Christmas Lies My Mother Told Me
Recently, the 4 year old daughter of a friend of mine began asking questions about Santa Claus and how he was able to get inside their house when they had no chimney. My friend, who waived that detail away by telling her daughter that "Santa has the keys to all the houses", was met with a furrowed brow when Emma told her she didn't think Santa having the keys to all the houses in the world "was a very good idea".
The strange alchemy of the magical vs. the practical that goes on in every child's mind when confronted with the Santa Claus myth is both unique and universal, presenting parents with some amusing challenges in their quest to perpetuate the Santa Claus myth.
My Mother's Santa Story was more of an elaborate ruse where she arranged a candlestine Kaffezeit with Santa Claus on Christmas Eve (Kaffezeit: literally means coffee time in German; comparable to the English tea time, it's a snack of coffee and cakes usually taken after lunch and before the evening meal).
Because we followed the German tradition of celebrating Christmas on Christmas Eve, Santa had to drop off our presents while we were awake. My Mother's solution was to tailor her own version of Santa's visit with a flair for the dramatic that was part of my Mother's indulgent nature. This included sending us off with my Father, getting dressed in her evening finery, outfitting the coffee table with her wedding china and silver, along with her homemade sandtorte, and arranging Santa's presents under the tree. When my Sister and I arrived back home, she would exclaim, "Oh! You just missed Santa Claus!", pointing to the two cups of half drunken coffee that remained on the table as evidence. Clearly I was not as astute a child as the inquiring Emma to not have put together my outings with my Father coinciding with my Mother's annual kaffezeit with Santa, I only remember the wonderful feeling of imagining Santa sitting down on my couch drinking coffee with my Mother and nibbling on her pound cake! It all seemed so incredibly fantastic! And oh, look, there are presents too!
Later on my Mother was required to answer the more obvious questions; like how Santa was able to visit all the children in the world in one night, and how does he get into other people's houses when they're asleep. These were dispensed with my Mother's "magical rationale" which for the time being made sense to a six year old who had relegated Santa to that place where fairies and magical beings already lived, but eventually took an unexpected turn when my Sister and I asked my Mother why it never snowed on Christmas Day like it did in a "Charlie Brown Christmas"
"Because we live in Los Angeles where the weather is too warm", was my Mother's practical reality based answer.
This was not good enough for my Sister and me.
"But what if a miracle happened", we persisted. "Then could it snow on Christmas Day?"
Seeing where the conversation was going and wanting to keep the Santa Claus myth alive, my Mother relented and admitted, that yes, if a miracle happened, it could snow on Christmas Day.
That's all my Sister and I wanted to hear. Miracles were still intact. Santa was still living in the realm of fairies and magic, and maybe one day it would snow on Christmas Day.
Eventually it did, although not in Los Angeles. Many years later, when my Sister and I were faced with spending the first Christmas without my Mother after her death, we decided to visit our Aunt and cousins in Germany. Surrounded by family, picture albums, and memories it was both bittersweet and comforting. But perhaps my fondest memory of that trip, and my Sisters too, was waking up on Christmas morning in the city of my Mother's birth, only to discover that during the night it began to snow. And in honor of my Mother's recognition of miracles, my Sister and I went out in the snow and had the best snowball fight in the history of snowball fights on Christmas Day.
While I'm a stickler for the truth and living in a reality based world as an adult, I'll forgive my Mother for the "Big Lie" while I take a moment to reminisce in a sweet memory on Christmas Day of my Mother playing with us in the realm of make believe.
Merry Christmas and wishing everyone fond memories of their own!
Comments
Given that my faith is The Fairy Faith...
You'll understand that I believe in miracles. I think your mother was there in Germany, that she remembered that long ago conversation and that she put in a word with The Weather to bring you that snow...if she didn't create it on her own.
Thanks for this memory.
Thank you for that Shah
Sometimes, you just have to hold onto those memories in the absence of the person themselves. I enjoyed reliving them
There is always Music amongst the trees in the Garden, but our hearts must be very quiet to hear it. ~ Minnie Aumonier
I am happy to suspend reality as I perceive it
and it's a bland- to mad-time of year in the Northern Hemisphere. White here today and temperatures dropping through the rest of Sun-Sat week.
We are all okay. Except any who are not. I am feeling okay, not great. I received one gift bag by car yesterday and none today. Christmas postponed. Friday now, nearly New Year's.
Hey! my dear friends or soon-to-be's, JtC could use the donations to keep this site functioning for those of us who can still see the life preserver or flotsam in the water.
When I'm not feeling great
I like to suspend reality by watching movies, especially old holiday movies where they have all that fake snow that never melts when the actors come inside from out of the snow. Lol
I do, however, remember the winters back east when the snow did melt and was a terrible incumbrance to walk through. But I also remember that living in New York could be very festive during the holidays. I live in Southern California in the foothills of the San Gabriel mountains now, where we have giant deodars which line the entire street. Each year volunteers decorate them with hundreds of Christmas tree lights and it is quite fantastic to walk underneath them at night!
Hope you stay warm, riverlover, and stay safe this holiday season.
