If democracy means choice, then we are rapidly becoming less democratic

Republicans like to talk about freedom. Democrats like to talk about democracy. Neither of them walk the walk.
For the first time since the 1940's New Yorkers will only have two choices for governor.

The paucity of options is largely due to former Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo, who championed changes in election law two years ago that made it far more difficult for third parties to get on the ballot. The changes to ballot access law tripled the number of voter signatures required for groups to get on the November ballot and forced political parties to qualify every two years instead of four.

The steep climb to get on the ballot has prompted legal challenges, including one being heard this week in State Supreme Court in Albany, in a lawsuit filed by the Libertarian Party. The party’s nominee for governor, Larry Sharpe, argued that the rules are so tough that only the entrenched and connected can earn the right to appear on a ballot in New York.

Both parties have worked hard at keeping third parties off the ballot, and it's not just true for Blue States.
The Texas Republican Party sued to get 40 Libertarians kicked off the ballot in 2020 and sued again to get another 23 Libertarian candidates off the ballot in 2022.

However, it's the Democrats that have been the most hostile to democracy.
The Green Party already doesn't exist in nine states, and is not on the ballot in 19 states, but that's not enough.

In 2018 the Democrats managed to get the Greens kicked off the ballot in Montana. So the Democrats doubled-down in 2020 starting in Wisconsin.

A Democratic Party spokesperson filed a challenge against the Green Party petitions, claiming the change of address by Walker invalidated some of the petitions.

The hearing on the challenge before the state Elections Commission had all the trappings of a kangaroo court. The attorney for the Democratic challenger huddled with the Democratic chair of the Elections Commission to restrict the testimony of Green Party attorneys.

The Democratic challenge was upheld by the Commission and the signatures on those petitions were invalidated — conveniently enough to keep the Greens off the ballot.
...
In Pennsylvania, the Democrats went to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to remove Hawkins/Walker from the ballot. They were victorious on the flimsy technicality that the Greens did not submit signed filing papers in person but mailed them in.

You might be aware of the dirty tricks the Democratic Party in North Carolina has been using to get the Green Party off the ballot this year, but the Dems have been waging war on democracy for longer than that.
People are upset that the North Carolina Dems got copies of the Green Party petitions and went to signers and encouraged people to remove their signatures. But in fact that is exactly what the Dems did in 2020 to get the Green Party kicked off the ballot in Montana again!

So far the Libertarian Party has been most successful third party at surviving this onslaught, but they have their own self-inflicted problem. While Libertarians have long been in perfect agreement with the GOP on economic issues, they have at least separated themselves from the GOP on the culture war issues.

Libertarians have a long history of describing themselves as fiscal conservatives who are social liberals and arguing that the War on Drugs and the evangelical Christian Right have been terrible for the Republican Party and terrible for the conservative movement.

At least that was until recently. Now the Libertarian Party has become the MAGA wing of the GOP.

In July 28, 2017, Jeff Deist, the president of the Mises Institute, named for libertarian economist Ludwig von Mises, published a blog post arguing that “blood and soil and God and nation still matter to people. Libertarians ignore this at the risk of irrelevance.” The phrase “blood and soil” already had an unmistakable fascist overtone—but it took on an even more gruesome connotation two weeks after the post during the infamous Charlottesville Unite the Right Rally of 2017, where an anti-racist protester was killed. The white supremacists who tried to dominate the streets of Charlottesville chanted “blood and soil.” Several of the organizers of the Charlottesville rally identified as libertarians. In the wake of that event, Nicholas Sarwark, chair of the Libertarian Party, signed an open letter warning of the dangers of fascism. Arvin Vohra, vice chair of the Libertarian Party, wrote a post arguing that the “Mises Institute has been turned into a sales funnel for the White Nationalist branch of the Alt Right.”

The ensuing arguments over “blood and soil” lead to the creation of a Mises Caucus, which aimed to overthrow the pragmatic Gary Johnson wing of the party and adopt the incendiary culture war politics of the hard right.
...
On May 29, at the Libertarian Party Convention in Reno, McArdle won the title of chair of the party’s national committee. This was a decisive victory for the Mises Caucus, which received the vote of 69 percent of delegates. The Mises Caucus is now the undisputed ruling faction of the party.

"Taking the Libertarian Party out as a competitive force will help consolidate the right-wing vote around the Republican Party."
- Jeet Heer

Liberty and the alt-right are incompatible.
On the other hand, if an extreme right-wing element undermining a fringe conservative political party sounds familiar, it should because Trump did this to the Reform Party.

