America's First Mass Student Movement

On April 22, 1936, half a million college students nationwide walked out of class for the Third Annual Student Strike Against War.
As impressive as that sounds, it is even more impressive when you consider that in the mid-30's there was less than 1.5 million college students.

This was the culmination of five years of student organizing and political agitation.
WWII would soon cut short this student movement, and it wouldn't rise again until the New Left of the 1960's.
However, this first mass student movement would lay the foundations for the next generation of student activists.

Until the economic and political crisis of the early 30's, student groups normally stayed clear of politics, and the few participate politically that did were concentrated in large eastern cities.

The origins of radical student politics in the United States can be traced to City College of New York.

The student body of CCNY in 1931 was one of the poorest in the nation. 80% of students there in 1938 were Jewish, most of them were from eastern European refugee families. Their concern about rising fascism in the world made this the perfect location for the creation of the National Student League, a coalition of communist and socialist students.
During this period of time it was common for 50-80% of college graduates to be unemployed. By 1933 it was normal for students (and the public in general) to question the viability of the capitalism.
While students were generally leftist, college administrations remained solidly conservative.

Start of a movement

The initial February 1931 issue of Frontiers magazine, published by the Social Problems Club, questioned the legitimacy of the ROTC on campus. Back then it was common for colleges to require compulsory service in the ROTC.
College president Frederick C. Robinson was beyond conservative. He was a fascist sympathizer. He confiscated the magazine and suspended the charter of the Social Problems Club. When the members of the club protested, Robinson suspended them from school.

A broad alliance of left-leaning student groups organized and put pressure on the NYC Board of Higher Education, through protests and letter writing. Eventually Robinson's edicts were rescinded, but the student alliances remained.

The NSL's next action was to send a student delegation to Harlan County, Kentucky in support of the striking miners who were being "legally murdered" by company thugs. About 80 student left New York by bus on March 23, 1932. Their arrival was met by angry crowds, somewhat similar to the reception to the Freedom Riders 30 years later.

The following year saw the Reed Harris case.

Harris, the crusading liberal editor of the Columbia Spectator, ran stories exposing the bad conditions in the campus dining hall with regard to the preparation of food and treatment of student waiters. He was clumsily expelled, in the course of a series of events which highlighted the high-handedness and hypocrisy of the Columbia administration...
Harris’ expulsion precipitated a sort of small-scale free speech movement, with thousands of students coming out in the first collegiate student strike of the decade on April 6, 1932, to manifest their indignant protest. The result was mainly a victory; Harris was reinstated, although he had first to make some concessions.

After the Reed case campus life, at least on the East Coast changed. Free speech fights, protests against fee hikes became common.
The faculty, OTOH, was increasingly put in a difficult situation. They often had sympathies with the students, but college administrations cracked down harder and harder. Some colleges started demanding loyalty oaths from the teachers. Public displays of radical politics often ended with faculty members being fired.

But it was compulsory ROTC that pushed things over the edge.
Ohio State and Cornell faculty and students petitioned the trustees to abolish compulsory ROTC. University of Minnesota students sponsored a "Jingo Day" protest and 1,500 attended.

Not to be outdone, the students at CCNY held their own “Jingo Day” anti-war demonstration on May 29, 1933, to protest an ROTC review.

On “Jingo Day,” President Robinson calls the police to disperse demonstrators. Students accuse President Robinson of attacking them with his umbrella; the administration accuses the students of “preventing the normal functioning of the school.” The Social Problems Club, the Student Forum, and the Liberal Club, as well as The Campus, the student newspaper, are suspended for supporting the demonstration. Twenty-one student leaders are expelled.

One uniting factor in all the student group was pacifism.

In 1934 the two radical student organizations launched what seemed to many at first a rather wild idea, but which turned out to be the most successful single action of the movement: a “Student Strike Against War.”

The date was set for the anniversary of the United State's entry into WWI, April 13, 1934. Students were told not to skip classes, but to actually walk out of their classrooms.
This first student strike, coordinated by the SLID was a surprising success with 25,000 participating, almost all of them in New York, despite administration threats.

“They are making fools of themselves.... What war are they worrying about anyway?”
- Fordham dean, 1935

CCNY President Robinson didn't get it.

President Frederick B. Robinson invites an official delegation of students representing Benito Mussolini’s fascist regime in Italy to be honored on October 9, 1934 at a special assembly in CCNY’s Great Hall. A fight breaks out at this event when campus authorities seek to halt the anti-fascist remarks of the CCNY student body president.
The Robinson administration expels twenty-one anti-fascist student leaders for disrupting this college event and dissolves the Student Council. Over one hundred students are called before a college disciplinary committee.

Robinson was heard to call the anti-fascist protestors "guttersnipes". This became a rallying call for the students.

The following April the Student Strike Against War protest was much larger and more widespread. Around 175,000 students participated nationwide. 130 campuses participated, including 20 in the south.
At Kansas University speakers urged students to work toward eliminating war profiteering and to remind people that war is "not inevitable".

