Delusions

The sheer longevity of the “Stop the Steal” movement must cause us to consider its ramifications if only because the fact of so many of our friends and neighbors being so utterly deluded suggests a deep-seated denial of the social compact upon which our nation rests. The depth of passion of its adherents coupled with their dedication to their fearless leader must give further pause. If that passion issues from fear and uncertainty, then it suggests the possibility of physical danger to ourselves and to our families. It is that very passion which forces us to ask: “what is it that they are looking at?” What is it that they are seeing? To deny that they are seeing something is to join them in their denial leaving us all at a loss.

We see their delusions. Trump as a great leader therefore the election must have been stolen, the ridiculous adversaries that they set up in their culture wars, the threats they feel from ordinary citizens. Is it possible that they are reacting to delusions that they impute to us? If so, what might they be?

If we consider their actions, then we can group them together to see if they line up in a recognizable direction.
Group “A”:
• Armed surveillance of voting locations
• Rejection of early voting
• A broad and sustained effort to curtail, suppress, and discourage voting
• Denigrating the term “Democratic” (as opposed to “Republican”) by insisting on using “democrat” as in democrat proposals, democrat policies, democrat Senators; this done with great relish
• A deep seated distrust of the entire process of government: executive, legislative, judicial
• A total adherence to the party line with no concern for compromise
• A total willingness for public officials to lie, cheat, steal in support of the party line and/or the quest for personal power
• No concern whatsoever for the “greater good”, the security and wellbeing of our nation
• A willingness to commit acts of treason in support of the party line and/or the quest for personal power
• A willingness to operate their political party as a criminal enterprise
• Much is made of saying the Pledge of Allegiance before every single meeting of Congress

Group “B”:
• Utter disdain for “political correctness”
• Utter hatred of “Black Lives Matter” and “Me Too”
• An insistence on fighting a culture war
• An utter disdain for the lives, liberty, and wellbeing of persons of color
• A vitriolic hatred for abortion
• Hatred for the entire sexual orientation alphabet
• Insistence upon the existence of a two-tiered justice system.

The actions and attitudes presented in Group “A” seem to be constellated around the nature of our government itself. Like almost everyone, when asked what form of government the United States has, I would say “it’s a democracy”. This, of course, is not true. The correct description is “a constitutional republic”. It has never been a democracy and was designed specifically to avoid all possibility of being thought of as a democracy:
The word “democracy” appears only once in the official journal of the “federal convention” held in Philadelphia beginning in May of 1787. It appears in the last several pages of the notes made by James Madison and during the final debate immediately preceding the vote on whether or not to sign that document which became known as the “Constitution of the United States”. The word is attributed to Mr. Gerry of Massachusetts and reflected the sentiments of all of the members in attendance. The journal reads:

“In Massachusetts, particularly, he saw the danger of this calamitous event [civil war]. In that state there are two parties, one devoted to democracy, the worst, he thought, of all political evils; the other, as violent in the opposite extreme.”

In other writings by other members, democracy was described as the pathway to tyranny and as that approach most susceptible to the installation of a despotic ruler. The members were all very sensitive as to how their new government should be viewed by their trading partners in Europe and especially given the events in France and in Massachusetts in what became known as “Shays’s Rebellion”. For these reasons, the “Bill of Rights” was left out of the Constitution. When five states refused to consider ratifying the Constitution without the “Bill of Rights” included in it, an agreement to amend it in after ratification was reached with three of those states. Rhode Island and North Carolina did not ratify until after the amendments were made.
The words of Mr. Gerry of Massachusetts (above) should be taken to heart as they describe the current condition of our nation. It is interesting to note that the recent attempt to establish an autocracy in our country attacked the very thing—the only thing—that prevents our form of government from being a democracy.
The word “democracy” does not appear anywhere in our Constitution, the Declaration of Independence, or the Pledge of Allegiance. In the Pledge, of course, the word is “republic”.
No citizen of the United States has ever voted to elect either a President or a Vice-President. All votes cast in such elections are to elect delegates to the Electoral College. For this reason, the phrase “the popular vote” is empty of meaning.
No doubt some things are seen by both sides. It is difficult to ignore the fact that at least six Supreme Court Justices and every single Congressperson is beholden to moneyed interests. Sure, we get to vote directly for our Congresspersons, but we have very little say in who runs for office. We are given a choice between either Puppet “R” or Puppet “D” and endure the laughter as we try to convince ourselves that the lesser of two evils is not also evil. If the moneyed interests are seen to be too far away, then the illusion of a democracy becomes impossible to maintain.

