Massive Protests against Narendra Modi’s fascist Hindu Supremacist Law

CAA protests in Nalbari, Dec. 20

I’ve been thinking of analogies such as Kristallnacht, then after more days of protests and police actions: pogroms.  At this point, it’s become impossible for me not to write up, as grotesque as it is.  Will the DoJ and Congress sanction the hell out of him and his  government, and revoke Genocidaire Modi his American Visa as the GW Bush did?  And make it permanent?  Ah, but Obomba had let him in again with great fanfare and approbation, hadn’t he?  Because: the market of 3.8 billion people for Silicon Valley?  And DT loves him!  BFFs with virtually conjoined hearts!

It began:  ‘India adopts Hindu supremacist citizenship law’, Rohantha De Silva and Keith Jones, 13 December 2019,

“In the face of widespread popular opposition and warnings that India is rending its “secular” political-constitutional order, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government have rammed through legislation that effectively redefines Indian citizenship in Hindu supremacist terms.

Tabled in the lower house of India’s bicameral parliament only on Monday, the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill, 2019 or CAB was given presidential assent last night.

Passage of the CAB sets the stage for the BJP to proceed with its plans to draw up a National Register of Citizens (NRC), under which all of India’s more than 1.3 billion residents will have to prove, to the authorities’ satisfaction, that they are Indian citizens. Those unable to do so will be declared stateless and subject to detention and expulsion.

The NRC’s ostensible purpose is to identify “illegal immigrants.” In truth—and the CAB makes this manifestly evident—the aim of the NRC will be to harass, intimidate, and victimize India’s Muslim minority.

Adding insult to injury, the BJP is cynically trying to dress up the CAB, to use Modi’s words, as an act of “compassion and brotherhood.”

The CAB [now the CAA, Citizen Amendment Act] grants Indian citizenship to non-Muslims from Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan who entered India prior to 2015, on the grounds that Hindus, Sikhs, Jains, Buddhists, and Christians in those countries have been subject to religious persecution.

Conspicuously left off the list are members of minority Muslims groups, such as Pakistan’s Ahmadiyas or Afghanistan’s Shia Hazaras, who are victims of state discrimination and/or communal violence. Also, notably absent are the Rohingya, more than one million of whom had to flee Myanmar (Burma), which borders India to the east, in late 2016. Claiming the Rohingya are a “security threat,” the BJP government has held those that fled into India in detention camps and is deporting them to Myanmar.

When coupled with the CAB, the NRC’s essentially fascistic anti-Muslim purpose becomes clear.

Taken together the CAB and NRC effectively reduce India’s 200 million Muslims to second-class citizens.” [long snip, although I’d say ‘third-or fourth class, depending on caste...]

“In according preferential treatment to non-Muslims from select neighbouring states, while setting up a process whereby only Muslims must establish their Indian citizenship, the BJP government has gone a long way to realizing the Hindu right’s longstanding goals of asserting Hindu dominance and making religion and not territoriality the criteria of citizenship.

The inclusion of Christians who migrated or fled to India from Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Afghanistan among those to be accorded citizenship under the CAB is a ruse. It is meant to camouflage the legislation’s Hindu supremacist motivation, no doubt with an eye to currying favor with the White House and the US Christian right.”

‘Protests across India against new Hindu chauvinist Citizenship Act’, Rohantha De Silva, 16 December 2019,

“On Friday and again on Sunday, the thousands who took to the streets of Delhi to protest against the CAA were set upon by police with lathis (batons) and tear gas. Violence erupted in south Delhi yesterday, when police blocked demonstrators’ path. Police subsequently invaded the campus of Jamia Millia Islamia University (JMI), without permission, and, according to University Chief Proctor Waseem Ahmed Khan, beat up students and staff members. More than fifty protesters had to be treated, some for severe injuries, at a nearby hospital.

Delhi authorities have ordered all schools in southeast Delhi closed today. Earlier, in an attempt to defuse the situation and no doubt to curry favour with the government, the JMI administration had postponed end-of-term exams and ordered the university closed until early January.

Police also invaded the campus of Aligarh Muslim University in Aligarh, Utter Pradesh, Sunday evening after using tear gas, water cannon and rubber bullets to disperse protesters. At least sixty students were injured. Early Friday, in response to an announcement from the Aligarh Muslim University student union that it would hold an anti-CAA protest, district authorities had shut down internet service and placed Aligarh under Section 144 of the Criminal Code, thereby criminalizing any gathering of more than four people.

There have also been large protests in Gaya and Patna, the two largest cities in the eastern Indian state of Bihar. The JD (U), which leads the Bihar state government and is a close ally of the BJP, supported passage of the CAA. But in the face of a public outcry, it is now claiming to oppose extending the NRC to Bihar.