There is always Music amongst the trees in the Garden, but our hearts must be very quiet to hear it. ~ Minnie Aumonier
I really enjoyed this story
It's funny, but I never thought about Santa Claus being a big lie. Even when we knew the truth, both my sister and I still pretended to believe in Santa Claus. And even though our parents knew we knew, Santa still came to visit. I saw it as fun innocence of childhood that all of us in the family wanted to perpetuate. So even as near adults, every year at least one present under the tree came from Santa.
I know some people think it is wrong to lie about Santa or the tooth fairy or whatever, but I think we all need some fantasy in our lives. It is a relief from the harsh reality of every day living.
I do have a funny story about Christmas presents. My sister loved to try to guess what was in the wrapped gifts that came from our parents. I always wanted to be surprised, so I never would even look at my gifts. One year when we were teenagers, my sister had asked for a skateboard for Christmas. This was something she really wanted.
Then a package from Mom and Dad which was about the size and shape of a skateboard appeared under the tree with my sister's name on it. She got really excited and decided to shake it to confirm what she believed to be her skateboard. When she tilted the package back and forth, we could hear the sound of ball bearings. My sister was ecstatic.
On Christmas morning when she went to open her skateboard, she said how excited she was to get a skateboard. This was before she opened the present. Talk about disappointment. When she opened the skateboard package, inside was a brand new, shiny, study lamp! And a lesson was learned.
Do I hear the sound of guillotines being constructed?
“Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable." ~ President John F. Kennedy
My Sister and I did the same thing
With our presents under the tree when we were older. But my Mother got wise to us and then deviously left decoys where she'd put old books, wooden thread spools, and a few odd buttons in boxes and wrap them up. Imagine our surprise at opening up those on Christmas Eve! Definitely sympathize with your Sister's lesson!
Thanks for sharing your story
There is always Music amongst the trees in the Garden, but our hearts must be very quiet to hear it. ~ Minnie Aumonier
I can relate ...
one of the hardest thing for me in the US was that there was no Dec. 24th Christmas Day as we had it in Germany. I don't remember anymore, if I ever believed in the Santa Claus as a child, nor do I remember that my mother tried to make us believe in it.
But for us Christmas started the 24th with the Christmas Kaffee around 4:30 pm. It was the so-called "calm down and get into that typical German severely solemn mode you have to have to celebrate Christmas 'politically correct', even if you had not one ounce of relgious christian believes in you. I remember that we didn't talk a lot, my mother was totally exhausted with the Christmas preparations, my father finally got back from his "tour to meet all his employees personally" at their homes to wish them a Merry Christmas" and we were just thinking about the mandatory "sing along the Christmas carols" which we would have afterwards, when my mother ended the Kaffeerunde and went over to the piano. We all couldn't sing very well, or let's say not at all. My father never, ever could keep the right tone, but sang the loudest. My mother never, ever missed the right tone and actually could whistle the carols quite well. She was one kind of a whistler, breathing the air in and not out of her lips. That gave her whistle a certain special sound. We kids squeezed in some timid melodies with words.
AFter we were released from singing, a male person played Santa Claus. heh, no way any of us believed in our uncle or our mother speaking in a deep male voice was Santa Claus. No magic there, but ... ok... the bag of presents waiting there in the corner at the side of the Christmas tree made that failed pretending-being-Santa attempt worth to go along with what was expected from us, so we became the faux Santa believers. It was quite clear to us kids that the real believers in the magic of Santa Claus were all those adults. They got totally carried away and nuts with the idea. Sigh. the whole thingy lasted til around 10 pm when we finally got to eat. After midnight it was just bedtime, cozying up with our best present, usually a book or some music record.
Later in my life as an adult in the US I wanted to have my Kaffeerunde and get my son used to that tradition. It didn't work. My son's Dad never was willing to be on time for that Kafferunde. He remembered instead that it was time to go to church from his own childhood memories. So we went outside and looked for churches to go into. There were tons of churches in Washington DC, but we never could decide into which one we should go. I was not used to go to church as a child. My son's dad never went to church either as an adult, but by Christmas Eve his childhood memories just came up nagging his conscience again and he HAD to search for the church. Absolutely we HAD to find a church, each year again on Dec. 24th.
He actually was searching for the Christma songs, he remembered. (which all were sung in his own African dialect, though only around 30 000 people spoke that dialect. It was not a written language, just the bible and the songs got translated. I have heard these songs in his village church being sung by his extended family clan - and it was the most beautiful singing I ever heard - honestly).
Most of the Christmas Eve days in the US, I remember as being a frustrating affair for us. We never found the church to fit our mood. And of course, our moods were never the same.
The Christmas traditions all got wiped out in my little family while we lived here. One day I will find my church. The only 'religious' man I could listen to would be Chris Hedges. Most preachers I had heard were ok, but didn't touch my mind for more than the length of the sermon was. When I was at a church I remember always being nervous to find a preacher that I couldn't stand listening to. So I avoided going.