However, it was not without a conservative reaction. At Michigan State a mob attacked the peaceful anti-war rally by throwing rotten fruit and eggs, and then grabbing five students and threw them in the river. The night before about 200 students had threatened the Jewish fraternity with violence.

The success of the second Strike Against War was followed up by the Third in 1936. This time the nationwide turnout was so enormous that the major media began questioning if the young people of the United States would even fight to defend the country in the event of war.
The turnout in the south was nothing short of amazing.

according to one enthusiastic observer, "For the first time the majority of students in the Negro colleges participated: Hampton Institute, Morehouse College, Virginia Union as well as the veteran Howard..."

Unlike the 1935 protest, this year's protest at KU was not without its problems, when someone lobbed a teargas bomb into the demonstration.

The 1936 strike had begun with a march by the “Veterans of Future Wars,” who satirized a military unit by wearing paper military hats and carrying signs saying “Unfair to Organized Hypocrisy.”

Only eight days after this huge peace demonstration, 1,000 students at CCNY staged the first large sit-in in American college history. They were protesting the firing of faculty activist Morris Schappes. Student agitation continued throughout May. Finally in June the NYC Board of Higher Education reinstated Schappes and twelve other dismissed faculty activists. Robinson was defeated again.

“Will the Communists Get Our Girls in College?”
- 1936 article title in Liberty magazine

At this point it appeared that students at American colleges had become totally radicalized.
So what happened?

Administrators began offering college facilities, such as auditoriums, for student meetings. They no longer threatened draconian punishment for demonstrations. “Peace Assemblies“ replaced the anti-war strikes.
In 1937 the Civil War in Spain began to look like just the first step towards world war. Pacifism began to lose its appeal. Comintern was pushing for a popular front against fascism, and that was incompatible with pacifism.
When the socialists were kicked out of the student movement in 1938, the Roosevelt Administration gave its approval of the American Students Union, in a letter of greetings to the convention from the President.
Finally when Hitler and Stalin signed their nonaggression pact in 1939, the entire left-wing split down the middle.

Afterward

On December 19, 1938, President Robinson submitted his letter of resignation. Ongoing student opposition had now bled into the CCNY Alumni Association.
Schappes is arrested on March 18, 1941, and sentenced to up to two years in prison for refusing to identify other communists within the CCNY faculty.

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

LapsedLawyer's picture

up
0 users have voted.

"Our society is run by insane people for insane objectives. I think we're being run by maniacs for maniacal ends and I think I'm liable to be put away as insane for expressing that. That's what's insane about it."
-- John Lennon

Wow,

memories of growing up in a socialist family with wall to wall political discussions and activism

and spending 2 years as a grad student at Berkeley during the days of the student anti war revolution

then I sat on my hands politically for 40 years until the 2004 presidential election and found the Franklin County Democratic Party in Columbus was a shell with one full time employee and hand me down computers. The one employee was outstanding, but the party was non existent. I asked what the party was doing for education in democracy and the answer was to hand out suggested voting cards.

here is the note to gjohnsit

please continue your writing here and on dailykos

with all its faults, dailykos still is an important voice and your diaries/articles are part of the ongoing education of citizens

what is your background? You write so well and so deeply on so many subjects. I recall when you came back from the Peace Corps stint at Dominican Republic and continued to follow you.

the biggest thing to happen is the Bernie Movement which is the only effort with any chance of making a dent in the coup de'tat in our country.

so, even if you seldom make it to the REC list there, please keep writing your excellent articles

those who spend their time defending the he said/she said child language of the parties in the light of the constitutional crisis we face are having a harder time with their defense

thanks for your work

Don

up
0 users have voted.
gulfgal98's picture

here is the note to gjohnsit

please continue your writing here and on dailykos

with all its faults, dailykos still is an important voice and your diaries/articles are part of the ongoing education of citizens

Personally your (gjohnsit's) diaries form a huge part of my education on the issues, particularly the issues of war and the economy. Sometimes I find that my own comments will not be adequate enough to add anything to the content of your (gjohnsit's) diaries but I always read and recommend them all. Like Don has said, many thanks for your work. Good

up
0 users have voted.

Do I hear the sound of guillotines being constructed?

“Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable." ~ President John F. Kennedy

Hi Dorthy,

I saw a comment you made on DK the other day and didn't want to respond there because you might not see it.

Yes DK sucks. When I attended an event for DK at the one of the NN events and Kos spoke that his/our/DK role was to elect democrats, I was pissed

and the site is full of Hillary supporters and probably paid dem party hacks

but, the site does have a spirited dialogue

and the site is flushing out the anti Bernie comments (recent diary with a list of them)

and there has been a major change over the years

it was sorta left to support dems in the past years when DK started

these days, the world is much, much worse and the dems support the 1% and dems are warmongers and dems are trying to give away sovereignty through trade deals

see my comment this morning on the coup that has happened

http://www.dailykos.com/comments/1443175/58137913

as of 9:40 that comment has had 34 recommendations. That is incredible.

and some of the early lights here on dailykos are now international players

Glenn Greenwald spoke at the first Netroot Nations that Kos pulled off by speaking, chairing panels, and generally running in circles. NN has moved on since then but it is aligned with the dem party more than I would like. Glenn is approaching 600K twitter followers world wide

Jesselyn Radack was an early poster her and now is an international atty for whistle blowers. Likewise, Thomas Drake posted here a few times. I follow both of them on twitter. My twitter feed is oriented to surveillance and foreign policy.