Donald Trump says he’s never run for president before, but like much of what he says, that’s not quite true.

In 2000, he actively sought the Reform Party nomination, winning primaries in Michigan and California in the third party founded by Texas billionaire Ross Perot to fight NAFTA (North American Free Trade Act), and promote a balanced budget....
Trump left the race early citing infighting not “conducive to victory,” but there was more to the story. He had a “liquidity issue” (sounds familiar) and his campaign hinged on whether he sold his casino in Atlantic City.

Trump’s exit from the Reform Party race in February 2000 cleared the way for Patrick Buchanan, right-wing renegade from the GOP, to seize the nomination, which in turn led to the Reform Party’s eventual collapse.

While the Democrats are in-your-face at keeping the Greens off the ballot, the right-wing appears to take the more subtle strategy of undermining parties on the right from within.

Share
up
15 users have voted.

Comments

The Denmark-based Alliance of Democracies Foundation and Germany-based Latana data tracking firm polled the people of many countries as to their opinion of the extent of their democracy. China had the most positive result, 83% of the respondents replied in the positive. In the US it was 49%. The Chinese people consider themselves a successful democracy, the US population does not. Voting is one mechanism to provide influence over the government by the people, which is the ultimate goal. On the other hand if the government listens to the people and implements programs that the people want and need, then you have a functional democracy. In the US the congress listens to the corporations, the MIC and the wealthy. Restricting voter choice completes the closed mechanism. The Princeton study verified that there is zero correlation between what the people want and what congress passes. We don't have a failed democracy, we just don't have a functional democracy and probably never had. The founding fathers distrusted the people and believed that wealthy, land owning, slave owning aristocrats should run the government with a loose checking mechanism with occasional voting, but only for representatives in the house. The morphing into a two party system completed control by the elite. That we tout our democracy as something exceptional is a fantasy.

up
18 users have voted.

Capitalism has always been the rule of the people by the oligarchs. You only have two choices, eliminate them or restrict their power.

The Liberal Moonbat's picture

...is it not time we saw the writing on the wall, and accepted its meaning?

In what could be argued to be THE supreme betrayal of the American Experiment, peaceful revolution has been made impossible.

You know what's left.

up
9 users have voted.

In the Land of the Blind, the One-Eyed Man is declared mentally ill for describing colors.

Yes Virginia, there is a Global Banking Conspiracy!

for what Ds have done here and there to thwart the GP, although some in the party might see it all as a sneaky way for Rs to contribute and help dilute the D vote, and so Ds play hardball. Certainly though the Rs play hardball as well, as in the way they made it easier for DJT to glide to re-nomination with states dropping their primaries or changing a proportional system into winner-take-all. If he runs again in 2024, look for similar thumbs on the scale maneuverings.

Considering other important factors however, it's clear that Rs are the party out to destroy democracy. A very partial list: Voter suppression laws in the red states aimed at Ds; extreme partisan gerrymandering, much worse than what Ds have done historically; a GOP Scotus radically watering down the Voting Rights Act; the same R-appointed justices taking away rights enjoyed for half a century; the current attempt by GOP legislatures across the land to put in place their Independent State Legislature theory of the constitution, which in 2024 could mean the R legislatures acting unilaterally could thwart the will of the people. https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/independent-stat...

There's also the troubling anti-democratic activity lately in FL under DeSantis, trying to look Trumpish as he positions himself as the alternative to the Don for 2024, with his "Don't Say Gay" bill and his new election police force. Trying to stop voter fraud of course.

up
5 users have voted.
snoopydawg's picture

For those who think democrats can do no wrong. In case you didn’t know it both parties serve the same donors and don’t give a damn about our lives. I can’t believe that people think there’s a cow’s spittle worth a difference between them. Biden has continued many of Trump’s actions and policies that shitlibs only bitched about when Trump was doing them. Biden is still holding migrant kids in cages for longer than the law allows and they are still sleeping under the tin foil blankets that they slept under during both Obama and Trump’s tenures. Yawn….?

up
8 users have voted.

Which AIPAC/MIC/pharma/bank bought politician are you going to vote for? Don’t be surprised when nothing changes.

Just found out last week, that my Governor Death Satan changed the Florida absente ballot law. Now you have to ask for one every year. It used to last 4 years or 2 election cycles. How many old people will not be able to vote because of this?

