Cuomo: "6,300 nursing home deaths are a political charade

The hubris and arrogance of Cuomo's statement is unbelievable.

Andrew Cuomo's deadly failures

On March 30, as COVID-19 cases and deaths piled up across the Empire State, and the USS Comfort arrived to calm a broken city, Gov. Andrew Cuomo called New York the “canary in the coal mine” of the U.S. coronavirus crisis. “What you see us going through here, you will see happening all across this country.”

Except it didn’t.

Instead, New York racked up massive coronavirus deaths, as the governor’s policies (as well as those of Mayor Bill de Blasio) left New Yorkers exposed. The rest of the country suffered losses, but nowhere near the intensely high number reached by New York.

The story of Cuomo’s role in the pandemic has been massaged by the media. And, indeed, Cuomo’s “just the facts” press conferences were initially soothing at a time of confusion and disarray. His Powerpoint presentations, blessedly boring during a tumultuous time, often began with what day it was, a feature appreciated by people in a seemingly permanent Groundhog Day in their homes. One of the slides invariably included raw numbers of how many had been diagnosed, how many were in the hospital, and how many had died. But as the smoke began to clear, it’s become increasingly obvious that the governor’s bad decisions, petty rivalries, and general incompetence caused much of the destruction in the first place.

The major story of the coronavirus epidemic in New York is how the governor’s policies toward long-term care facilities enabled the virus to run rampant among our most vulnerable population. In late April, it came to light that the previous month, the state ordered long-term care facilities to readmit residents who had been treated for the coronavirus. New residents who were “medically stable” were to be admitted as well. Thus did Cuomo’s New York guarantee that the most vulnerable population would be widely exposed to COVID-19 in environments that enabled its quick and deadly spread.

The official tally has about 20% of New York coronavirus deaths attributed to nursing homes, but we actually can’t be certain of how many people died because of this negligence. If someone from one of these mass-infected nursing homes died in a hospital, it’s not counted as a nursing home death. There’s also evidence that many of those who died at nursing homes weren’t tested for COVID-19, so the official statistic remains a question mark, but it’s almost certainly higher, perhaps much higher, than the state admits.
....
He also shrugs off blame and argues that “nobody” should be held accountable for the nursing home deaths: “How do we get justice for those families? Who can we prosecute for those deaths? Nobody. Mother Nature, God, where did this virus come from? People are going to die by this virus. That is the truth.”

During Cuomo’s April 23 press conference, the governor was defiant about his mandate, saying: “[The nursing homes] don’t have a right to object. That is the rule and that is the regulation, and they have to comply with that. If they can’t do it, we’ll put them in a facility that can do it.” It was a crass death sentence for countless New Yorkers. The nursing homes, understaffed and with minimal personal protective equipment, didn’t stand a chance. During his May 18 press conference, Cuomo was asked about the elder-care experts’ claims that even before COVID-19, New York state had one of the lowest levels of care in nursing homes and lax health enforcement. Does the state deserve some blame? Cuomo completely dismissed the question.

Cuomo has given nursing homes immunity from prosecution for not providing staff and patients with PPE which caused people to get infected. How is this possible? You would be surprised at how congress has lowered the standards of treatment for nursing homes because of course their lobbyists.

But of course there is more. Of course there is.

On March 17, de Blasio told New Yorkers to prepare to “shelter in place,” an order to stay home except for essential needs, similar to what had been implemented in northern California. That night, Cuomo smacked that down as impossible before implementing essentially the same guidelines in his PAUSE order three days later.

On April 2, de Blasio announced a new recommendation to wear masks in public. At a press conference the next day, Cuomo questioned the need for them before reversing himself less than two weeks later.

On April 11, the mayor announced that schools would remain closed for the rest of the school year. The governor was quick to jump in and say no decision had been made, arrogantly saying of de Blasio: “He didn’t close them, and he can’t open them.” On May 1, Cuomo was forced to concede the schools are indeed staying closed.

