Football, Violence and Politics

Somewhere between the F-16 patrols, the attack chopper flyover, the armed forces chorus singing the Star Spangled Banner, and the call from the Commander in Chief after the Super Bowl ends, we will hear plenty of banter concerning "field generals", "aerial attacks" and "blitzes" among other things.
It's almost enough to make one wonder where the military ends and the football game starts.

That's not a coincidence. Politics and sports has always been closely aligned. In fact, there are times in history when the two are inseparable.

Most Americans are aware of the American-boycotted 1980 Olympics and Soviet-boycotted 1984 Olympics, and how the world banned South Africa from sporting events during Apartheid.
  The older generation could tell you about Nixon's Ping Pong Diplomacy and the Black Power salute by Tommie Smith and John Carlos at the 1968 Olympics.

 Perhaps you've read in history books how FDR told Joe Louis, "Joe, we need muscles like yours to beat Germany," after Max Schmeling had promised to donate his prize money to build German tanks.

  However, all these examples are about symbols. What I want to talk about is when sporting events stop being just symbols.

  A good example of this is the Football War between El Salvador and Honduras in 1969.
   The real cause of the war involved the 300,000 impoverished Salvadorians living as immigrant farmers in Honduras, and the United Fruit Company's plan to dispossess those peasants of their lands.
   Nevertheless, the flash point of this war was the 1970 FIFA World Cup semi-final qualification round. There was already fighting between the fans when Honduras won 1-0 in Tegucigalpa on 8 June 1969. The violence was even worse in San Salvador when El Salvador won the second game 3-0.

   The final match in Mexico City on 26 June 1969 ended with El Salvador winning 3-2 in extra time to advance to the finals against Haiti. The same day El Salvador cut diplomatic ties with Honduras and accused their government of "crimes which constitute genocide".
   Sporadic violence soon broke out on the common border. On 14 July 1969, the El Salvador military invaded Honduras. Thus beginning a four day war that would kill over 3,000 people.
   El Salvador, despite having more military success, gained nothing from this war. The hundreds of thousands of displaced civilians would eventually destabilize the democracy and lead to their devastating civil war.

  Football being a flashpoint to war is not as unusual as one might think. Just 21 years later in Zagreb, Croatia, a football riot is considered the first step towards the bloody Croatian War of Independence.
   Interestingly, the two combatents at this riot were the Bad Blue Boys (fans of Dinamo Zagreb) and the Delije (fans of Red Star Belgrade). Red versus Blue. Each color representing a political faction.
   The reason I find that interesting is because it sounds just like the ultimate historical example of sports, politics, and violence fusing into one indivisible unit of destruction.

  I am referring to the Nika Riots.

Byzantium sports

 Constantinople entered 532 AD with Emperor Justinian in his fifth year of rule. To pay for his ambitious dreams of restoring the Roman Empire, Justinian frequently went beyond just heavy taxes and engaged in outright theft. This included not just the wealthy, but even bonuses for the military after campaigns.
   This made him very unpopular.

 Like Rome of a few centuries earlier, the public was kept distracted by dangerous sporting games in a huge arena - the Hippodrome. This enormous stadium could hold 100,000 spectators.
  The most popular sporting event at time was chariot races.

 Chariot races was not an individual sport. They usually required financial backers who often competed for the most skilled drivers, much like NASCAR today. Chariot races were extremely dangerous, particularily on the turns, and often what made a successful racer was simply surviving the race.

   Constantinople continued the Roman legacy of team colors. In roman tradition, the Reds were aligned with Mars, the Whites to the Zephyrs, the Greens to Mother Earth, and the Blues to sky and sea. By Byzantium times, the colors became associated with religious factions as well as political ones.
   Wearing a team's colors became an important part of Byzantium fashion, much like today. Betting on races was extremely popular.

  Fans would chant "Nika!" after their team won. It translates to something like "Victory!" or "Conquer!".

  Byzantium had two subtle, but important changes, from roman chariot race traditions. First of all, cheating became more obvious (Justinian legal code only outlawed places curses on opponents). Secondly, racers were given public funding, thus putting them under imperial control. The Emperor himself belonged to one of the teams. In Justinian's case, he was a member of the Blue team.
   His palace was directly alongside the Hippodrome, and like Roman tradition, the races were often the only place were citizens could see and address the Emperor.

  By the time of Justian's rule, the two dominant teams were the Blues and the Greens. Much like English soccer thugs of today, the fans of these two teams would violently clash in the streets. Murders were not unusual. More than one riot had begun at the Hippodrome before the Nika Riots.

