Libby, Montana

My family moved to Libby, Montana in the 1970's when I was still young. I spent the largest part of my childhood growing up in this tiny, mountain town.

  The city only had about 2,000 people in it and you had to drive about 90 minutes on Highway 2 to get to a city of any real size. There was almost no crime, despite (or because of) the fact that guns were everywhere. No matter where you were in town, if you went 10 minutes in any direction you were in middle of the wilderness. It wasn't unusual for people to hunt deer without ever leaving their front porch.

 It wasn't a perfect town by any means. There was few good paying jobs. The school system was mediocre. The people who lived there were often rednecks.

  But the water, the land, and the air were pristine. Everyone who visited called it "God's Country".

 So you can imagine how surprised I was when I learned that Libby, Montana is now listed as a toxic Superfund site by the EPA.

  First and foremost, Libby is a logging town. Everyone there, no matter the sex or age, knows how to use a splitting mall and a chainsaw. Chances are that someone in your family worked in the forest or at the St. Regis logging mill (until it closed). You either cut trees or you worked for the Forest Service. A rare few taught at the schools or worked behind a bar.

 However, there was one exception - the Zonolite mine.

 In its heyday, the mine produced 80 percent of the world's vermiculite. It was the area's largest employer from 1924 to 1990. At times its largest stack spewed 10,000 pounds of asbestos each day, according to W.R. Grace figures.

As the dust settles

 The first I heard about the dangers of zonolite was when the movie, Libby, Montana, showed up on the recommended list of my Netflicks.

  But the story had been broken several years before.

 First, it killed some miners.

Then it killed wives and children, slipping into their homes on the dusty clothing of hard-working men.

Now the mine is closed, but in Libby, the killing goes on.

The W.R. Grace Co. knew, from the time it bought the Zonolite vermiculite mine in 1963, why the people in Libby were dying.

But for the 30 years it owned the mine, the company did not stop it.

Neither did the governments.

 W.R. Grace is a multi-billion dollar conglomerate.

  In 2005 they were indicted by the Justice Department and the EPA for knowingly endangering the residents of Libby. But W. R. Grace had filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in 2001.

  But before W. R. Grace filed for bankruptcy they took time to hide funds.

 In May 2002, the Justice Department intervened in Grace's bankruptcy, the first time it had entered this type of case. The federal charges alleged that before Grace filed for Chapter 11, it concealed money in new companies it bought. Justice Department lawyers said Grace's action was the "fraudulent transfer" of money to another of its companies to protect itself from civil suits.

"Grace allegedly removed billions of dollars of assets against which parties who were injured or damaged by Grace's asbestos-containing material had claims," the Justice Department told the court.



view from the mine

 The EPA began investigating the site in 1999, but W. R. Grace obstructed the investigation for nearly two years.

 This isn't the first time that W. R. Grace has found itself the subject of a civil lawsuit. Grace paid $8 Million to eight Woburn, Massachusetts families after children died of leukemia from drinking well water contaminated by a W. R. Grace factory.

 Approximately 1,200 residents of Libby have been identified with some sort of asbestos-related abnormality. That's right. About a third of the people who have lived in Libby these past few decades.

  More than 200 people have died from the asbestos in the mine's vermiculite ore, although the number could be much higher. Another 375 people have been diagnosed with fatal diseases directly related to the asbestos.

 There have been hundreds of civil actions against W. R. Grace, but the district court is only allowing one civil actions every three months. Given the amount of time involved, the asbestos is taking care of the plaintiffs almost faster than the courts.

 Throughout Lincoln County are families torn apart by asbestos, but none has paid a higher price than the Bundrocks. Six of the family's seven members have been diagnosed with asbestos-related disease.

Arthur Bundrock worked at the mine for 19 years. He died last summer on the front lawn of his house, having left his oxygen bottle inside.

[...]

  The main illnesses caused by airborne asbestos are mesothelioma, or cancer of the pleural lining of the lung; cancer of the lung itself; and asbestosis, a thickening and scarring of the lungs.