In West Bengal, which has a large Muslim minority, there have been violent protests, expressing popular outrage over the latest BJP provocation. On Saturday, protesters blocked motorways and attacked several trains and train stations. The authorities have suspended internet services in parts or all of five districts: Howrah, which lies on the outskirts of Kolkata, Malda, Murshidabad, North 24 Parganas, and parts of South 24 Parganas.” [snip]

“The Indian bourgeoisie rallied behind the BJP after the Indian economy faltered at the beginning of the decade, making the BJP under Modi its premier national party, with a share of power in a majority of states as well as control of the national government and presidency. Whilst some sections now wring their hands over the BJP’s implementation of its longstanding Hindutva program, fearing Modi may soon reap a whirlwind, big business still clings to the Hindu “strongman,” calculating that he is the best bet to assert its predatory interests on the world stage and push through social incendiary pro-investor “reforms.”

From Arundhati Roy on Dec. 19: “Three years ago we stood in line obediently outside banks as demonetization was imposed on us, a policy that broke the back of our country’s economy. Now the National Register of Citizens coupled with the Citizenship Amendment Bill is set to break the back of our Constitution and cut the ground from under our feet,” the Booker Prize winning author said in a statement issued through Haymarket Books.

“Are we going to stand in line once again, obediently, and comply with this policy that eerily resembles the 1935 Nuremberg Laws of the Third Reich? If we do, India will cease to exist. We are faced with the biggest challenge since Independence. Stand up. Please. Stand up,” she added.”

And at a protest:

‘India’s Government is Going to War Against Its Own People’, Vijay Prashad, Dec. 20, 2019,

“On December 13, the United Nations high commissioner for human rights released a powerful statement that criticized India’s new citizenship law. This “fundamentally discriminatory” Citizenship (Amendment) Act of 2019 would expedite citizenship for persecuted religious minorities from India’s neighboring countries. But in the list of those minorities, it names only Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, Parsis, and Christians. It does not name Muslims, despite the fact that there have been several important cases of Muslims being persecuted in Pakistan (the Ahmadis), in Afghanistan (the Hazaras), and in Myanmar (the Rohingyas). The UN said that not only does this law violate India’s obligations to conventions, treaties, and compacts that it has signed at the global level, but also that it is in violation of its own Constitution.” [snip]

“The BJP government was particularly ruthless against protests at two major universities—Jamia Millia Islamia (New Delhi) and Aligarh Muslim University (Aligarh), both historically Muslim universities. The police have been extraordinarily violent against student protests in the past several months, but this was at another level. At Jamia, the police beat unarmed students, chased them into their dormitories and continued to beat them, and fired tear gas into the library. There is video evidence of policemen burning buses, assaulting journalists, and creating the conditions of a full-scale police-driven riot; in Aligarh, there is video evidence of the police breaking student motorcycles.” [snip]

“As if on cue, the BJP government hastily shut down internet access in India’s northeast, and in parts of the country where the protests have been most virulent. Last year, India led all other countries in internet shutdowns. Overall, 67 percent of all shutdowns of the internet took place in India; this year, already, 63 percent of all shutdowns have been in India. Internet in Jammu and Kashmir has now been off for 136 days (between August 4 and December 17); there is no sign that it will be restored. Indeed, the suffocation of Jammu and Kashmir continues unabated. The Kashmir Chamber of Commerce says that Kashmiri businesses have lost over $1.4 billion in this period.”

Prashad then writes of the IMF’s chief economist having visited Inia this week, saying she was shocked, I tell you…shocked…that Modi’s economy was tanking, and the IMF is urging ‘structural austerity reforms’ which he notes actually means: fuck the workers, erase any remaining restraints on business, please the Investor Class.

“Farmer, peasant, and trade union organizations have been consistently on the march against the government’s various economic policies. In the past five months, the price of onions—a good indicator of food inflation—spiked by 253 percent. Rather than fix the endemic internal problems in the domestic onion market, a demand of the farmer and peasant organizations, the BJP government has loosened rules for the import of onions, a demand of the big traders. BJP policy is not made to benefit the working class and peasantry. It is made on behalf of the big businesses. It is almost as if the BJP-IMF slogan is “Save the Billionaires,” or “Billionaires Bachao,” as Srujana Bodapati, the coordinator of the Delhi office of Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research, writes. Little wonder that the farmer, peasant, and trade union federations have announced a major general strike for January 8, 2020. It is expected that hundreds of millions of workers and peasants will be on the streets on that day. Their charter of demands is a direct assault on the BJP-IMF austerity policies.”

You know it’s a criminal horror show when Amnesty International and the Guardian cover the massive protests.

and from the Twittersphere, including #IndiaHatesModi; it seems a lot of them see Modi as Hitler. ; )

(cross-posted from Café Babylon)

6 users have voted.


OzoneTom's picture

I am thinking more about faith/racial based instances rather than more purely class or economically-based government oppression, i.e.:
Rohingya genocide
Israeli apartheid
China Uighurs
Bolivian and Brazilian indigenous peoples

So I am not thinking so much about Hong Kong, Chile(?), France.

