Hypocrisy at CDC may endanger your life

CDC = Centers for Disease Control

There might be some dispute about the number 1 controllable disease, though tobacco use is probably number 1, followed closely by obesity-induced diabetes. That being said, it is perhaps unsurprising that another Trump appointee has been called out for dangerous health-related hypocrisy. The first of note was alleged physician Tom Price, former Georgia Congress critter. Tom a victim of Travelgate should just as well been a victim to the STOCK act, of which he was notably violating.

The STOCK Act

The STOCK Act is an original bill to prohibit Members of Congress and employees of Congress from using private information derived from their official positions for personal benefit, and for other purposes. With this bill in place, Congressman will no longer be allowed to use information garnered through official business for personal reasons. The Stop Trading on Congressional Knowledge (STOCK) Act prohibits members and employees of Congress from using "any nonpublic information derived from the individual's position… or gained from performance of the individual's duties, for personal benefit.” The bill also applies to all employees in the Executive and Judicial branches of the federal government. The STOCK Act requires a one-year study of the growing political intelligence industry, and requires every Member of Congress to publicly file and disclose any financial transaction of stocks, bond, commodities futures, and other securities within 45 days on their websites, rather than once a year as they do now. The Act also requires members of Congress and Executive branch officials to disclose the terms of mortgages on their homes, prohibits them from receiving special access to initial public stock offerings, and denies federal pensions to members of Congress who are convicted of felonies involving public corruption. The bill is divided into nineteen sections...

Section 6

Amends the Ethics in Government Act of 1978 (EGA) to require specified individuals to file reports within 30 to 45 days after receiving notice of a purchase, sale, or exchange which exceeds $1,000 in stocks, bonds, commodities futures, and other forms of securities,

This Act is a fortuitous accomplishment of Joe Biden and Hussain Obama, one of the very few either has managed in their years of public disservice.

The CDC has several missions:
1. Research into cause of disease, often communicable, but not necessarily
2. Epidemiological surveillance of disease patterns
3. Notification of local Health Jurisdictions of impending serious disease occurrence, whether naturally occurring or man-made
4. Research in disease prevention and treatment developments
5. Making available to the medical community means of directing and controlling diseases whenever possible
6. Notification of the medical community AND to the population at large knowledge about said conditions and causes to inform them appropriately.

After the unlamented departure of Tom Price from HHS, a sort of shake-up began. Perhaps unrelated to Price's corruption and patronage, came the appointment of deeply flawed physician, Dr. Brenda Fitzgerald of Georgia (in fact the same district from which Dr. Price was spawned). She in fact was appointed by the orange-haired bezoar to head the CDC.

But, as to be expected from a government containing the likes of Steve Mnuchin and Wilbur Ross, Dr. Fitzgerald had a penchant for making a loose buck wherever she could.

The Trump administration’s top public health official bought shares in a tobacco company one month into her leadership of the agency charged with reducing tobacco use — the leading cause of preventable disease and death and an issue she had long championed...

Buying shares of tobacco companies raises even more flags than Fitzgerald’s trading in drug and food companies because it stands in such stark contrast to the CDC’s mission to persuade smokers to quit and keep children from becoming addicted. Critics say her trading behavior broke with ethical norms for public health officials and was, at best, sloppy. At worst, they say, it was legally problematic if she didn't recuse herself from government activities that could have affected her investments...

After assuming the CDC leadership on July 7, Fitzgerald bought tens of thousands of dollars in new stock holdings in at least a dozen companies later that month as well as in August and September, according to records obtained under the Stock Act, which requires disclosures of transactions over $1,000. Purchases included between $1,001 and $15,000 of Japan Tobacco, one of the largest such companies in the world, which sells four tobacco brands in the U.S. through a subsidiary.

One of Fitzgerald's stock purchases included Merck which works cooperatively with CDC on several ventures including HIV, Ebola, and Zika viruses. The first of these three entities provides massive support to private industry--including firms like Merck.

Fitzgerald could have abided by an ethics agreement already in place at CDC by recusing herself on matters pertaining to stock interest such as tobacco and Ebola. But seeing as to the wide-ranging disease promotion caused by tobacco, Doc Fitzgerald would have recused herself on much of the required duties of CDC Director. In other words, she would have recused herself to the point achieved by Beauregard Sessions in matters pertaining to Russia--i.e., useless and impotent.

Retribution for her callous misdeeds fortunately visited her early, before she could wreak havoc on health matters. Politico reports her rapid resignation.

Dr. Brenda Fitzgerald's resignation comes one day after POLITICO reported that one month into her tenure as CDC director, she bought shares in a tobacco company. Fitzgerald had long championed efforts to cut tobacco use, which is the leading cause of preventable death.

Fitzgerald, a doctor and former Georgia Department of Public Health commissioner, assumed leadership of the agency in July and was close to former HHS Secretary Tom Price, who resigned in September after POLITICO reported his use of private jets.

An apologist for Fitzgerald, CEO John Auerbach of Trust for America's Health said

“She was doing a good job of leading the CDC”

To me, that's like saying Hitler was doing a good job of directing the Wehrmacht. Auerbach continued his apologia with

disappoint[ment] because the CDC’s work is extremely important and it needs to have support from the administration and from Congress.”

How can that hypocritical alleged health proponent Auerbach bemoan the absence of such an overt corrupted director of the CDC? Support from the Administration--what? In the form of another corrupted individual similar to Price and Fitzgerald?

Note from the surgeon general:

Inhaling the fumes of government propaganda is dangerous to your health
Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

Pricknick's picture

depend on how much money you can make.
It crosses all boundaries but seems to be a requirement in government today.
As for the STOCK act. It is violated with impunity by most if not all congress critters at both the state and federal level.
What a country!

up
0 users have voted.

