so in 1917 (Lusitania, yadda yadda) and caring more about Mexico. (This is another reason I appreciate wiki. Those things might be 100 pages apart in a history book. When you can read them all in five minutes, putting things together--adding two and two--is so much easier) When I start squinting, I also start wondering if my imagination is too active. But, as Lily Tomlin said, "No matter how cynical you become, it's never enough to keep up."

I have prepared some of the next part. However I have not read about the work or fight order yet. A relative worked in the shipyards during War War I, though. The family stories are sketchy--or maybe I tuned them out as a kid--but I had the impression that he had been forced to do that somehow, either by law or physically forced. I think some physical issue had rendered him ineligible for military service.

The family stories also tend to focus more on things like how cold it was there (not a huge amount of global warming by 1915 or so) and that he supposedly became sterile while working in the shipyards. I am not sure why--an injury maybe? I didn't hear, or didn't focus on, anything about relevant laws or orders.

I know he got pneumonia while working in the shipyards, but I don't think that causes sterility. (He was very poor and tried to keep warm by putting cardboard under his shirt, which is a part of the story that did stick with me because it was so heart-wrenching to a child.) He also used cardboard when he got holes in the soles of his shoes. Imagine relying on cardboard soles in a shipyard, even without the snow!

The legislation that Obama still uses is the Espionage Act Wilson requested during his 1915 SOTU, which I get to in the next part. People from Debs to Snowden have been charged under it. That will be in the next part I hope. I get so interested in the things I read, I probably put too much into these segments.

Thanks for telling me about Babe Ruth working in the shipyards, too. My two biggest childhood heroes were Abe Lincoln, with whom I started this series, and Babe Ruth. The reason: My elementary school teacher thought I was reading too much fiction for my book reports. She told me to ask a librarian to help selecting non fiction for me to read.

The Librarian gave me Sandburg's two-volume biography of Lincoln--ambitious for a fourth grader!, but I read it. She also gave me a biography of Ruth, but I don't remember the name of the author. They were more hagiographies than biographies and both men seemed to me like perfect super heroes to me. At least, until I got older.....

Back to Wilson: I think the reason he didn't get right into World War I when it started had to do with the lack of war readiness at the time, both in terms of troops and equipment. He may have felt he was not ready himself yet. He was still a relatively new President. Also, his first wife's health may have distracted him, even if he did have a mistress (or two)!

BTW, I have already begun writing about the 1916 election and I did snark about the campaign slogan.

up
0 users have voted.

I look forward to them. I am happy to learn and do learn a great deal from the essays you write.

Now as far as Babe Ruth is concerned, George, Jr according to my grandfather who knew the Babe and his father, George, Sr, the elder Ruth married a Schamberger(I am trying to remember all this) who was a Protestant and they were married in a Protestant church. She was never well and couldn't keep up with little George and his younger sister, so George was shipped to St Many's on Wilkins Ave. Babe converted to the RC church while at St Mary's(it was run by the Xavierian Brothers.)

I grew up with my maternal grandparents and my great-grandfather. The latter, and his two oldest sons, were longshoremen and helped bring the union into the docks. My grandfather left school after the 6th grade to become a delivery boy for Libbys which had a retail business at that time. George, Sr's saloon was part of Pop's route and he knew Babe's father very well.

My great-grandfather saw many of the Old Oriole games in the mid-1890's when they were inventing the modern game and dominating the sport. He also went to St. Ann's RC church and in the pews were Hall of Famers Dan Brouthers, Hughie Jennings, John McGraw, Joe Kelley and Willie Keeler. After McGraw and Wilbert Robinson, the Hall of Fame catcher for the team opened up The Diamond on Howard St, grandpop went there in the evenings to shoot pool and bowl - duckpin bowling was invented there - and have a beer. A big attraction to the Diamond was the presence of McGraw & Robinson as well as players like Willie Keeler with whom grandpop developed a friendship for a couple of years until the team was split up and most of the best players went to Brooklyn.

German St was not far from Howard St and it was renamed Redwood St during WW1 - still is Redwood St.

I don't know how much ship building Ruth did but the short while he was employed he mostly played baseball for the company team.

I was born about 8 blocks from where Babe was born and he was well regarded in the family and the city.

One thing about Babe Ruth: In this steroid era, still no one has hit a baseball consistently, or ultimately, as far as the Babe did. For all the bulking up Bonds did, for instance, did he never hit one 500 feet. Babe hit a lot over 500 feet including his last one for the Braves which traveled 540 feet. (No one has hit them as far as Jimmy Foxx either but Babe outdistances them all.)

up
0 users have voted.

"The justness of individual land right is not justifiable to those to whom the land by right of first claim collectively belonged"

Do we now know the inspiration for your screen name? I grew up with ten pins. I imagine they are easier to knock down than duckpins.