Marcy Wheeler was an early poster there but for some years has had her own web site and continues with excellent work. Confession - her work is incredibly detailed and I seldom read it in depth and I stopped following here on twitter because she posts too much.

and back when DK started, we used to go to NY TImes and WA post for news. I get Sunday times at home but only go to those webs sites now when I am following a link

in other words, the premier news sites have been less important to me than The Intercept and commondreams.org

And there are the incredible number of comments on dailykos. Marcy Wheeler, Emptywheel, only gets a few comments and likewise for Kevin Gosztola who started Shadowproof with excellent reporting and only a few comments.

people on DK are interested in elections and how they can shape policy. There is strong support on racial issue and women issues and other topics

I am currently using the daily Bernie News Roundup to post issues oriented comments

Long winded statement - in summary, DK will never be at the forefront like it was in the early days. As Glenn Greenwald responded when asked about a billionaire funding The Intercept, that it takes money to go after power. They have spent tens of millions on legal fees related to their coverage of Edward Snowden and other topics.

It is sad when strong voices like Joanne Leonard (joanneleon), bobswern, Evening Blues which is now posted here, and others leave that site.

But it is important

I don't spend much time there even though it looks like it

Dorthy please respond so that I know that you at least read this

thanks

don

up
0 users have voted.
gulfgal98's picture

I just wanted to tell you that I am very glad to see you posting here more often. I learn a lot from reading your posts. Thank you. Nancy

up
0 users have voted.

Do I hear the sound of guillotines being constructed?

“Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable." ~ President John F. Kennedy

enhydra lutris's picture

up
0 users have voted.

That, in its essence, is fascism--ownership of government by an individual, by a group, or by any other controlling private power. -- Franklin D. Roosevelt --

both of you follow economics

and many other people here do as well

a noted person who responds to my emails is David Cay Johnston. If you clicked on my comment on dailykos today

David Cay JOHNSTON
9:54 AM (1 hour ago)

to me
Thanks for the link.

I am now busy drafting an entirely new federal tax code with these features:

- progressive rates that do not stop at the thresholds for the 1% (mostly two income professionals) but continue into the billions...
- cheat proof unless you engage in a criminal conspiracy with the standard for conviction being conduct not intent (no mens rea)
- no corporate income tax but all corporate profits are taxed by restoring a principle in the first corporate income tax in 1909
- Lifetime deferral of capita income that is reinvested, but full taxation of gains at death (with provisions to protect spouses and for small businesses to pay over time with interest)
- NO NO NO borrowing against capital accounts for consumption (how billionaires escape most tax)
- no tax returns except for those who choose to be sole proprietors

In short all gains get taxed and those that are deferred are deferred against rising values, not a fixed value, tone of the biggest tax avoidance games today.

You may want to read this Newsweek cover story, which explains current deferral in the context of "if you could buy a house the way multinational corporate America pays its taxes":
http://bit.ly/1Aa8xQ3

And, again, thanks for the post at Kos.

up
0 users have voted.
shaharazade's picture

I really enjoy your history diary's This one is really interesting as my knowledge of mass student strikes and activism begins with my own student days. I read Howard Zinn's A People's History of the US about 10 years ago at the urging of my nephew who was attending Evergreen an environmental college in WA. Most of my knowledge about student strikes starts with Paris 1968 and Danny the Red and the SDS and other student movements here. Up against the Wall Motherfuckers.

In the early 70's I lived for a few months in NYC with some CU students on 114th and Amsterdam right across from the Columbia University campus. I had to cross the campus to get to my subway stop. There were riot lights that had been installed after the 1968-9 student strikes and I liked crossing the campus at night when I got off work as it was so well lit. The Alma Mater statue with a hole blown out of it had not yet been repaired yet. As I walked home at night I passed the war torn Minvera, backlit by the riot lights. An eerie sight in the quiet night, as you could feel the echo's of the campus takeover.

Thanks for the back history of the 30's student strikes. I noticed in reading today about the late 60's student unrest that both here and in Paris the student activists formed coalitions with other groups. In Paris it was with workers and at Columbia, antiwar students formed a coalition African American's in Harlem who were fighting the university's expansion into the black community. Too bad that the left today cannot seem to find solidarity and form coalitions with each other. Nowadays it's all about my or your identity and 'issues'. At a time of globalization by the powers that be you would think that a global movement of people would form solidarity and build coalitions to stop this shit.

up
0 users have voted.