Zoebear, I am happy for you to have such fond memories and wish you that they will continue to give you much joy for the rest of your life. Merry Christmas to you and your family.
https://www.euronews.com/live
Appreciated your very honest account
Of your childhood memories. Especially enjoyed this description:
You have a wonderful way of capturing the humorous and human moments in those kinds of situations.
There is always Music amongst the trees in the Garden, but our hearts must be very quiet to hear it. ~ Minnie Aumonier
@mimi Christmas Eve is also
"More for Gore or the son of a drug lord--None of the above, fuck it, cut the cord."
--Zack de la Rocha
"I tell you I'll have nothing to do with the place...The roof of that hall is made of bones."
-- Fiver
Nice story, zoebear.
Have been thinking of this lately, since now the Boy is just past two. Both Christmas's have been without any fanfare and at this moment I see it continuing that way.
Loved the scene of the California girls giddily pummeling each other with snowballs (you learned fast!), thinking of your mother's promise. And your mom's setting is indeed wondrous too. We do need moments of that kind of "magic." But my memories, while fond also, I now realize were mostly just the expectations of spoiled kids who couldn't wait to pounce on their bounty. Looking back now, I see just piles of savagely ripped wrapping paper and big dumb plastic toys (many times war-related garbage, i.e. GI Joes, war board games, army men, etc), and I'm kind of disgusted by the propaganda of advertising that worked on all of us.
When I got a little older I stopped buying Xmas presents completely, and my family followed suit (except for my Mom still wanting to give a thing here and there). I resent the commodification of the entire holiday season, from the stupid songs while we dutifully do our Pavlovian duty of shopping, to the ugly rush of consumerism. Haven't got stuck in that hellish scene for at least 25 years now.
So yeah, am debating how I'll proceed with these two kids. My gut tells me it ain't gonna happen, especially not remotely the way we've been conditioned to do.
I do like the idea of something magical for the kids. In my own little way I've been doing that with my son since before he turned two earlier this month. Started calling attention to the moon at night. And whenever possible clutch him in my arms and take him up to the roof of my apartment to look for it. He now asks for the moon at various points during the day. He just started singing along to the song I've been singing to him too:
"If I should ever die, God forbid, let this be my epitaph:
THE ONLY PROOF HE NEEDED
FOR THE EXISTENCE OF GOD
WAS MUSIC"
- Kurt Vonnegut
Cheers to you and your family
[video:https://youtu.be/pu7AR0-FRro]
Snowball Fights
Well, truth is, we got lucky because the snow was pretty sticky. I also had a little practice in the art of snowball fighting when I used to skate at Wollman Rink in Central Park. Marvelous venue during the winter. Always brought my own special hot chocolate, if you know what I mean
I think you can make Christmas for your children in what ever way you feel is appropriate. With or without gifts. My Mother never had enough money for a lot of gifts. What she did have was a great sense of play and imagination. For her, the holiday was about closing off all the noise of the world and creating a world of make believe. This came easy for my Mother having grown up in post war Germany where watching American movies was an appealing way to block out the reality of everyday life. She was, in the most pure sense, always at her best when she was at play, and you could definitely feel that during the holidays. Now that she's gone, it's much more comforting to remember those things about her. Especially this time of year.
Hope you and your family have a lovely holiday!
There is always Music amongst the trees in the Garden, but our hearts must be very quiet to hear it. ~ Minnie Aumonier
@Mark from Queens For me, it's eat, drink,
Food, drink, friends, tree. Maybe lights for the outside.
I could do without the presents altogether. My mom still likes doing a stocking with me (our stockings were legendary in my youth), so we do that. But my family of choice and I don't buy each other presents. Kate is a fiber arts person, so she knitted each of us a pair of socks this year, but I think we'd all be more than OK without any presents.
When the Grinch steals Christmas, the only thing I'd miss are the tree and the roast beast. Otherwise, I sort of see him as a helpful spirit, taking the crap away.
"More for Gore or the son of a drug lord--None of the above, fuck it, cut the cord."
--Zack de la Rocha
"I tell you I'll have nothing to do with the place...The roof of that hall is made of bones."
-- Fiver
As a Single Mother
Working on a waitress salary, my Mother just didn't have the money for expensive presents. But she was creative, and like your friend who knitted socks for presents. My mother used to sew and knit us doll clothes. They were exquisitely done.
I like the decorations too
I have chili lights on my window and had someone help me with the lights on the tree outside my place. Very festive.
There is always Music amongst the trees in the Garden, but our hearts must be very quiet to hear it. ~ Minnie Aumonier
Hi zoe
I really enjoyed your Christmas story of childhood memories and the sense of innocence they reflect.
Wishing us all a touch of childhood innocence in our adult realities.
Thank you Janis
Love the picture post card. Reminds me of the advent calendars my Grandparents used to send us. Hope you a have a beautiful holiday, surrounded by people who love and appreciate you
There is always Music amongst the trees in the Garden, but our hearts must be very quiet to hear it. ~ Minnie Aumonier
What a tender and beautiful wish.
Thank you, zoebear.
Great story
Great comments
Thank you!
Marilyn
"Make dirt, not war." eyo