Caitlin Johnstone on Ukraine-Russia


From Caitin Johnstone


They’re Just Outright Telling Us That Peace In Ukraine Is Not An Option

US Senator Joe Manchin said at the World Economic Forum on Monday that he opposes any kind of peace agreement between Ukraine and Russia.

Manchin, who at the moment is one of the most powerful elected officials in Washington, added that only the complete forcible ejection of Russia from all of Ukraine is acceptable, that the war should ideally be used to remove Putin from power, and that he and the strategists he talks to see this war as an "opportunity".

"I am totally committed, as one person, to seeing Ukraine to the end with a win, not basically with some kind of a treaty; I don't think that is where we are and where we should be," Manchin said.

"I mean basically moving Putin back to Russia and hopefully getting rid of Putin," Manchin added when asked what he meant by a win for Ukraine.

Joe Manchin, speaking today at the World Economic Forum, rejects the idea that the Ukraine war should ever be resolved with "some type of a treaty." Instead demands fighting "to the end," until total victory -- which includes "getting rid of Putin"

— Michael Tracey (@mtracey) May 24, 2022

Manchin clarified that he did not mean pushing Putin back to "pre-February", ostensibly meaning with Russia still controlling the largely Moscow-loyal Crimea and supporting separatist territories in the Donbass, but with Kyiv fully reclaiming all parts of the nation.

"Oh no, I think Ukraine is determined to take their country back," Manchin said when asked to clarify, further clarifying that he wants his call for regime change in Russia to be carried out by "the Russian people."

"I believe strongly that I have never seen, and the people I talk strategically have never seen, an opportunity more than this, to do what needs to be done," Manchin later added. "And Ukraine has the determination to do it. We should have the commitment to support it."

Manchin's comments fit in perfectly with what we know about the US-centralized empire's real agendas in Ukraine.

Earlier this month Ukrainian media reported that UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson told the nation's president Volodymyr Zelensky on behalf of NATO powers that “even if Ukraine is ready to sign some agreements on guarantees with Putin, they are not.”

Last month US Secretary of "Defense" Lloyd Austin acknowledged that the goal in this war is not peace in Ukraine or the mere military defeat of Russia but to actually weaken Russia as a nation, saying "We want to see Russia weakened to the degree that it can’t do the kinds of things that it has done in invading Ukraine."

Last week The New York Times reported that the Biden administration is developing plans to "further choke Russia’s oil revenues with the long-term goal of destroying the country’s central role in the global energy economy."

Just the other day Ukraine’s military intelligence chief announced that the mission has already creeped forward from the goal of defeating the Russian invaders to reclaiming the Crimean territory which was annexed by the Russian Federation in 2014.

Two months ago Biden himself acknowledged what the real game is here with an open call for regime change, saying of Putin, "For God’s sake, this man cannot remain in power."

Statements from the Biden administration in fact indicate that they expect this war to drag on for a long time, making it abundantly clear that a swift end to minimize the death and destruction is not just uninteresting but undesirable for the US empire.

This is not a proxy war with peace as an option anywhere within sight. It's not about saving Ukrainian lives. It's not even about beating Russia in Ukraine. It's about achieving regime change in Moscow, no matter how many lives need to be destroyed in the process.

Peace is not on the menu.

All forward motion in this war has nothing but violence as far as the eye can see on its trajectory into the future. No matter how much wealth and war machinery you pour into this conflict, that trajectory of death and destruction will just keep stretching out to the horizon. As Chris Hedges recently explained, war is the only path the empire has left open to itself.

I've seen some cute kids in my time, but nobody's as adorable as people who think the US pours weapons into foreign nations in order to achieve peace.

[edited for length]


I'm not so sure as Caitlin about the motivation for all this idiotic bellicosity coming from the Empire. But I do agree with her that this is bat shit crazy -- crazier than anything that has ever come before now.

Since Russia and China are nuclear powers, we can't just have a war with either of these brutal, fascist, anti-democratic, utterly evil, psychotic and hopelessly inept Sworn Enemies of Each and Every American Citizen and Ally.

Nope, we are not evil and we do not start wars ever. We punish warmongers with sanctions and with support for their enemies. See how smart we are?

So, in order to weaken Russia, we need to keep them bogged down in Ukraine and we cannot let Russian sympathizers within Ukraine divert us from the task of making Putin look bad to his own people.

Once sufficiently weakened and with Boris Yeltsin II in charge, we will finally ACHIEVE . . . . uh what?


I keep saying that nobody is THAT kind of stupid.

In either case -- lip farting dumbbells or functionaries following a larger "plan" -- this crap will not fly with anybody for any length of time. I just saw gasoline selling for $7.29 a gallon in Los Angeles, across the street from the Beverly Center. I also just this morning had occasion to visit the three story shopping center at Sunset Blvd and Laurel Canyon. Two thirds of the shopping units were vacant. All along the iconic streets of Hollywood -- Beverly, Melrose, Santa Monica -- there are dozens and dozens of empty store fronts.

Stagflation is already the New Normal.

Whereas I still see lots of people wearing masks, including me, I have seen exactly one example of "Support for Ukraine" here in WeHo -- a single poster, lost in a bevy of other unrelated posters, on the side wall of carpet store. You really could not make out the text without standing right in front of it.

Whereas I have friends and relatives who are still very concerned about Covid and related issues, I do not know anybody in real life who gives a fuck about this situation. I'm pretty sure the knee-jerk Democrats would parrot the party line if asked about Ukraine -- but the issue could not be more abstract or more distant from daily life.

The idea that Biden can blame the rising prices and collapsing economy on Putin is beyond preposterous.

Yet the lunacy marches forward as if it made any sense at all . . . .

24 users have voted.


I played with neighborhood kids from about age 11 through my college years when pot made the game a lot more fun. By the end and two players had zillions of 10-Armies making the battles last dozens of rolls it got pretty boring.

And then creepy old adulthood busted up the party. Which has brought a flashing memory of the odd "countries" of the Risk! world.

The Ukraine is a country, but Russia is not. And can anybody tell me what ever happened to that The?

9 users have voted.

I cried when I wrote this song. Sue me if I play too long.

Russia will take a large part of yesterday's Ukraine. The area referred to as Novorossiya, from the Donesk in the East along the coast of the Black Sea to Odessa is historically Russian. It is being liberated from Ukrainians who hate Russians, the Russian language and everything about them. There is a hard promise to these Russians that they will never have to go back to being terrorized by Ukrainians, Azov and other Nazis. This is a promise that can never be broken. That so many American politicians also have the attitude that no compromise is possible makes the solution both obvious and very dangerous. Ukrainians and the West have to realize that only Western Ukraine is the real core Ukraine and realize that they will have to secure peace with Novorossiya and Russia. This will take a very long time. Russia may have to take Western Ukraine to achieve peace. The West Will have a fit and it will become a permanent world partition, 86% of the world with Russia, China, India etc. and 14% with the West. Russia is more than ready for this. The US is not ready for the complete collapse of its imagined empire.

17 users have voted.

Capitalism has always been the rule of the people by the oligarchs. You only have two choices, eliminate them or restrict their power.

shaharazade's picture

on the net is absurd. Yet it's all scary as this is the reality being pumped as reality. It's not. Yet it's hard to ignore as there is no media available for people to read or watch. TV? hahahaha. Got no TV got no cable and yet I read and turn on my computer to see what condition my condition is in. It's not good. Neither is the world we are al