My rural polling place is small, about 300 registered voters. It is run by the loal Baptist Church, which is next door to it. When I go up there, I feel young, (I'm over 60), and these people got 10 or 20 years on me.

up
6 users have voted.

I agree with this dude, except I have in mind the names Manchin and Cinéma for "illiberal fringe elements":

up
2 users have voted.
snoopydawg's picture

@wokkamile

I guess that’s why both parties voted for the patriot act that pretty much nullified the constitution and that they have voted to keep it in place every time it’s come up for a vote. And why both parties voted to give Bush immunity for spying on us and Pelosi re-upped it during Trump’s tenure giving the most dangerous president ever more power to spy on us. And why Obama rescinded habeas corpus and gave the president the power to arrest anyone he wants and hold them indefinitely without access to a lawyer or a trial.

Americans think that they are free, but look at what happens any time they want to use their 1st amendment right to protest. That’s when they find out that the only right that is mostly still standing is the 2nd. And congress is working on it….

As for democrats playing fair in elections I guess you have forgotten how they tinkered in the primaries to make sure that Bernie lost. See the tweet above where the guy rigged the coin toss and good gravy democrats play just as dirty as republicans. Hence this essay.

up
4 users have voted.

Which AIPAC/MIC/pharma/bank bought politician are you going to vote for? Don’t be surprised when nothing changes.

@snoopydawg on FP and nat'l security, the parties are quite similar. The Ds, since the days of McCarthy, have tended to go on the defensive re FP and national security so as not to be accused by demagoguing Rs of being weak, appeasing Neville Chamberlains.

As I stated above, there is no doubt that on SOME issues they are about the same. A finding which speaks badly of our democracy and also of the AWOL, cowardly, and nearly non-existent Left.

But looking at the much broader scope of issues rather than cherry picking, they are often not the same. Take your 2A for instance. One party for gun control, the other not only opposing such in lockstep but often calling for fewer restrictions, laxer regulations. In fact, if they get their way, the gun party will basically leave us with only one amendment, the Second, perhaps also with a much more restricted 1A in the areas of free speech (see FL) and religion -- only the Rs seem to represent or advocate for a sort of white Christian nationalism, only Rs seem to be calling for the elimination of the separation of Church-State.

Only the R leaders are calling for, or implementing in their states, educational policies that mandate a whitewashed, faux patriotic and anti-historical teaching of US history.

I noted above that only Rs are advocating for severely restricting or criminalizing abortion, including no exceptions even for rape or incest, even when minors are involved.

Voting rights being suppressed by one party as they also seek now to return to the state legislatures the power to elect US senators, and as they seek to have their state legislatures decide elections as against the wishes of the voters. That's about as anti-democratic as it gets.

And so on in the various crucial areas I've noted. More substantial differences than similarities.

up
2 users have voted.
TheOtherMaven's picture

@wokkamile

"Voting rights being suppressed by both parties"

They just choose different methods of going about it. Or hadn't you noticed the intense D efforts to restrict the voters' so-called "choices" to Turd D or Turd R?

up
2 users have voted.

There is no justice. There can be no peace.

usefewersyllables's picture

There's a good reason why 50% of eligible voters have simply stopped bothering: it is clear that it doesn't make a bit of difference.

Colorado is now a vote-by-mail state, which is the only reason I bother: if I had to go to a caucus or stand in line at the polls, I wouldn't. I'm not voting for any major-party candidates in any case. Neither party offers me anything at all other than the standard-issue empty-suit shit sandwiches.

We missed the last election, for the first time on over 40 years in my case. Our ballots went to the smoking crater that was our old residence, and were returned as undeliverable- so the SoS office shut down both of our registrations for our convenience. I went back and reregistered about a week ago, but it took quite a while for me to decide to bother at all.

To quote the old saw, "It Didn't Have To Be This Way." But it is. That is the way that it is.

And that calls for one of my favorite Robert Fripp tunes, from “Exposure” (1979). And yes, the lyrics were all improvised on this one-take wonder, with the exception of the title. And also yes, I have played a cover version of this live, many times…. Fun!

up
4 users have voted.

Twice bitten, permanently shy.

enhydra lutris's picture

be well and have a good one

up
2 users have voted.

That, in its essence, is fascism--ownership of government by an individual, by a group, or by any other controlling private power. -- Franklin D. Roosevelt --