Corruption and the Housing Affordability Crisis

According to a nationwide survey, nearly three out of four American households believe the country is facing a housing affordability crisis.
They are right to think that. The NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Opportunity Index shows that by the third quarter of 2018, the index had plummeted to 56, meaning only 56% of home sales were affordable.
There is a direct link between escalating housing prices and homelessness.

The usual solutions that get offered is that government should ease regulatory requirements and/or provide incentives to build more housing, but that fails to answer the question of what made things so bad to begin with.

Low-cost rental housing also is becoming increasingly hard to find. While renters’ median housing costs rose by 11% between 2001 and 2016, their incomes fell by 2%, according to Harvard University’s Joint Center for Housing Research.

The reason for this rental and housing affordability crisis isn't because of regular people and environmentalists preventing progress.
The actual reason for this rental and housing affordability crisis is because of wealth inequality, financial corruption, and a parasitical economic system.

While rental prices are at record highs, housing vacancies are also near record highs.

The number of unoccupied homes jumped by 26 percent—from 9.5 to 12 million between 2005 and 2010...
The number of vacant units has declined over the course of the recovery, but there are still more today than there were before 2005. Housing units that are considered temporarily vacant—that are neither on the market, being held for future occupancy, or being used seasonally—have increased by more than 50 percent, from 3.7 million in 2005 to 5.8 million in 2016.

vacancy.jpg

More empty houses should force down prices, but that's not happening.
The only logical reason why this could be true is if the home owners simply aren't interested in living in, renting, or selling those houses.
Those owners must also be wealthy, and Wall Street is part of the problem.

No less an entity than the U.N. is wading into the U.S. housing affordability crisis. In a pair of letters to the U.S. government and Blackstone Group, Leilani Farha, the UN Special Rapporteur on the right to adequate housing, calls out the role of private equity in the housing market and blasts the federal government for failing to protect the right of people to housing.

Blackstone, the world's largest private-equity fund, also owns the largest single-family rental operation in the U.S. through its Invitation Homes unit. It's not the only private equity firm to invest in housing, but Blackstone's large size and concentration in a few metro areas has made it a dominant player in the rental market, where "it is having devastating consequences for tenants," the letter said.

"Blackstone's and its subsidiaries' business model is pushing low-income, and increasingly middle-income people from their homes," the rapporteur wrote. Among the tactics it ascribes to Blackstone, drawing on news reports, are purchasing housing for low-income renters and deeming it "undervalued," renovating it, dramatically increasing the rent and forcing out residents if they can't pay. Farha also cites the addition of processing fees, automatic late fees and "immediate" eviction notices if tenants are late with payments.

The proportion of residential rental properties owned by individuals and families has fallen from 92% in 1991 to 74% in 2015.
While it's tempting to blame Wall Street and stop there, the lion's share of the blame is further afield. To give you a good example of this let's start at the top.

President Trump's real estate sales have gotten much more secretive since he won the Republican nomination in 2016, with the majority of buyers now using limited liability companies to hide to-be owners' names, a USA Today investigation has found. In the two years before Trump was nominated, just 4 percent of buyers used shell companies to make purchases; in the year that followed, and throughout Trump's first year in office, that rate jumped all the way to 70 percent.

What is going on is classic money laundering.

All-cash transactions have come to account for a quarter of all residential real estate purchases, “totaling hundreds of billions of dollars nationwide,” the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network – the financial crimes unit of the federal Treasury Department, also known as FinCEN – noted in a 2017 news release. Thanks to the Bank Secrecy Act, a 1970 anti-money-laundering law, the agency is able to learn who owns many of these properties. In high-cost cities such as New York, San Francisco, Los Angeles and Miami, it’s flagged over 30% of cash purchases as suspicious transactions.

It looks suspicious because it is suspicious.
That's not my opinion. All-cash purchases through anonymous shell companies is suspicious to regulators too.

Selection_001_18.png

That headline leads you to believe that the regulators have the situation under control.
The problem is that one year later we see the EXACT SAME HEADLINE.

Selection_002_17.png

To sum this up, we have massive fraud going on in real estate, where prices are at record highs, while regulators decline to enforce the law.
Gee, where have I heard that before?

Share
up
23 users have voted.

Comments

a prime place for money laundering, but also a tax haven for foreign investors. You afraid of xenophobia? Wait till people learn how much foreign actors (legal and illegal) are taking advantage of the housing crisis.

up
23 users have voted.

On to Biden since 1973

Lookout's picture

My thought is they all have their fingers in the pie and don't want us to know. Printing money, giving it to corporations that use it to buy their own stock, driving the market to ridiculous levels. What a ponzi top to bottom. But like all ponzis, it will come tumbling down. The question is when.