The microscopic asbestos fibers are so small they hang suspended in the air for extended periods. When inhaled, they can penetrate, then irritate the lung. The lung cannot remove an asbestos fiber that has speared into its tissue. It cannot be coughed out or washed out of the tissue by blood. So the area around the fiber becomes inflamed, and eventually the site becomes scarred.

Over a period of years it becomes impossible to take a deep breath. The tissue changes from the elasticity and thickness of a balloon to that of a thick orange peel. When breathing is restricted, oxygen cannot get into the lungs and carbon dioxide and other impurities cannot get out.

 At this point you may be wondering how such a huge percentage of the people in Libby could have gotten contaminated.

  I can answer that.

  My family had a two-story log house in Libby that sat on two acres at the edge of town. The only access to the attic was through the closet in my bedroom. I used to notice a fine layer of dust on some of my shirts and a small pile of dust directly under the access panel.

   Our attic was filled with zonolite, tailings from the mine. It seems that zonolite makes great insulation. W. R. Grace, instead of paying to dispose of the tailings, offered them to anyone in Libby who wanted to shovel it into their pickup truck and drive away with it. Grace, of course, never bothered to mention that it was dangerous.

 According to the last news I've read, the legal action against W. R. Grace continues. Executives at Grace could face 15 years in prison.

  The EPA continues clean the hundreds of contaminated homes in Libby, one at a time.

  The zonolite continues to exist in 15 to 35 million homes and businesses throughout America and the world.

 At my class reunion I asked some classmates about the issue. Their response was that it was no big deal.

  If you know people from small, isolated, mountain towns, this response shouldn't surprise you.

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

now, she's on disability and was basically priced out of the west side of the state. She's got friends over there who worked at Hanford. When that leak happened a couple weeks ago, she was worried but not hysterical. Her ex husband was really upset as they have a daughter. But the one's who used to work at Hanford just shrugged and said no big deal. Maybe it's just easier to believe that when you've put yourself at that kind of risk?

I hope you're OK after living around that dust, my God. I read "A Civil Action" several times about Woburn, great book and made me look at the whole personal injury "ambulance chaser" thing a lot more sympathetically too.

up
0 users have voted.

Only a fool lets someone else tell him who his enemy is. Assata Shakur

PriceRip's picture

@lizzyh7

          ... constitute a dichotomous population. I am of one type, the other type just shrug it off. Too many of the wrong type work in industrial and national laboratories. This incident is a big deal. Hanford is an awful mess. ← BTW, that is my professional assessment.

          I have never been concerned by my exposure because I know how to not get exposed.

up
0 users have voted.

@PriceRip One of her relatives used to work at the site and another friend used to also. After Rump was elected, I allow myself to fantasize at times about buying a house with land and since my friend is over there I considered it. But after reading what I recently have about Hanford, I'm no longer using that fantasy. If that thing blows up one day, any land around it would have to be quarantined and I imagine you'd lose whatever property you have. And with the fact that its as bad as it currently is, and with additional funding cuts, its pretty scary.

up
0 users have voted.

Only a fool lets someone else tell him who his enemy is. Assata Shakur

PriceRip's picture

@lizzyh7

          I grew up down stream of the Hanford Site. After going through my educational phase and getting a teaching a position here in Nebraska I met a biologist that did his graduate field study in the Horse Heaven Hills. He found radioactivity all over the place. On site plants are contaminated. Animals eat plants and wander. Coyotes eat these animals. Then the coyotes leave radioactive deposits as they wander great distances.

          Record keeping was sloppy at best. Most of the old deteriorating storage tanks contain an unknown mixture of chemicals. From time to time the contents a container will "turn over" and "belch out" gas of uncertain composition. I will never live down stream of that place again. And, I have no intention of living down wind of it as well. The place could be cleaned up. The process is as straight forward as it is expensive. But as there is no "profit" in doing the right thing, we all know what TPTB have planned.


Head In Sand
Photo by Sander van der Wel

up
0 users have voted.

@PriceRip Counterpunch I believe. One I won't send to my friend. She's trapped there for a while due to being on SSDI and her daughter is 10. She's got more than enough to worry about and they are "downwinders."