Perhaps the belief that we live in a “democracy” is imputed to the rest of us as a delusion?

The actions and attitudes presented in Group “B” seem to be constellated around the concepts of “equality” and “rights”. There is, of course, a two-tiered justice system. There always has been and there always will be. Nothing could possibly establish that as fact beyond the treatment of their fearless leader. Given this and the concentration of wealth in our country, we must admit (as we sometimes do) that belief in equality in our country is the acceptance of a delusion. Perhaps Orwell put it best: “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.” This was, of course, aimed at the Soviet Union, but if the shoe fits…
If “equality” has yet to be realized in our country, we must look at “rights” in a different way. Contrary to popular opinion, popularity polls do not establish rights. In our country, rights are established in our Constitution. Therefore, women still do not have rights equal to men and will not unless and until the ratification deadline for the “Equal Rights Amendment” is extended by Congress. Similarly and despite chants and placards to the contrary, abortion is not a right. Claims that abortion and sexual identity are rights are untrue. Exercising the right to have preferences does not make a preference into a right. Some of us realize this even while chanting in the street, but most do not. It must be said that those who do not realize it are deluded. Certainly, when the polls do not go our way, we do not assume that the other side has established a right.

Perhaps the belief that we live in “equality” and enjoy certain “rights” is imputed to the rest of us as a delusion?

Humans have delusions. Some delusions are shared by many humans. Since delusions are irrational, arguing about them is pointless. Short of agreeing to accept each other’s’ delusion, it may be possible to admit that we all have delusions and to agree to tune down the volume and rhetoric as we all indulge in our own preferred delusions. Maybe then we can agree on the things that we all see.

Share
up
7 users have voted.

Comments

enhydra lutris's picture

analyze, critique etc. in that post. I'm sure that you know that some of those things cross party lines, and that some in each party reject some things and some in each party buy into them.

One exception is "Democrat" versus Democratic". That is rendere problemaatic by the fact that the DemocraticTM party isn't at all democratic, leading to things like calling them "Big D" democrats, etc. (I'm aware that the republican party isn't republican, but there is no catchy thing to do to it like they do to the Dems.) Of course, they love to do it because it pisses the dems off because they believe heavily in the magic of words, substituting them for actions whenever possible.

Anyway, it is dome one thing that one can arguably address quickly. Since the Democrats (not Democratics, you might note) are clearly autocratic or otherwise non-democratic, they should henceforth be universally clearly referred to as a BRAND and not really a party, as DemocratsTM, The Democratic PartyTM, DemsTM, etc.

be well and have a good one

up
8 users have voted.

That, in its essence, is fascism--ownership of government by an individual, by a group, or by any other controlling private power. -- Franklin D. Roosevelt --

enhydra lutris's picture

@enhydra lutris

&lt sup &gt TM &lt /sup &gt

up
4 users have voted.

That, in its essence, is fascism--ownership of government by an individual, by a group, or by any other controlling private power. -- Franklin D. Roosevelt --

usefewersyllables's picture

@enhydra lutris

Committed to my electronic virtual Post-It note full of tricks...

up
5 users have voted.

Twice bitten, permanently shy.

enhydra lutris's picture

@usefewersyllables

&lt is supposed to be the less than symbol, and &gt greater than, but it didn't come out that way.

be well and have a good one

up
3 users have voted.

That, in its essence, is fascism--ownership of government by an individual, by a group, or by any other controlling private power. -- Franklin D. Roosevelt --

@enhydra lutris
a semi colon at the end, after the "t" on both instances.

