Salon: The Democratic civil war is almost here

I thought this was a fascinating and well balanced piece produced by Andrew O'Hehir over at Salon Magazine.

Stop laughing, Democrats! As the GOP goes down in flames, your post-Bernie civil war is almost here

In it, the author encourages us to stop laughing at the Republican clown car and consider carefully the state of the Democratic party.

So the Republican Party has finally turned against Donald Trump, the monster it created, in an excess of self-righteous hypocrisy. It’s a classic case of what historian Ian Kershaw once described as “the sinking ship leaving the rat.” Anytime you trot out Mitt Romney to accuse someone else — literally anyone else — of being a fraud and a phony who is trying to play the American people for suckers, you have officially triggered on the Historical Irony alarm. But here’s what I have to say to gleeful Democrats, eagerly looking forward to a November massacre: Laugh, fools, laugh! Because the crazy is coming for you too. When you look in the bathroom mirror, what’s that mad glint in your eye? I know it’s hard to see, because someone has written REDRUM across the mirror in lipstick over and over again, and the writing looks familiar somehow.

I suspect many of us here already see this quite clearly. I've often been dismayed at how readily GOS laughs at the Republicans and fails to see their own party in the self-same mirror. This author takes it as a near certainty that Hillary will win the nomination although to his credit he also acknowledges that this has been a year of surprises and so being wrong is more the order of the day than an anomaly. That's a point I've never disagreed with. Bernie's (and our) battle was always a long, long shot as all David vs. Goliath contests are. And I cannot say I'm surprised by how unanimously every single organ of the establishment has worked tirelessly to stop him. Had that not happened, I'd have to be wondering what I'd gotten wrong.

Indeed, the most striking aspect of the Sanders phenomenon is that he came as close as he did, given how poorly suited he was for the role. Let me say it again: Bernie Sanders was never the solution, and Hillary Clinton, much as she has done to earn the ire and mistrust of critics on the left, was never the problem. They are both symptoms or symbols, and in the short run the outcome of their symbolic collision was not in doubt. But the long run, and the collision between the forces behind Clinton and Sanders — that’s an entirely different matter.

The challenge he lays before us (the left) is whether we have what it takes to make the revolution happen... to elect county clerks and dog catchers and other Berniecrats starting at the bottom and working at every single level... to do what the Tea Party did in short. If we don't, if it all depends on Bernie in his own person, then we never had a chance.

ActBlue for Berniecrats

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

jiordan's picture

And yeah, it's spot on. I was glad to see it because I thought no one (besides the Bernie supporters) thought there was a civil war brewing on this side of the aisle.

up
0 users have voted.
vtcc73's picture

Well reasoned and written IMHO. Drop this in DK and I bet the comments will be dismiss it as just another PUMA revolt sure to fizzle. The big difference is that this is the Dem base instead of the DLC wing and how many newly energized young and, until Bernie, disaffected voters. How many of those step back from politics and voting? Are we to be left with an extremely low voter turnout election of people who hate the other side's candidate enough to get out and vote against him/her? Isn't that the more immediate issue than whether the Democratic party goes to war with itself? A war will play out over many years while a President Trump, or Cruz, or Rubio (HAHAHAHAHA), will be right up in our faces in January.

The longer view question is how to turn this into a progressive movement. I'm afraid disappointment and inertia will replace the Bern. So does the DNC and RNC too, I think.

up
0 users have voted.

"Ah, but I was so much older then, I'm younger than that now..."

SnappleBC's picture

I can only speak for myself, of course, but I am not motivated by fear.... particularly not short-term fear. I no longer choose to be controlled that way. Nor do I accept responsibility for a Trump presidency if that's how it works out. I lay that at the feet of people who voted for Trump. I accept responsibility for my vote and my vote only. I will cast an affirmative vote this November. Ideally that vote would be for Bernie. Failing that, it'll be for Jill Stein. Should either of those two candidates win then I accept responsibility for what they do in office.

Whether the "PUMA revolt" fizzles or not is not my problem. My problem is choosing the best person to sit in the POTUS seat. I do think, however, that when poll after poll shows something like 14% of Democrats and huge percentages of independents won't vote for Hillary that there's a certain element of whistling past the graveyard involved in thinking it'll all be OK.

Insofar as the longer view, my current hope is that this site becomes the site for the populist movement. It needs a lot of work to serve in that capacity but hopefully enough web developers will offer services (I do design by the way) and people will donate to make it work in that capacity. The populist movement needs an identity and a cohesion outside of an individual candidate or the Democratic party. I can tell you that I personally will be disappointed if Bernie doesn't win but I won't be surprised and it won't be the end of the road for me. If nothing else, Bernie has demonstrated quite clearly that my populist sentiments are far from alone.

up
0 users have voted.

A lot of wanderers in the U.S. political desert recognize that all the duopoly has to offer is a choice of mirages. Come, let us trudge towards empty expanse of sand #1, littered with the bleached bones of Deaniacs and Hope and Changers.
-- lotlizard

The Dems are only one or two election cycles behind the GOP.

up
0 users have voted.
Jazzenterprises's picture

Great post, thanks for sharing.

up
0 users have voted.

Progressive to the bone.

Democratic civil war may be too late. The effects of climate change are accelerating almost daily at this point. We need to fight the corruption now, so that we can do something about climate change and inequality. I am pessimistic

up
0 users have voted.
SnappleBC's picture

A long, long time ago when I had fucked up rather completely in my early 20's a wise older guy took me to the sea shore. He asked me to take a look at what I saw. I was baffled but answered... "A big ocean with a lot of waves rolling in."

He said to me, "Right. And you know what? Those waves are going to keep rolling in tomorrow and the next day no matter how completely you think you are a failure. Time will continue and tomorrow will happen. Rather than abandon hope, why not look to making a better tomorrow."

That advice was 30 some odd years ago and I still cling to it.

up
0 users have voted.

A lot of wanderers in the U.S. political desert recognize that all the duopoly has to offer is a choice of mirages. Come, let us trudge towards empty expanse of sand #1, littered with the bleached bones of Deaniacs and Hope and Changers.
-- lotlizard

In comments everywhere I go, I see comments from people that there is no way in hell they will vote for her. They are making it known and will vote so it can't be written off to voter apathy. If the number show the revolt and Trump wins, then what? To me, it is just the first shot across the bow. I think we need to make them lose everywhere we can. If we can't hurt them, they have no reason to care what we do.

up
0 users have voted.

"Religion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich."--Napoleon