   Late in 531 AD there was a riot after a chariot race in which several people were killed. Everyone involved was sentenced to death. However, two men managed to escape on January 10, 532 AD. One fan of the Green team, and one fan of the Blue team. They sought sanctuary in a church.
   The fans of the teams demanded the unpopular Emperor give the two men pardons. Justinian refused.

Nika!

  On January 13, 532, the Hippodrome was packed with angry spectators.
As the races were run, fans of both teams appealed for mercy for the two men from the Emperor. Near the end of the day, at race 22 (of 24), the partisan chants of "Nika!" changed to a unified chant directed at the Emperor.
   When Justinian fled to the palace, the fans erupted into a riot. But instead of turning on one another, they unified against the Emperor.

  They first attacked the local jail (the Praetorium) and freed the prisoners before setting it on fire. After that the riot got completely out of control. Other fires were soon set.

   It is unclear exactly when the aristocracy and some senators decided that now was a good time to get rid of the unpopular Emperor, but it was soon after the riot started.
   They first demanded the resignations of three unpopular ministers, including the chief tax collector. The Emperor agreed, but the rioting continued.
   More fires were set and spread. The rioters by this time were now armed, probably by the senators. The small number of Thracian troops in the city were unable to stop the rioting.
   By the end of the rioting, nearly half of the city had burned to the ground.

  Justinian, afraid of treachery in the palace, expelled his brother Pompeius and his two nephews, including cousin Hypatius. Now in the hands of the mob, they selected Hypatius as their new emperor.
   This was not a title that Hypatius sought, but was now something he accepted.

   At this point Justinian was in despair and prepared to leave the city.
Then two things happened that changed everything.

Moment of Truth

  Justinian was literally on the dock, ready to board a boat and go forever into exile, when his wife, Empress Theodora, gave a historic speech.

 "My opinion then is that the present time, above all others, is inopportune for flight, even though it bring safety. For while it is impossible for a man who has seen the light not also to die, for one who has been an emperor it is unendurable to be a fugitive. May I never be separated from this purple, and may I not live that day on which those who meet me shall not address me as mistress."

 She went on to quote an ancient saying, "Purple makes a fine winding sheet [burial shroud]." She then marched back towards the palace without waiting for her husband's reaction.
   Shamed by his wife's words, Justinian followed her.

  Empress Theodora was a most interesting historical figure. She was born a commoner and made her way in life as an acrobat and actress. Justinian changed the laws so that he could marry her, and she ruled as de facto co-regent of the Empire.
   No other woman in Byzantium history possessed more power and influence.

  The other significant event that happened that night was the return of General Flavius Belisarius from the Sassanid front. Belisarius was the best general in Byzantium history.

 With these two pillars of support, Justinian rallied his courage and devised a new plan.

Slaughter

  Justinian announced new games at the Hippodrome on January 18, and made false noises about concessions to the mob. The coronation of Hypatius was supposed to happen during the games. Tens of thousands turned out for what they thought would be a celebration.
   After the games began, Narses, a trusted eunuch, entered the stadium carrying a bag of gold. He was unarmed and unescorted, surrounded by a mob that had already killed hundreds.
   He went directly to the Blue section and approached the most important of the aristocracy. He first reminded them that Hypatius was a Green, and thus was a rival. He then distributed the gold that Justinian had given him.

  The Blue aristocracy took the bribe and left the stadium. Choas began erupting as the shaky alliance between the Green and Blue began to crumble.
  At this point General Belisarius arrived with his troops and sealed off all the exits. Justinian's orders were clear and unmistakable - no one was to leave alive.

  At least 30,000 Byzantium citizens were slaughtered that day. Hypatius was captured and executed.

Afterward

  All games at the Hippodrome were suspended for five years. Chariot races were never as popular again.
  Every suspected political rival of Justinian was either killed or exiled and their estates were seized.

  The Nika Riots turned out to be very advantagous to Justinian. Without any political rivals, he was able to run the Empire exactly the way he wanted to.
   This included the rebuilding of Constantinople, and the expensive reconquest of most of the old Roman Empire.

  In the end, Justinian's rule brought death, destruction and disease thoughout most of the Mediterranean region. Justinian's conquests nearly bankrupted the Byzantium Empire, and the lands were too far flung to hold.

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

up
0 users have voted.
Azazello's picture

drop your greens and blues.
Thanks for the reminder, I had read about this in Gibbon but forgotten the details.
The violence and popularity of football say a lot about the culture of an empire in decline.

up
0 users have voted.