Real estate hustles (emoluments) was always the way to impeachment with Trump...just the misuse of his DC hotel...not to mention Mar-a-lago. But the dimwitted dims are guilty too. Like the $hill's 10 M from Ukraine, and Kerry's nephew getting the same sweetheart Burisma deal as Hunter. The corruption is deep and foul.

up
21 users have voted.

“Until justice rolls down like water and righteousness like a mighty stream.”

snoopydawg's picture

@Lookout

Where the players have gotten so corrupt and have shucked all the rules designed to keep them from becoming corrupt. This was just a game for the 4,of us that did it, but it comes with real life consequences for that are doing it now.

....
blasts the federal government for failing to protect the right of people to housing.

Hell it was the government that put blackstone in the position to do this. This goes back to when Obama asked them to buy up all the vacant houses and to get them off the market. It took over a decade to see the damage Clinton did to us. We saw it while Obama was still in office.

Bernie was interviewed about the homeless crisis and his plan is to build 10 million low income housing. Utah just sold an old movie theater for $1 to let a company build apartments. They only had to make 1% of them affordable for low income. Sweet deal! Oh yeah. Utah is raising taxes on food and gas while lowering it for corporations and people who make over a certain amount. Guess who this is going to hurt the most? Low income people. Of course. But there are two referendums, but we know how they feel when we overwhelmingly vote for something. Like they can just ignore us. Bastards!

up
22 users have voted.

Was Humpty Dumpty pushed?

link

Almost $1.5 trillion of the world's cash, with U.S. $100 bills making up a great deal of it, is reportedly unaccounted for. So what happened to the money?

"Literally, a lot of these $100 bills are sitting in bank vaults all over the world," Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin told FOX Business' Lou Dobbs during an interview on Tuesday.

Mnuchin pointed to the negative interest rates causing people to turn to American dollars as a solid investment.

up
9 users have voted.

like taxing second homes at a higher rate, and third homes even higher. Or taxing anything over 2,000 feet per person in residence. Almost every time I take my kids places they see homeless, people who sleep outside. Not sure we are doing very well as a society when we allow that.

I got a contract once to work on part of a new build that was affordable housing. All the people moving in made more than me, professionals. I think affordable meant their income had to be under 75K or something. Duplexes, beautiful, in a good part of town too. Affordable would be something to get people off the street. I rented a room in New Orleans in 78 or something for $14 a week. Triple it for today's dollars and it would be affordable. Gets down in the teens here at night.

up
10 users have voted.
janis b's picture

@ban nock

Here in NZ, we don’t even have a capital gains tax on the primary home, when many even have a secondary one. It’s an awful situation for most millennials here. My best friend’s daughter and partner have been trying to buy a home of their own in West Auckland for over a year. It’s nearly impossible, even for a couple who are both employed.

up
11 users have voted.

@ban nock
Say I have a house that's 2200 square feet (I do). It's OK until I die then my widow gets taxed up the wazoo for being "rich", like my Social Security is taxed because I'm "rich", i.e. I don't have to eat dog food.

This kind of talk is what turns working people against the Left.

up
4 users have voted.

I've seen lots of changes. What doesn't change is people. Same old hairless apes.

Dawn's Meta's picture

@The Voice In the Wilderness taxed the first time around, when it was earned. This is another 'income' tax on cashing in the savings account. Bah humbug.

up
7 users have voted.

A society grows great when old men plant trees in whose shade they know they shall never sit. Allegedly Greek, but more possibly fairly modern quote.

Consider helping by donating using the button in the upper left hand corner. Thank you.

@Dawn's Meta
I recognize that it must be taxed, but why does it count as income for Senior property tax relief and SS taxation? It's a drain of assets, not an increase of assets.

I advise my descendants to ignore conventional IRA's and also 401K's unless they have matching, which is genuine income. Take you match and invest your other free cash into a Roth vehicle. You will wish you had when you retire. My 401K saved me 24 to 26% when I was working. Now, even with the lower brackets, I pay 22% on withdrawals because of the extra taxation of SS that it causes.

up
4 users have voted.

I've seen lots of changes. What doesn't change is people. Same old hairless apes.

@The Voice In the Wilderness

Take you match and invest your other free cash into a Roth vehicle. You will wish you had when you retire. My 401K saved me 24 to 26% when I was working. Now, even with the lower brackets, I pay 22% on withdrawals because of the extra taxation of SS that it causes.

In addition, I expect at some point the government is going to raise taxes on 401k and IRA income.

up
6 users have voted.

@gjohnsit

up
4 users have voted.

I've seen lots of changes. What doesn't change is people. Same old hairless apes.