One of my early arguments with my mother was over Hanford. She worked for Bechtel Power, building nukes all over the world. She bitched about how unfair the NRC was and how much quicker plants went up in Riyadh. I'd read about Hanford somewhere and starting asking her why she thought nuclear power was sustainable on what's essentially a finite planet? Where to put that pesky waste? I think this was about the time that Diablo Canyon was going to be nuclear in Cally, the one on or very near the San Andreas fault line. As usual, she just ignored that and went on her merry way. I don't think that one went nuke though, read that somewhere not long ago.

up
0 users have voted.

Only a fool lets someone else tell him who his enemy is. Assata Shakur

PriceRip's picture

@lizzyh7

          If we had a lot of Admiral Rickover clones I would have no problem with Nuclear Reactors, but as soon as Profit Motive and laissez-faire Capitalism come into play I am out of here.

          The only real problem with Nuclear Reactors is the enormous amount of tailings and the fact that the air (Radon Daughters) in the mines will kill you. But that is also an issue for coal mines, so as always I suppose we should try to force people to accept Photovoltaic and Wind Turbine energy sources. Oh, wait, we the people are already going that way ...

up
0 users have voted.

me or me to even know what else to say. I'm sorry.

up
0 users have voted.

Bet there are stories very similar to this one all over. In the olden days, one could claim ignorance. Today, there is no reason, but it goes on. Well written. Beautiful pictures of what should be nature's glory.

up
0 users have voted.

"Religion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich."--Napoleon

gulfgal98's picture

Your photographs showed how beautiful a place it was. The town in western NC when I spend a lot of time was home to logging and a tannery in the first half of the 20th century. The tannery had dirt floors and all the toxic chemicals were just dumped on the site. There are still brown fields here but with the die off of the tannery business, we ended up being a much cleaner and safer place for people to raise their children.

I hope that you are not now nor will not suffer ill effects in the future from your exposure to the vermiculite tailings.

up
0 users have voted.

Do I hear the sound of guillotines being constructed?

“Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable." ~ President John F. Kennedy

@gulfgal98
I managed to avoid any health effects from this, and have stayed healthy most of my life.

The area is still beautiful. You'd never know about the poison from looking around.

up
0 users have voted.
gulfgal98's picture

@gjohnsit makes me smile. Smile

up
0 users have voted.

Do I hear the sound of guillotines being constructed?

“Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable." ~ President John F. Kennedy

studentofearth's picture

Steven Hawkins thinks our species should simply run away from humanities problems. It would be easier than fixing our self destructive tendencies of self imposed ignorance and standing up to human bullies.

updated - should have added the snark tag.

up
0 users have voted.

Still yourself, deep water can absorb many disturbances with minimal reaction.
--When the opening appears release yourself.

dervish's picture

@studentofearth as we've ever been. We don't even have the physics for it, let alone the engineering. We'll either live or die on this rock, for now, anyhow.

up
0 users have voted.

"Obama promised transparency, but Assange is the one who brought it."

PriceRip's picture

@dervish

          ... throwing a cold splash of reality into the conversation.

          I love Steven Hawkins but sometimes he gets a bit silly and most are not comfortable disabusing him of his fanciful musings. Lately he has been carrying on about artificial intelligence with the same reckless abandon. But, on the other hand, unrestrained thought usually stimulates the creative spark needed to do the job right.

up
0 users have voted.
dervish's picture

@PriceRip reality following fantasy, if that's what it takes. I remember well the flip cell-phones, and where I'd seen them first. Now warp drive, that's an issue...

up
0 users have voted.

"Obama promised transparency, but Assange is the one who brought it."

@studentofearth

The "winning applicants" from his call for volunteers are now training for their one-way trip to Mars where they will spend the rest of their lives in a hamster cage.

up
0 users have voted.

Beware the bullshit factories.

I was a freelance book indexer back in 2004 when one of my assignments was to index the Pulitzer Prize-winning book, "An Air That Kills" by Schneider and McCumber (authors). The book details with sickening precision how toxic vermiculite has poisoned the entire town of Libby, Montana. The stuff was even donated to use in building school playgrounds by W.R. Grace, despite them knowing full well that it caused cancer. It was used in insulation panels inside the World Trade Center and though it's never been investigated, I believe it was the cause of the cancer that struck down so many first responders. An ongoing tragedy of epic proportions.

up
0 users have voted.
k9disc's picture

was one of the things that really kicked my anti-authoritarianism into high gear.

up
0 users have voted.