We wanted decent healthcare, a living wage and free college.
The Democrats gave us Biden and war instead.

Wink's picture

tackle football by 7th or 8th grade becuz they discover girls (and want to keep their front teeth and body parts intact). But is a great game to watch on tv. What blows is the militarization of sporting events - from the star spangled banner to F-16 flyovers.

up
0 users have voted.

the little things you can do are more valuable than the giant things you can't! - @thanatokephaloides. On Twitter @wink1radio. (-2.1) All about building progressive media.

Real football gave the idea how to launder money and own people in modern times. Legal.
http://www.sportskeeda.com/football/pablo-escobar-and-the-rise-of-narco-football-in-colombia

Francisco Maturana, then coach of Atletico spoke of how Pablo’s money helped in their rise to one of the top clubs on the continent, “The introduction of drug money in soccer allowed us to bring in great foreign players and keep our best players from leaving.”

However, Escobar wasn’t the only drug trafficker who was awash with cash and needed a means to legalise it; and he wasn’t the only one with a deep love for Colombian soccer.

This marked the beginning of what came to be popularly known as “narco-soccer.”

The fallout from their poor showing on the international stage was immediate and devastating. Barrabas Gomez, the brother of assistant coach Hernan, left the squad after death threats had demanded he didn’t play. The national team captain and Pablo’s namesake, Andres Escobar, popularly nicknamed “the gentleman of football,” and a role-model to thousands of young footballers, was confronted by three men and shot six times for his own-goal that led to their elimination from the World Cup; he succumbed to his wounds a few hours later.
If South America feels too distant, look no further than Europe and the corruption scandal that rocked FIFA and UEFA; which saw UEFA President and FIFA President Michel Platini and Sepp Blatter banned from the game for six years.

corrupt

up
0 users have voted.

After the first time you even hear about Buskashim (an Afghani sport), you realize that most of our so-called "sports" are actually just dumb games. I had a friend that once watched Buskashim played old-school, between two villages over the horizon from each other. The villages were the goals, and only guns or swords were considered unsportsmanlike. Punching, trampling, "fighting your horse", horse-whips, boot-heels and small knives were apparently OK. This friend had grown up in the saddle, in Wyoming, and said he had never before or since seen such displays of horsemanship. The match lasted most of the day. The "ball" is a decapitated goat's carcass. So, yeah, next to all-day, lightly-armed, dead-goat extreme polo with no penalties, pushing a half-pound football around for a few hours with frequent breaks seems not so impressive.

Can't prove it, but I suspect that Buskashim has something to do with why Afghanistan is the Graveyard of Empires. Once the invader figures out that their own cherished "sports" are by comparison more like effete, toothless rituals, it's all over.

up
0 users have voted.

"Capitalism is the extraordinary belief that the nastiest of men for the nastiest of motives will somehow work for the benefit of all."
- John Maynard Keynes

always has been there

Many critics of these protests asserted that sports and politics simply don't mix. But that's wrongheaded. As research I recently conducted with my colleague Emily Thorson shows, sports fandom does indeed correlate with political attitudes. And one issue that has dominated American politics in the 21st century is especially intertwined with sports culture: economic inequality.

No other form of pop escapism so consistently embeds a narrative that explains achievement in terms of meritocracy. Winners succeed, sports tell us, because they work hard. Rare is the exultant athlete, hoisting the trophy at the victors' podium, who makes reference to the team's free-agency binge in the offseason that helped them buy the championship. Rare is the sportswriter who can resist the heartwarming tale of a superstar born into poverty, hustling his or her way out of the hood. Rare is the fan who doesn't swoon for the underdog upsetting a heavy favorite by dint of sheer effort.
...
By offering tidy metaphors for meritocracy, sports also implicitly tell us tales about why economic inequality might persist. As such, we could benefit from more athletes engaging in political consciousness, and not merely limited to issues of racial injustice.

Players might embrace a posture of humility that acknowledges luck -- luck of genetics, luck of gameplay -- as much as effort determined their fate.

up
0 users have voted.

A Phalanx of Alexander the Great would quickly understand American football. Both were about advancing ground troops with hand weapons.

True Story: I once had a manager -a Ring Knocker from Albany- who actually cried when Navy beat Army on the gridiron. I said, "It's only a game". He retorted, "You don't understand."

I understand all too well, Captain. You don't own your mental faculties, which is why you were such a lousy manager. You were programmed to follow orders, not give them. And, as a Tax Payer First Class, I outrank you all.

up
0 users have voted.

Vowing To Oppose Everything Trump Attempts.