When Cuomo announced New York beaches were allowed to open, de Blasio quickly said New York City’s shores would not. The whole point of this kind of coordination was so no state opens ahead of another one and causes people to travel for goods and services. With New York City beaches not allowing swimming, New Jersey, Long Island, and Connecticut beaches braced for a wave of New Yorkers, with some beaches changing their rules to allow only their own residents onto their beaches.
....
The rivalry is also obvious in Cuomo’s limited consideration of New York City. On May 7, New York City finally suspended 24-hour subway service to disinfect train cars overnight. The fact that the trains, which fall under the governor’s purview, weren’t already being cleaned and disinfected, months into the pandemic, was shocking. As of May 1, 98 Metropolitan Transportation Authority workers had died from the coronavirus, more than any other state or city agency. A March 6 memo to MTA employees addressed the question of masks, noting, “Masks are not medically necessary as a protection against COVID-I9, and not part of the authorized uniform. They should not be worn by employees during work hours.” An outcry forced the MTA to permit transit employees to wear their own masks a week later. It would be weeks before the MTA would give out masks to its workers. Following in the governor’s footsteps, MTA Chairman Pat Foye blames the CDC and the World Health Organization for their directives saying masks are unnecessary. But there’s a vast gulf between saying that masks aren’t needed and prohibiting employees from wearing them. In Cuomo’s New York, no one takes any blame, and the buck doesn’t stop with the governor.

I bet you are thinking that the media will hold him accountable for his actions right? Think again. They have been covering his daily press conferences and some have gone as far as propping him up to replace Biden as presidential nominee if Biden continues to fail.

All of this has gone largely ignored by the media. They need a neat narrative and have widely decided that Cuomo is the hero, while DeSantis is the villain. But by all indications, DeSantis has done a far better job.

His shtick with his brother, who famously broke quarantine while actually sick with COVID-19, is one of the more noxious examples of the media’s complacency when covering the New York governor. Obviously, the governor’s brother lobs him softballs, if that, but other media outlets don’t do much better.

Cuomo is a gaffe machine, but the press are uninterested. He has blamed the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, “experts,” and others for how hard COVID-19 has hit his state. “Where were all the experts? Where was the New York Times, where was the Wall Street Journal, where was all the bugle blowers who should say, ‘Be careful, there’s a virus in China that may be in the United States?’ That was in November, December.” New York Times Metro Editor Jorge Arangure responded on Twitter: “From Jan. 9 to March 1, the date the NY state government finally took the coronavirus threat seriously, the New York Times had more than 450 stories about the coronavirus.”

52% of people have said that they won’t be able to pay their mortgages or rent next month. Surely congress will get off their asses and get help to us to keep the economy from tanking any further right? Ha...of course not.

This is going to go on and on and on, made worse by the fact that the Federal Reserve and Congress have chosen to bail out the rich and give peanuts to everyone else. Riots and protests will continue, because why not? People don’t have enough money, are going to lose their housing, the jobs to go back to don’t exist. Provocations which before were barely tolerable now set off firestorms.

The rich don’t care: they were scared at first, because a lot of them got infected in the first wave. Rich people have a lot of social contacts and travel a lot, BUT now that they know there’s a problem, they can self-isolate and protect themselves, and if they do get sick they receive the best care. Most poor people can’t self-isolate: they live in group housing, their jobs are often physical and usually put them around other people.

So there’s little incentive for Covid-19 to be handled properly: the rich are fine and pretty much safe, they just have to stay home a lot, in their big houses and multi-bedroom condominiums. They’re fine financially. What happens to other Americans is of little concern to them, so why not make them go back to work?

Something like a quarter to a third of small businesses are likely to be destroyed by this crisis. Whatever’s worth buying will be bought up for cents on the dollar by the rich, and they’ll consolidate further control over US real-estate.

Crises are good if you have cash money, and the rich are salivating. Let this drag out, let them take further advantage.
...
Understand that this is a chosen fiasco. All that was required was reasonable subsidies, a moratorium on rent, mortgage and other loan payments, track and trace, mandatory masks and shelter in place orders.

Once your lords and masters realized they were mostly safe, they stopped caring about the crisis. Some states dealt with it acceptably, but on a national level, this is a totally forseeable, and thus essentially planned clusterfuck.