&lt-; &gt-; (remove the dashes)

< sup > TM < /sup >

up
6 users have voted.
enhydra lutris's picture

@JtC

be well and have a good one

up
4 users have voted.

That, in its essence, is fascism--ownership of government by an individual, by a group, or by any other controlling private power. -- Franklin D. Roosevelt --

Socialprogressive's picture

@enhydra lutris
Hold the alt key and enter 0153 on the numeric keypad.

up
5 users have voted.

I woke up this morning determined to drink less, eat right, and exercise.
But that was four hours ago when I was younger and full of hope.

enhydra lutris's picture

@Socialprogressive @Socialprogressive

is those good old Alt+numeral codes. Alt is a very dangerous key on my rig. My equivalent of that trip is ctrl-shift-u, release +4 digit hex code, space or other character for appropriate unicode character. The table of same is huge. Per das googly, it should be 2122 ™, which worked, but i could use it being larger, like TM

be well and have a good one

edit - it looked way smaller in draft.

up
3 users have voted.

That, in its essence, is fascism--ownership of government by an individual, by a group, or by any other controlling private power. -- Franklin D. Roosevelt --

much there to ponder
please keep us informed if development of your ideas progress
you may find a responsive audience here.

Q

up
5 users have voted.
strollingone's picture

@QMS @QMS: If there is anything here to see, then it will reveal itself slowly...the fog of war, perhaps. The energy being wasted on ridicule and provocation really does need to be redirected both to avoid something very negative and to begin to build something positive. The emotional content of delusion removes it from the possibility of intellectual resolution. Kind of like trying to convince a four year-old that they are not bored or a spouse that they are not being taken for granted.

up
6 users have voted.

@strollingone

why does my wife of 35 years suddenly want a divorce?
midlife crises, not properly worshipped, or 4 year old
mindset. Who knows. Gotta roll with the changes.

really does need to be redirected

thanks again for your expressions!

up
6 users have voted.
Creosote.'s picture

@strollingone
Here I am, awake up late in a 'comfortable' neighborhood where I'm likely seen if at all as an old person with no car or interests.
I came from the other place because I needed 99's posters' range of knowledge, courage and care and now give thanks to those working to bring the deep grit needed to create the carpet we can walk on without sinking and try to build further on here.
In my local life I've found almost no hunger for or interest in even major areas of concern. I had expected, earlier, to find real depth of care for major ethical concerns ~ yet most "took whatever there was to take and threw the rest away."
Still alive at least after a recent repair to the tricuspid valve.
What happens next?

up
4 users have voted.
snoopydawg's picture

@Creosote.

Glad to hear that your surgery went well and that you still are. I can’t sleep either so take that in mind.

I had expected, earlier, to find real depth of care for major ethical concerns ~ yet most "took whatever there was to take and threw the rest away."

I pondered this and thought it might be because people’s minds have just been worn down after the last decade of constant propaganda and being told that 2+2=5 now and people are just exhausted from trying to tell others that it’s still 4. Then I read fire’s comment below and it makes sense. After 5 years of Russia Russia Russia and Orange Man Bad Durham laid out the truth for everyone on a golden platter and people think he’s full of it because of how those hip deep in it responded to it or they were still shoveling the shit which befuddled people’s minds even more.

Face it. …. It’s very hard to continue to see through the propaganda day after day after day. People went through this and then they were hit with Covid Covid Covid only then to get hit with Russia bad again and Ukraine good. Seriously whose mind wouldn’t be turned to mush?

Maybe that’s not what you meant. But maybe it’s just people who should care are just so worn out. Dunno. Grain of salt since my brain doesn’t do well in the morning anytime

Smile

up
5 users have voted.

Which AIPAC/MIC/pharma/bank bought politician are you going to vote for? Don’t be surprised when nothing changes.

Sima's picture

@snoopydawg
is very good. I will be re-reading it every day for a while. Thanks!

up
2 users have voted.