“Tactics without strategy is the noise before defeat.” ~ Sun Tzu

NCTim's picture

I have seen the no big deal attitude. I grew up near Pittsburgh. The air and water were overwhelmed by industrial pollution. People were willing to look the other way for the higher paying jobs. Union and blue collar workers were subverted, and propagandized into allowing the industrialists to prioritize profit over people. My father's family lived in a power plant town. Coal fired power plants at either end of town and slag pile deserts. He and all but the youngest of his siblings have succumb to cancer. How ironic that The Rachel Carson Homestead was just down the street from the family home. Uncle Chuck worked at West Penn Power, the camera is pointed toward New Kensignton, Springdale is back and to the left. It looks like the photographer was on Coxcomb Hill, which is on the other side of the river.

The Duquense Light plant was on the other end of town.

That is the Allegheny River running past the power plants. There were fish, and an advisory not to eat them. They contained high levels of heavy metals. I still remember the fly ash. So tell me again about regulations being job killers.

up
0 users have voted.

The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe. If you try it, you will be lonely often, and sometimes frightened. But no price is too high to pay for the privilege of owning yourself. - Friedrich Nietzsche -

NCTim's picture

My spouse, of 33 years, passed 1/31/17. She too grew up in western PA and succumbed to ALS. ALS has a relatively low incidence rate, making it difficult to research. The ALS Foundation managed to get NIH funding for a database. The ALS Assocuation and ALS clinics encourage patients to join the database. It takes a computer literate person about four hours to complete their history. Recently, the database has yielded a statistically significant higher incident rate around bodies of water with heavy industry and big agriculture. Translation, heavy metals and pesticides. In case you didn't know, many pesticides are nuero-toxins, be extremely careful, wear a mask. Tell me again about regulations effecting your profits.

up
0 users have voted.

The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe. If you try it, you will be lonely often, and sometimes frightened. But no price is too high to pay for the privilege of owning yourself. - Friedrich Nietzsche -

PriceRip's picture

@NCTim

          You have my condolences.

          Profits trump People ... every day ... every way.

up
0 users have voted.
NCTim's picture

The elementary school I attended, Bon Air, was condemned and demolished due to flocked asbestos insulation. Ironic name?

up
0 users have voted.

The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe. If you try it, you will be lonely often, and sometimes frightened. But no price is too high to pay for the privilege of owning yourself. - Friedrich Nietzsche -

PriceRip's picture

@NCTim

          ... were later equipped with positive pressure systems supplied with filtered air. There was a risk that the up-wind storage structures at the Umatilla Army Depot might leak.


UmatillaArmyDepot.jpg
Umatilla Army Depot

          Hanford is North of Hermiston. I sat at the crosshairs for twenty years.

up
0 users have voted.
PriceRip's picture

See @NCTim and @PriceRip

EPA website

up
0 users have voted.
NCTim's picture

@PriceRip Early 1950s. He said they were told not to eat the local produce. How about them apples?

up
0 users have voted.

The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe. If you try it, you will be lonely often, and sometimes frightened. But no price is too high to pay for the privilege of owning yourself. - Friedrich Nietzsche -

PriceRip's picture

@NCTim

          I wonder how far that "local" designation applies. As you (maybe) know produce, particularly apples, are shipped from orchards East of the Tri-Cities to ... well everywhere. We would truck Hermiston watermelons throughout Washington as well as into Northern California. Oh, and I shouldn't forget to mention the Ore-Ida potatoes that get shipped everywhere.

          So, the solution to radioactive contamination is to ship it out as food. Cynical, me?, maybe not so much. The solution to pollution is dilution.

up
0 users have voted.
NCTim's picture

@PriceRip I said apples, because I was awe stuck by Yakima.

up
0 users have voted.

The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe. If you try it, you will be lonely often, and sometimes frightened. But no price is too high to pay for the privilege of owning yourself. - Friedrich Nietzsche -