It’s you, or your elites. Until you remove them from power, by whatever means necessary, they will kill you and let you die whenever it is convenient to them, or just inconvenient to keep you around. (You may have thought it was only brown foreigners like Iraqis they were willing to kill hundreds of thousands of. Wrong.)

h/t joe shikspack

It’s obvious that rich people don’t give a rat’s ass about us and that includes congress because they are also filthy rich after decades of insider trading and getting rewarded by their donors. Gawd help us all because things are going to get ugly. Fast.

Share
up
25 users have voted.

Comments

mimi's picture

that it was Europe, who brought the virus to NY. Ok, fits the picture. They want their war with Europe. I won't even listen to this BS. They will get their war and corona will speak justice. There are not enough bunkers for people to hide and kill themselves in it.

I haven't read much lately, just scanned. All I want to say is that I have huge respect for the many courageous black people in the United States, who fight so bravely.

Thank you Snoopy, it is hard for a person like me on the outside, to follow the news. I guess I will die before I read it all. Stay safe and healthy. I think we are on the brink of losing it all.

I promise to read it more thoroughly when I have time. So far I am busy to make sure I don't get sick.

Don't get sick, if you can manage it.I wish all the good people in the US to survive, fight and win over that gawd-awful empire of rich oligarchs.

up
5 users have voted.

The truth, on the other hand, is invisible and incomprehensible. That is almost certainly by design by the same folks who are lying so energetically.

The quoted article properly debunks the absurdity of Cuomo's decisions as Health Czar, but then extrapolates from his arrogant folly to "rich people," as though Cuomo was not just one Blue Governor from an extraordinarily corrupt state but also an emblem for the entire establishment. Maybe so. But nothing in this particular article supports that idea, and much of it contradicts it as New York has had the worst experience with the virus of any place on earth. It seems far more likely to me that Cuomo is just an arrogant jerkoff who made several stupid decisions and now is using the main stream media's anti-Trump obsession to divert attention from his own hideous errors.

Although I personally have to scratch my chin about some of the bizarre shit coming from various power centers, I still do not buy the idea that "rich people" are responsible for the ludicrous hodge-podge of policies, directives and random bullshit that we have seen from the Feds, the states, the counties, the cities and the multiplicity of alphabet "health" bureaucracies. Incompetence, hidden agendas and lunacy riddle our utterly corrupt society (that lives on debt and makes war for no other reason than that the guys who sell weapons want to make money). But three plus months into this nightmare, I still don't see a logical motive for killing customers.

Yeah, I have seen the argument made here and many other venues that a wave of evictions, defaults and bankruptcies will enable "rich people" to buy up "assets" very "cheaply." Well, how are you going to make any money off of apartments and small businesses if nobody can afford anything? I can see greed going on autopilot in the middle of this shit -- but creating a generation of unemployables does not make any sense.

Who knows anything for sure now? For what it's worth, my opinion is that we are witnessing the internal collapse of our society. Nobody is really in charge in our Neoliberal Paradise of Profit. The dreaded gov-a-ment that Reagan decried as something to get off our backs has been undermined in a thousand different ways for the last 40 years and now NOTHING works. We saw the first example of this when Katrina flooded the city of New Orleans and civilization abandoned the area for several weeks -- because there was nothing significant the government could do if it tried.

I don't think it was possible for any kind of coherent strategy for resisting the virus to be implemented in our bureaucratic dystopia. Instead, we have lots of television shows, usually on at noon -- some of which get good reviews, as did Cuomo. Of course those reviews are utterly disconnected from the actual fight against death and disease. The media's infatuation with the Governor of the State hit hardest -- not just within the USA, but in the world -- proves that.

Keep in mind that the national media is clearly puffing up Cuomo as Biden's replacement if that becomes necessary. The media industry in this country is at the heart of our corruption.

Thanks for this essay. It encourages the discussion of Why rather than just What. I hope I am wrong about my take about how our government is more like The Keystone Kops than The Third Reich. You can fight the Nazis. But against stupidity, the gods themselves contend in vain.

up
6 users have voted.

I cried when I wrote this song. Sue me if I play too long.

It's plain inhumane. Die Quickly seems to be the one-size-fits-all modern solution to everything.

