GLAAD: too few transgender characters on TV

GLAAD has released its yearly report analyzing the quantity and quality of LGBT character portrayals on television. Where We Are on TV 2015 found that of the 881 regular characters on broadcast primetime programming in the coming year, 35 are identified as LGB. That's 4%. Not one of the regular or recurring characters is transgender.

I guess that means we are not to expect Mrs. Hudson to pop up on Elementary this season.

The number of regular LGBT characters counted on cable increased from 64 to 84, while recurring characters increased from 41 to 58.

Now I know that you are wanting to shout about the award winning series Orange is the New Black and Transparent, but they fall into the new category.

For the first time, GLAAD counted LGBT characters on original series that premiered on Amazon, Hulu, and Netflix. GLAAD found 43 series regulars and 16 recurring LGBT characters across 23 series.

There are no transgender characters counted on primetime broadcast programming, while only three recurring trans characters were counted on cable (2%). Streaming series boast the highest percentage of trans characters at 7% (4) with two notably being series leads (Maura on Transparent and Nomi on Sense8). Of the seven trans characters counted, only one was a transgender man.

The expansion of the television landscape into digital platforms is helping to spark needed changes, as content creators like Netflix and Amazon are making their mark with groundbreaking series like Sense8 and Transparent.

--GLAAD CEO Sarah Kate Ellis

Racial diversity among the LGBT characters is lacking: 71% of the LGBT characters on cable and 73% of the LGBT characters on streaming services are white.

Out of the 881 regular characters counted on primetime broadcast shows, 287 of them are people of color — a six-point increase from last year.

The critical and commercial success of series like Empire, Transparent and Orange Is the New Black can serve as an example to network executives that audiences are looking for stories they haven’t seen before.

There are still plenty of stories about our community yet to be told. LGBT people of color have remained underrepresented for years, and transgender men have been all but invisible in the media.

--Ellis

The report specifically praises Empire as "one of the most inclusive programs on broadcast television"...including the portrayal of a gay musician and a bisexual singer.

Bisexual representations shot up on both broadcast and cable this year, where the latter saw an increase from 10 to 18 bisexual men in its programming. However, the study argues that depictions of such characters tend to reinforce stereotypes associated with bisexual individuals (i.e. that they are untrustworthy, prone to infidelity, use sex as a means of manipulation or lack a sense of morality).

Orange is the New Black has more LGBT characters than any other show.

The number of Americans who personally know someone who is transgender has gone up, but an overwhelming majority (84%) of Americans learn about trans people through what they see in the media. It is imperative then that creators not only include trans characters, but also improve that representation by telling a wider variety of stories and empowering trans people to tell their own stories.

One way to do this is to introduce more transgender characters who are defined by more than just being transgender. A good example is Nomi on the Netflix series Sense8 who has the same type of dramatic storylines as other characters and is living her life beyond the “transition narrative” we have seen so much of recently.

We would also like to see Hollywood eliminate the use of some harmful and outdated tropes as it begins to integrate trans stories into shows and movies. These include:

• portraying trans characters as tragic victims;

• depicting the transition process as medically dangerous;

• portraying trans people as killers, psychopaths, and villains, who are o en mentally ill;

• and portraying the majority of trans women as sex workers, especially with no context given as to why trans women may be forced into sex work including widespread employment discrimination, among other factors.

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

...don't watch television much, but most Americans get most of their cultural education through that venue.

up
0 users have voted.
cybrestrike's picture

Network television is pretty terrible when it comes to diversity, even though there are outliers like Empire and How to Get Away with Murder. But that's about it.

I did love Sense8. That was a pretty positive trans relationship, the 1st relationship of its kind that I've ever seen on television. The show treated it like a "normal" relationship--there wasn't any gimmick (besides the sci fi premise of the show). Nomi and Amanita were in love, would have done anything for each other, and it was awesome. "I will burn this building down before I let anyone touch that beautiful brain!" That was real ride-or-die sort of quote and it kicked ass. Nomi was one of my favorite characters on that show (besides Capheus, Hernando, and Wolfgang, and Sun). Glad there's a 2nd season coming.

And yes, having more of a LGBT presence on television in a realistic fashion would go a long way of eliminating preconceived biases of the so-called mainstream. Because in the end, we're all mainstream.

up
0 users have voted.
enhydra lutris's picture

up
0 users have voted.

That, in its essence, is fascism--ownership of government by an individual, by a group, or by any other controlling private power. -- Franklin D. Roosevelt --

LapsedLawyer's picture

Diversity on TV in general is pretty awful, but with regards to LGBT characters it's really bad. Even back in the day with Will & Grace, The "L" Word, and Queer as Folk there were very few LGBT characters as series regulars or with recurring roles; they seemed to be mostly confined to those shows, and the occasional Law & Order franchise appearances as witnesses or prostitutes. Even with W&G both the character Will and his friend Sean seemed to be living very chaste lives, with a lot of talk (laced with a lot of salacious innuendo) but very little actual showing of romantic relationships, still a huge problem with gay characters on TV. As for trans characters, well, you've said it all in your post.

Blog for you and everyone to check out (if you haven't already): Robot Hugs. Has the potential to be a Dykes to Watch Out For for the trans community (and note I said "potential"; right now it's just pointed fun, but that's a good thing too, imo).

up
0 users have voted.

"Our society is run by insane people for insane objectives. I think we're being run by maniacs for maniacal ends and I think I'm liable to be put away as insane for expressing that. That's what's insane about it."
-- John Lennon