If you're poor now, my friend, then you'll stay poor.
These days, only the rich get given more. -- Martial book 5:81, c. AD 100 or so
Nothing ever changes -- Sima, c. AD 2020 or so

Creosote.'s picture

@snoopydawg
My sense is that people are living, in a way, very far above the ground on ladders they can't see that have missing rungs and no destination, and with no idea that any alternatives exist. It's almost as if the idea of alternatives is foreign, of no interest, or impossible. In my family I saw it as one parent's family left farming in the 1950s, moved to a western city, and found nothing worth doing. At thanksgiving television westerns played on in the living room. I never heard music there; the literature I did see was a few clippings of prayers from some local paper scotch-taped to the wall over the sink or stove.

On the other hand I've just discovered a group called Nation, or The Nation, that is doing very sound work. Their song "Eucalyptus" may be a good introduction, though one has to go to "lyrics" sites to get more details of the writing.

I'm glad you are here!

up
0 users have voted.

Speaking of delusions, this is from a recent article in The Nation Magazine. While making a stubborn effort to justify Trump Hate, it nevertheless recounts the delusional thinking cued up by Hillary R. Clinton to the effect that Trump was in cahoots with the Hitler du-jour, Vladimir Putin:

With the release of special counsel John Durham’s report on the origins of the Trump-Russia investigation, one of the strangest scandals in American history has ended not with a bang but with the most simpering possible whimper. Although Donald Trump and his supporters on the right claim that the report vindicates their long-held theories of a “deep state” conspiracy against the former president, on examination it offers little more than a rehashing of old arguments that were long ago made irrelevant by the passage of time.

Russiagate was widely considered to be the most important news story in the world. The idea that Trump was, in Hillary Clinton’s famous words, Putin’s “puppet” dominated headlines and political conversation, drowning out countless other topics. In August 2019, then–New York Times Executive Editor Dean Baquet addressed the newspaper’s staff in a town hall and described the editorial thinking of the previous years. According to Baquet, “Chapter 1 of the story of Donald Trump, not only for our newsroom but, frankly, for our readers, was: Did Donald Trump have untoward relationships with the Russians, and was there obstruction of justice?” Baquet noted that the release of special counsel Robert Mueller’s much-anticipated report in March 2019 forced many to rethink their assumptions about the story. Or should have.

Trump’s fans of course have heard the dishonest claims about how Russia stole the 2016 election. To them, the possibility of an election being stolen is not some weird and out-of-bounds hyperbole, but what the dems and the national media did to their candidate of choice. This does not make them correct, but it does show that their delusional thinking is not unique to their particular cult. Their opposition, with their own blind faith in “liberal” politicians like Biden and Harris, is every bit as delusional as MAGA loony birds.

up
10 users have voted.

I cried when I wrote this song. Sue me if I play too long.

TheOtherMaven's picture

@fire with fire

is ignorant or delusional, or both. The shenanigans since at least 2000 have been well documented - and both major parties are equally dirty.

I sometimes wonder if we have ever really had "free and fair" elections, or if that too is a delusion.

up
8 users have voted.

There is no justice. There can be no peace.

usefewersyllables's picture

@TheOtherMaven

this morning via WayOfTheBern/Saidit:

h/t to u/BerryBoy1969 for that one.

up
4 users have voted.

Twice bitten, permanently shy.

#3.1 The OP complacently assumes that the "undeluded" reader "knows" that it is delusional to believe that the 2020 election -- conducted during massive social dislocation from a bevy of mandates and restrictions -- was tainted by corruption. I heard this rap a week or two ago on a call from my brother who lives in Dallas: "Polls show that over half of Trump supporters believe that the 2020 election was stolen. That is just crazy." I diplomatically agreed that there is a lot of craziness these days.

So this meme is making the rounds. Part of the slide into civil war that has been going on since 2016. Dueling accusations of insanity -- with both sides clearly correct in their respective assessments in our world gone crazy.

up
7 users have voted.

I cried when I wrote this song. Sue me if I play too long.