Regardless of the path in life I chose, I realize it's always forward, never straight.

travelerxxx's picture

@Pricknick

Verily, verily I say unto you, wherefore when the gluttonous and greedy and those that lusteth endlessly for mammon and to be seated among principalities and powers, shall have become as saints and priests, so shall the sins of the poor be manifested. The rod shall not be spared.

up
0 users have voted.
snoopydawg's picture

corrupt. The new head of the FDA is another person who came from the industry he's supposed to regulate. The republicans have had a great time letting these people get appointed. Everyone of them are on record saying that they want all regulations in their agencies to be abolished. Pruitt is rolling back our air and water to the 60's. Mercury and lead in your water? No problem. Congress passed the EPA and I would think that it would take an act of congress to undo the regulations. But no. Trump has let the corporations run his agenda and run wild.

up
0 users have voted.

Which AIPAC/MIC/pharma/bank bought politician are you going to vote for? Don’t be surprised when nothing changes.

Pricknick's picture

@snoopydawg

Trump has let the corporations run his agenda and run wild.

There has been more than enough democratic support to facilitate this.
So yea. Both sides do it.
I was booted from somewhere by comparing both parties to be evil yet I MUST pick the lessor of the two.

up
0 users have voted.

Regardless of the path in life I chose, I realize it's always forward, never straight.

snoopydawg's picture

@Pricknick

It's just that I don't think that Hillary would have been able to get away with what Trump is doing. Her supporters would crucify her if she had appointed the same people as Trump did. I've watched as the democrats have voted for many of the things that republicans have. The FISA bill, payday loans and the rolling back of the banking regulations.

The other thing I've noticed is people think that the democrats aren't the same. Anyone who even mentions something like that on ToP get piled on.

up
0 users have voted.

Which AIPAC/MIC/pharma/bank bought politician are you going to vote for? Don’t be surprised when nothing changes.

SnappleBC's picture

@Pricknick

I was booted from somewhere by comparing both parties to be evil

The mantra "false equivalency" is one of the foundations of their epistemic closure. They can chant that phrase and ward off any evil thoughts without once investigating whether the equivalency might be true. This, in turn, allows them to not know the places where the equivalency is true and thus closure is completed.

up
0 users have voted.

A lot of wanderers in the U.S. political desert recognize that all the duopoly has to offer is a choice of mirages. Come, let us trudge towards empty expanse of sand #1, littered with the bleached bones of Deaniacs and Hope and Changers.
-- lotlizard

Thanks for publicizing this typical Rumpist abuse of power. You almost have to admire the gall!

"Now that we have the papacy, let us enjoy it". -One of the "less reputable" pontiffs, according to Arthur Clarke.

Not to criticize this good essay, but like I tell some earnest friends: it's not about logic or hypocrisy. It's all about power. Them that has it, use it. Assuming that they have some logical basis or moral/ethical consistency can give the perps too much credit. In that context, is even "corrupt" appropriate? Worth thinking about.

Maybe "gall" is a more fitting word? Suggestions? Words matter.

up
0 users have voted.

@pindar's revenge
This also explains, very simply, the sudden puppy love (call it an Orange Crush) between the New York valued, money-laundering, philandering, serial polygamist, lawyering, locker-mouthed lying libertine playboy and the true sincerely-held beliefers of the imMoral notRight. The evangelists smell power, and they have a really, really easy rationalization gun all locked and loaded: Gawd works in mysterious ways. Power, baby, power. No hypocrisy. All he has to do is kiss back.

What's interesting is that in November 100 years ago, according to some of the stories, the Bolsheviks had to be dragged into taking power. That was a promising auspice; in general, I prefer people who are reluctant to assume, or keep, power. Didn't stay that way, though, for many reasons.

Then why are the Donorcrats so unconcerned with taking and using power? That is not a promising auspice. In their case power is money, not governing, and the money is satisfactorily rolling in. And the right people have positions of power in the counting-house. All good!

up
0 users have voted.

do you expect anyone else from me? Diane Feinstein. Does the STOCK Act include husbands?

up
0 users have voted.

On to Biden since 1973

mimi's picture

How can that hypocritical alleged health proponent Auerbach bemoan the absence of such an overt corrupted director of the CDC?

May be because Mr. Auerbach thinks the mental health syndrome of a cognitive disorder is not spread and caused by a virus and is not a communicable disease. Isn't that a big mistake?

I have to say that the names for certain laws impress me a lot for their creativity values. May be we need a STICK Act. Stop the Talking Irrational Congressional Kangaroos. Their pouches are too deep and a constant seduction to be filled up with unhealthy money viruses.

Good Morning, I feel sicko, may be I am already infected with the talking irrational virus. Thank you for informing us about the STOCK Act. Isn't that at least a little bit of something reasonable done by Obama? Please say yes. I can't take it anymore.

up
0 users have voted.
Alligator Ed's picture

@mimi

May be because Mr. Auerbach thinks the mental health syndrome of a cognitive disorder is not spread and caused by a virus and is not a communicable disease. Isn't that a big mistake?

The chief virus infecting those committing politics is the dreaded GREEN virus. This is infectious. Large quantities are stored in banks and Wall Street just as mold collects under damp carpets.

up
0 users have voted.
Lookout's picture

...

Inhaling the fumes of government propaganda is dangerous to your health

... be posted on all news broadcasts and publications, AE?

up
0 users have voted.

“Until justice rolls down like water and righteousness like a mighty stream.”