I thought we had it bad here. Ontario currently has the Canadian military in care homes providing direct care to the older adults and seniors in care. Under-paid and precariously employed staff like Personal Support Workers were largely missed in considerations for government-funded COVID-19 extra pay and many private care facilities didn't have enough/any PPE available, so many of them said "see ya!" and walked. Enter the military (paid for by taxpayers, naturally, because why should privately-run care homes pay for staffing and equipment, amirite). The Conservative premier Doug Ford was all ruffled and upset when the soldiers were not quietly outraged by what they found almost everywhere: starving, sedated people sitting in their own shit in roach-infested squalor. Then Ford tamped down on his reaction when called out to answer if he knew and understood that the Conservative party, his party, was in power and made the decision to privatize long-term care in the 1990s. This has almost completely disappeared from public view though after it was further reported that one of the/if not the biggest long-term care home company (Revera) is a wholly owned subsidiary of Public Sector Pension Investments, a Canadian Crown corporation that invests funds for the pension plans of federal public servants, Canadian Forces personnel and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. Whoops! Hiding in plain sight was that Canada's public servants get fat pensions off the suffering and neglect of older adults and seniors for decades. Some pushback to change is allegedly underway, but we'll see. It's not that no one knew, it's that they didn't care.

up
8 users have voted.
snoopydawg's picture

@Le Frog

and of course a national shame, but when money is more important than people's lives what should we expect? It is sad to hear that the neglect happens in Canada too. Any word on how the military is doing its job?

Under-paid and precariously employed staff like Personal Support Workers were largely missed in considerations for government-funded COVID-19 extra pay and many private care facilities didn't have enough/any PPE available,

Paying people the lowest wages possible while having them take on high case loads for patients is another crime in my opinion. Through the years I spent lots of times witnessing the appalling conditions in nursing homes starting over 40 years ago and just a decade ago I was visiting them again and the situation and environment had gotten even worse.

Nursing homes all over the country were derelict in not providing PPE for staff or taking every step to protect patients from getting infected. Except for Washington state that did seem to get its act together once word got out about how things were in the one that was the hotspot. The rest of the country had plenty of time to act. They did not. Cuomo should be brought up on charges for what he allowed to happen, but that doesn't happen in the shithole 3rd world country anymore. The media should have been hounding him for this until it got fixed, but instead they propped him up as doing what Trump should have been the whole time. I am still ticked that Trump alone gets blamed for every damn death in this country while Cuomo gets a break. A DK writer tried to give Cuomo a pass for what he did but many members were not having it. Trump derangement syndrome strikes again. Yes Trump should have responded differently, but here is the evidence that Cuomo was screwing up just as badly. As did many other governors.

I posted this last night and it should be a crime for them to just dump people in homeless shelters and elsewhere and not notifying families that they did that.

They just dumped him like a piece of trash

Here is one more. You can be forgiven for not clicking on the links for wanting to be spared what you read in these 2 articles, but then you might want to bear witness.

Horrendous : Medicare Mills and Nursing Home Nightmares

It makes me sick and heartbroken that the elderly are seen as less than if they end up in nursing homes and treated as less than human. Not all, but far too many of them. What this does to my soul and my heart......

up
6 users have voted.

Which AIPAC/MIC/pharma/bank bought politician are you going to vote for? Don’t be surprised when nothing changes.

@snoopydawg PSWs in Ontario make around $15/hour, which is a dollar above minimum wage in the province, so off the bat, no one is falling over themselves to get into this line of work. The majority of PSWs work for an agency on contract, meaning their work assignment locations change all the time, work assignments aren't steady, they have to travel a lot for their work (and this is never 100% covered as an incurred work expense), and the list goes on. I heard from someone who worked in healthcare funding that PSW turnover is over 50% annually (I believe regionally but may have been provincially), so one of the solutions to this from some out-of-touch suit from the executive brain trust was for volunteers to fill in the gaps. Can't pay people to do work, so find people to do it for free (and never mind that that costs money to arrange and manage) does not seem like it's destined for success.

As far as I know, the military members are carrying on okay but I'm glad that no one sees it as an acceptable or viable solution even on a shorter basis. The labour shortages for direct care staff are dire right now, and if not for soldiers, no one would be looking after the thousands of vulnerable and sick people in long-term care. I hope that this is a stinging slap to the face to a lot of people that high quality care will never be delivered on the backs of people making poverty wages or in an environment that measures success with profits.

up
5 users have voted.