Probably how these are viewed have much to do with how one feels about the specific government and oppressed group. I realize my selections and how I am defining them reveal my own biases, but will admit a lack of deep knowledge about most.

2 users have voted.
wendy davis's picture


but you might also add the armenian genocide to your list. some add the tatars in ukraine, as well. as to the uigurs, i've read vastly different accounts about that, and in fact i'd just seen a a title at craig murray's site noting that his blog has always been in defense of the uigurs.

i sure can see why you'd imagine israel/palestine, as clearly israel is a stolen land as is turtle island. but you've reminded me that i'd also fist seen the similarity before i'd read much about this iteration of genocidaire modi's rapid escalation. and yes, my bias may partially be attributed to having followed his hindu fascism since he'd begun killing and disappearing muslims and protestors in kashmir/jammu provinces under the name of some arcane old law (which name i can't recall) he claimed him gave him the right to Restore Order. it began, as i recall, due to the fact that those residents had demanded he call the long-promised plebiscite of self-determination.

but then i've long covered the epic travesty of arabs and muslims in palestine as well...

OTOH, has two pieces up today claiming this reaction is all by way of an anti-modi psyop. this is one; another is quoting an imam; go figure. ; )

3 users have voted.

It only took a few days for the US media to report on this, but it still refuses to mention Israel's proclaiming itself an apartheid state. Bias anyone?
Any bets on how long before Tulsi's "support" for Modi is mentioned every time her name is brought up on every channel except maybe Fox?

5 users have voted.

On to Biden since 1973

wendy davis's picture


i hadn't seen any evidence the US corporate media has covered this issue at all; might you tell me which ones? but of course most western corporate media believe that the US and Israel are the best democracies on the planet, and that israel must receive billions (over five?) of our tax dollars in military aid every year.

and are you feeling a bit defensive about miz gabbard's "support" for modi?

on edit: why do you include scare quotes with "support"? has she said anything on twitter about this travesty? i remember tle noting that with her 'present' vote for impeachment, that she could have also stood and said on what grounds she'd thought he should have been impeached.

2 users have voted.

@wendy davis I really wanted to like her but she turned out to be a one-woman non-stop circus.

Modi, on the other hand, is pure evil. Evil with a smile, no doubt, but evil none the less.

0 users have voted.
wendy davis's picture


but by lights she isn't what she IS called (anti-war, etc.)...on non-corporate sites across the blogosphere.

modi is pure evil to me, and i'd been tempted to put this on cass's Q: is it left of right to address the population explosion Q? (or close to that). and of course bill gates, attenborough, XR and greta have endorsed similar malthusian 'fixes'.

'NITI Aayog to Start Drafting Plan for 'Population Stabilisation; Experts believe that the “population explosion” theory is contentious as despite its 1.37 billion people, India’s birth rates have been falling', the wire india, dec. 20, 2019

"On August 15, 2015, Modi, while urging people to do “proper family planning”, had expressed concern over “population explosion” that may pose challenges for India’s future.

“A small section of society, which keeps their families small, deserves respect. What they are doing is an act of patriotism,” he had said.

Experts believe that the “population explosion” theory is contentious as despite its 1.37 billion people, India’s birth rates have been falling. Some also believe that if the government uses its people judiciously for the nation’s growth, the high population of India could also be an asset.

However, policy makers appear to be more worried about the fact that 30% of Indian citizens are young and fall in the reproductive age group. Because of this factor, the population continues to grow.

“Family planning is considered universally as the smartest development investment For India to realize its sustainable development goals and economic aspirations, it is important to ensure that people have informed access to contraception and quality family planning services,” the Aayog said, while adding that the budgetary allocation for the said goals may have to be increased." they afraid the youth will be more subversive than the elders or something?

thanks, sanchellewellyn. (what a handle!)

1 user has voted.
wendy davis's picture

Avoid rumors & know the truth’: India’s ruling party kick-starts social media campaign to calm Muslims over citizenship act’’, 23 Dec, 2019,

“Prime Minister Modi’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party has launched an awareness-raising campaign on social media to quell misperceptions about the hotly-debated citizenship act that critics say discriminates against Muslims.
The outreach effort, which started this weekend, aims to engage Indian Muslim communities by informing them about the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) and the National Register of Citizens (NRC).

Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has already made an appeal through Twitter “to our Muslim brothers and sisters to first understand the CAA itself and then explain it to others.” Responsible citizens should “avoid rumors and know the truth,” they urged.

The campaign involves easy-to-understand videos and cartoons that feature Muslim characters, “answers basic questions on the issue and also aims to dispel the doubts on CAA and NRC that it is in any way against the Indian Muslim citizens,” as a senior BJP official told the media.

one response:

1 user has voted.