A friend told me that people who wanted to bet against Ruth would take him out, ply him with booze and keep him up all night. And the next day, they'd still lose money if they bet against him because he played as he always did.

Before there were steroids in baseball, there were bats that were engineered better than the ones Ruth was stuck with using. That's why purists pooh poohed even Roger Maris's getting to the 60 home run level.

I loved the story of the Curse of the Bambino, even if there is no evidence that he ever cursed the Sox. Throwing a baby grand piano that supposedly had once belonged to Ruth into a lake near where he used to live was one of the things done to "reverse the curse" the first year the Red Sox finally won the Series again. All kinds of things were done, but that one was probably the most expensive--and made the least sense! Not that any superstition is sensible, I suppose, but pianos had absolutely nothing to do with the curse! Now, if they had thrown Ruby Keeler's tap shoes into the lake, that would have made some sense.

Thank you for your kind words about my posts. I value your opinions and your input. No one learns more from my researched posts than I do. They are a lot of work, but I really need the info and doing the work is fulfilling. And then your replies are always amazing. Thanks so much!

up
0 users have voted.

a little larger than a softball. The pins are smaller but fit on a ten pin format which means a perfectly straight ball can take out the one and five pins and leave the other eight standing. An average of 125 is a pretty good average.

It's interesting what you mention about baseball bats. Home Run Baker used a 52 ounce bat that had no give to it and was considered obsolete when he was using it. Ruth started out with a 50 ounce bat and always stayed over 40 ounces. No one would think of doing that now.

To add to the curse, Frazee, the man who sold Babe to the Yankees, was in debt for the refurbishing of Fenway Park to one of the two owners of the Yankees! Part of the price Boston got for Ruth was some forgiveness of the loan.

up
0 users have voted.

"The justness of individual land right is not justifiable to those to whom the land by right of first claim collectively belonged"

have to see if my favorite Sox fan knows about that bit. My family includes a resident baseball and football statistics spouter. I'll have to ask him, too. See, and I thought I knew that whole story. I keep saying, "Assume nothing," but I can't seem to follow my own advice.

up
0 users have voted.

spread false information and I've always liked the Red Sox.

Maybe I have it backwards: Maybe with the $100,000 came a loan. I'll try to find out and post it...I am sure I've read that there was more than just a bad cash deal.

up
0 users have voted.

"The justness of individual land right is not justifiable to those to whom the land by right of first claim collectively belonged"

it wrong. There's no end to the stuff of which I am unaware.

I never knew the details of the financial deal, only that Frazee was knocking tap shoes with Keeler and needed to raise money to finance No No, Nanette, a show in which she wanted to star. Last year, I think I read that even that is not accurate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No,_No,_Nanette

up
0 users have voted.

Paraphrasing: In addition to the $100,000 price Babe brought, the Yankee owners loaned Frazee $300,000 to keep his theatrical interests going. It was a loan so Frazee could stay with his first interest, the theatre. In 1925 No No Nanette began its run and it made Frazee a very rich man.

up
0 users have voted.

"The justness of individual land right is not justifiable to those to whom the land by right of first claim collectively belonged"

that Frazee sold the Babe to raise money. Then the urban legend says that Babe cursed the Sox. Or maybe it was the truth. For some reason, I like to think it was the latter.

The original version I heard said he cursed them for 50 years, but neither my favorite Sox fan nor the family statistics spouter had heard of any time limit in the curse, so they both mocked me.

up
0 users have voted.

Red Sox days, both say Ruth really liked Boston and the fans and bought, or rented, a farm north of the city and lived there year round. Ruth would never curse the Red Sox or the city of Boston but I think the curse comes into play because the act of selling Babe in and of itself was such a bonehead deal, as reported at the time, that it cast a pall over the team until the late 1930s when they began seriously competing for the pennant. (Lefty Grove & Jimmy Foxx and other Phildelphia A's helped the Sox become respectable.)

up
0 users have voted.

"The justness of individual land right is not justifiable to those to whom the land by right of first claim collectively belonged"

Another two: Theo Epstein.

Epstein, who was in the same high school class as my favorite Red Sox fan, apparently recently did for the Cubs what he had done for the Red Sox a few years back. I never understood why he and the Sox parted ways.

À Propos of nothing: Also in the same high school, though perhaps a different year, John Hodgman

[video:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m53llV2Nw3g&list=PLtKoyGyFAgSmWxgIYVE4Lu...

up
0 users have voted.

Next to the Babe, he was probably the best.

One stat that impressed me was that Lefty Grove won 20 consecutive decisions at Fenway, the graveyard for southpaws.

up
0 users have voted.

"The justness of individual land right is not justifiable to those to whom the land by right of first claim collectively belonged"

had not been away at not one, but two, wars in his prime. Quite a character. What a mess with his kids at the end.

up
0 users have voted.